Trade Week - Richmond Only

[taztiger4]

Gave up 32, 42, 43 & 45 = 1804 points

Received pick 20 = 912 points

Head scratching as to why we paid so much, no other team came close to having the points we could offer.

On face value we well and truly overpaid

1704

 

[Harry]

Is this for real? We traded 1,704 points for 912? Blair is a push over.

 

[Findthenextdusty]

We didn't give them pick 24.

We weren't the only ones after pick 20. Calm down.

No we didn’t but had we held reasonably firm we might have been able to get a pick from next year from them, after that trade gws are now in best position to do that , seems we were very generous with them, it seems rare that clubs are generous with us

 

[Rancey18]

Seems like a lot to give up at face value. Not sure on points but wonder if we could have given our later picks instead and kept 32?

 

[Ripplestick]

1704

View attachment 24595

Thanks, guess my mental arithmetic ability ain't what it used to be.

 

[Findthenextdusty]

Seems like a lot to give up at face value. Not sure on points but wonder if we could have given our later picks instead and kept 32?

That would have been my preference for sure

 

[taztiger4]

smart cookie is our Blair, revist this trade @ COB next Wednesday before passing judgement

 

[Tigers of Old]

We don’t know what the entirety of the conversations were..

 

[Harry]

Can't understand this trade. We've handed them a free passage for Ashcroft and have given away all of our points which could have been used in other trades and even on draft night. Big question marks over Blair for mine. Brisbane are laughing. Watch Blair crumble in the other trades.

 

[Harry]

smart cookie is our Blair, revist this trade @ COB next Wednesday before passing judgement

smart cookie? He got reamed.

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

Too much. We were in charge. We had the upper hand. Give us pick 20 otherwise we are bidding on Ashcroft.
Why 4 picks?? Shouldve been a hand full of picks after 40+ at best.

 

[taztiger4]

still holding the below & no player trades as yet




Thats 5130 points, about what we started with ? & moved up 12 spots at least

 

[Harry]

Seems like a lot to give up at face value. Not sure on points but wonder if we could have given our later picks instead and kept 32?

there was no need to give pick 32. 42 43 45 were more than enough (even too much)

 

[Harry]

This has just *smile* up our trade period. Had my doubts on blair and this confirms it

 

[The_General]

We had competition for Pick 20.
We weren't going to use all those picks.

There's no point dealing with us if they get back exactly what they gave us. We basically gave up 4 meh picks, and got a good one back.

Those picks would be lucky to get 1 player to play 100 games.
We got a pick back that gives us the chance to get someone who'll get more , given the depth of the draft.

Good work Blair

 

[tigersnake]

Can't understand this trade.

Bunch of lesser value picks for one higher value pick? Pretty straightforward

 

[taztiger4]

smart cookie? He got reamed.

we got pick 20, who else was after it ?

the market dictates what we pay not Harry

 

[Harry]

Gold Coast and Essendon need points. Could have used the picks as sweeteners in the Bolton, Rioli and Baker trades. Blair has just dropped his pants.

 

[Rancey18]

still holding the below & no player trades as yet


View attachment 24596

Thats 5130 points, about what we started with ? & moved up 12 spots at least

We started with 5922 I think so not quite what we started with. Turns out Pick 76 has no points value it seems.

 

[Harry]

We are always the good guys during trade week giving overs and accepting unders. Blair is a push over.