Dyer'ere said:Not if they're playing the other song! ;D
Visions of Melbourne "supporters" and Jordan McMahon's goal.
Dyer'ere said:Not if they're playing the other song! ;D
Wildride said:Well, Buddy and Tippett each got 1 week with a guilty plea, and Gordon's incident was viewed as a non-reportable offense. Reckon Buddy is lucky, should've been classed as intentional and 2 weeks with a guilty plea.
Bowerpower said:Kingy would have got life
Wildride said:Well, Buddy and Tippett each got 1 week with a guilty plea, and Gordon's incident was viewed as a non-reportable offense. Reckon Buddy is lucky, should've been classed as intentional and 2 weeks with a guilty plea.
artball said:1 week is absurd. do you have to get properly injured?
Wildride said:Well, Buddy and Tippett each got 1 week with a guilty plea, and Gordon's incident was viewed as a non-reportable offense. Reckon Buddy is lucky, should've been classed as intentional and 2 weeks with a guilty plea.
joegarra said:In my opinion the injury shouldn't come into it. Whether a player is hurt or not is a matter of mm which the player can't control. What he can control is the action eg going past the ball and lining someone up = 3 weeks in my book. Tackling a player and then slinging him around into the ground potentially causing serious injury = 3 weeks as well (all in my opinion of course). Unless you penalise the act and not the outcome, footballers will keep performing the act and gambling that the outcome isn't severe.
joegarra said:In my opinion the injury shouldn't come into it. Whether a player is hurt or not is a matter of mm which the player can't control. What he can control is the action eg going past the ball and lining someone up = 3 weeks in my book. Tackling a player and then slinging him around into the ground potentially causing serious injury = 3 weeks as well (all in my opinion of course). Unless you penalise the act and not the outcome, footballers will keep performing the act and gambling that the outcome isn't severe.