I would be trying to get North , Bombers and saints in that order and all 3 if possible
How many picks do you want to move to next year?
I would be trying to get North , Bombers and saints in that order and all 3 if possible
I'd probably push it back to you the other way. Why would Essendon do that trade? Pretty much a likely top 10, maybe top 5 pick, for pick 23 or 24 in this years draft.
I think there is a lot of over estimating of what we will get with our later picks, we won't be getting top 10 picks next year unless someone completely craps the bed that you are expecting to make finals.
The best chance IMO of getting a top draft pick in next years draft is this deal with Norths, otherwise its likely to be mid to late firsts next year 11-18 for our 23-24 this year (possibly with some late pick exchange to make it a bit more in our favour).
If we want a top 10 draft pick next year, we will be needing to give up a lot more than Pick 20
Maybe. Thing is this draft is very even.
Take specific clubs out of it for this example. At say our pick 23, in this draft there will likely be teams that will have guys ranked at say 12 on their internal rankings still available. They will trade for 23 and be happy to give up collateral up to that internal mark to get that pick.
i.e. they will see it as getting pick 12 in. Not 23.
Combine that with it being viewed as a strong draft (pick 12 this year > equivalent in 25') we might well get more than most think.
I don't doubt that, and said the same above, we are dealing in picks around 11-18 in 2025 for Pick 20 (23 or 24 in reality) but thats a fair way short of a top 10 pick.
Whats better?
6, 11 and losing 20 in this draft
Or 2, future top 5 pick, keep 20 but lose 11?
We could still potentially trade out Pick 20 or 23 if we got ripping offers in, but I don't see anyone offering up what North are apparently offering up. If Essendon want to get back into this draft, they may offer up their 1st (they won't offer up Melbournes IMO) but they will want more than Pick 20, probably at least 2 of those early 20's picks, we may still like that, but its still not the equivalent offer we are being provided by North.
Its not often that these scenarios pop up, where the benefit to both clubs is largely equal. With the age of their mids (I think there is a real chance they know they are losing LDU), but need to get the young forwards in to complement the Sheezel, Wardlaw, McKercher, Powell group and they have a real opportunity to get that this year, another year down and those players continue to get older, the talls won't hit their straps for 3-4 years at their best, so I think North know they have to strike now and it has to be talls. If LDU leaves next year, they add another mid then.
For us, it has a great chance of supercharging our rebuild.
Doesn't mean we couldn't do the other trades if we think they are valuable enough.
we will see ...I'd probably push it back to you the other way. Why would Essendon do that trade? Pretty much a likely top 10, maybe top 5 pick, for pick 23 or 24 in this years draft.
I think there is a lot of over estimating of what we will get with our later picks, we won't be getting top 10 picks next year unless someone completely craps the bed that you are expecting to make finals.
The best chance IMO of getting a top draft pick in next years draft is this deal with Norths, otherwise its likely to be mid to late firsts next year 11-18 for our 23-24 this year (possibly with some late pick exchange to make it a bit more in our favour).
If we want a top 10 draft pick next year, we will be needing to give up a lot more than Pick 20
3 would be greatHow many picks do you want to move to next year?
Did ya double check to make sure they're first night tickets n not second night?have secured tickets to draft night at punt road
So you'd want to cut our draft hand down to 1 - 2 - 10 - 18 - 20 for this year. Reckon that's way to skinny for what we need and the evenness of this years draft.3 would be great
Ideally #2 + F1 North for #6 + #11
#23 for Bombers
#24 fir St Kilda , Geelong , Hawks
3 mids and 2 kpp and take another either psd or RookieSo you'd want to cut our draft hand down to 1 - 2 - 10 - 18 - 20 for this year. Reckon that's way to skinny for what we need and the evenness of this years draft.
I want at least 6 this year. Lots of spots to fix. Deep draft year's the time to do it. Unless we're getting 3 inside the top 8 next year, I'm not big on trading too many out.So you'd want to cut our draft hand down to 1 - 2 - 10 - 18 - 20 for this year. Reckon that's way to skinny for what we need and the evenness of this years draft.
Sounds great, but I'm not sure you'd advance picks 23 n 24 into the early picks of next years draft. Reckon clubs would want some large sweeteners to risk a pick around 6 to 12 next year for 23 or 24 this year. Doubt there'd be anything more valuable lateish first round next year than late first round this year.3 mids and 2 kpp and take another either psd or Rookie
Sam Davidson would be nice to get
5 1st rounders this year and 4 next years
how do you buy them?have secured tickets to draft night at punt road
I got an email with an RSVP but there is an email contacthow do you buy them?
Looked on website cannot find a link
My feeling is that if we do any trading of picks pre draft it will only be for North's pick 2 and I have no idea if we will do that. You would suspect the deal will have to be a good one.Sounds great, but I'm not sure you'd advance picks 23 n 24 into the early picks of next years draft. Reckon clubs would want some large sweeteners to risk a pick around 6 to 12 next year for 23 or 24 this year. Doubt there'd be anything more valuable lateish first round next year than late first round this year.
Sounds great, but I'm not sure you'd advance picks 23 n 24 into the early picks of next years draft. Reckon clubs would want some large sweeteners to risk a pick around 6 to 12 next year for 23 or 24 this year. Doubt there'd be anything more valuable lateish first round next year than late first round this year.
Only almost certain chance yes.This is the way I see it. The only chance of getting a top 10 pick next year is Norths offer IMO