Welcome Sam Banks | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Welcome Sam Banks

Looks like Banks performance today has come under scrutiny.

Personally I wouldn’t be dropping him after one performance. We need to give these kids a decent block of games first before making any calls.

There are older players who need to go before the likes of Banks.
Banksy’s competitive efforts are a real worry. Strikes me as though throughout his juniors he was just the receiver and was never asked to get his hands dirty. Play him in middle at VFL or as lock down back pocket so can learn how to earn a hardball or man up
 
I still feel ralpsmith has more upside than this guy, i think 4 or 5 weeks time we will see ralph in the seniors yes he has his limitations but hes a hard runner and competes 10 times harder than this bloke
 
We could see West Coast reaching for outside fringe HB flanker talent over the next few years :cool:
 
  • Love
Reactions: 1 user
Looks like Banks performance today has come under scrutiny.

Personally I wouldn’t be dropping him after one performance. We need to give these kids a decent block of games first before making any calls.

There are older players who need to go before the likes of Banks.

most definitely.

when your flag window is closed, youngsters have to be given a decent crack at proving their worth
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Read back even one page and there is plenty of praise for him late last season.
Has one game in 2024 and he is suddenly hopeless.
This place still amazes me at times
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 13 users
Youngsters need to have basic non negotiable core attributes in the first place. Massive selection error by Clarke.
 
Banks'y was disappointing yesterday but this kid is a footballer and will come good

He will make it i have no doubt
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Very vanilla for me, so far. Prefer others.
Hasnt shown anything others havent.

McAuliffe, Green,, Jud, Coulthard I'd prefer to see.

Tigers need effort players and contest players.

McAuliffe and Trezise are2 juniors who bring contested footy and effort.

We may see them both sooner rather than later.
 
Read back even one page and there is plenty of praise for him late last season.
Has one game in 2024 and he is suddenly hopeless.
This place still amazes me at times
How long do you persist though? Hasn’t really shown anything of note at AFL level in seven games. I know it’s a small sample but the player has to do their part too and show something, anything worth persevering with.

AFL games are precious especially when developing youth and at this stage I’d rather we invest those games in someone else besides Banks.
 
Read back even one page and there is plenty of praise for him late last season.
Has one game in 2024 and he is suddenly hopeless.
This place still amazes me at times
Amaze isn’t the word I'd use.
 
I still feel ralpsmith has more upside than this guy, i think 4 or 5 weeks time we will see ralph in the seniors yes he has his limitations but hes a hard runner and competes 10 times harder than this bloke
HRS may run faster, with his golden locks flowing the in the breeze.

but

Turnover merchant and, from my limited viewing, doesn't compete hard at all!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Read back even one page and there is plenty of praise for him late last season.
Has one game in 2024 and he is suddenly hopeless.
This place still amazes me at times

not writing him off Sin,

but rather than the number of bad games, its more the nature of the bad game that I judge.

much like umpiring decisions, its so much the how many are paid, as where they are paid.

its what makes Seth Campbells moment so exciting - the nature of the moments.

we were down and out, all at sea, bereft,

when the kid had his moment.

ive watched Sam a few times at VFL level, and he's always struck me as a bit confused.

he can still overcome that,

but I reckon he should have by now.

we are gonna turn over at least 50 footballers between now and when we are competitive (Top 4) again I reckon.

I reckon im gonna be looking at 'em through a bit of a different lens

and I make sincere apologies for that
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user