GoodOne said:He has talent.
Been obvious for a while. I too think he's in our best 22. Think he deserves a chance.
GoodOne said:He has talent.
rokkafella said:kicked a couple out on the full when under little or no pressure.
if you think he's a player that could stand up to finals type of pressure your kidding yourself.
nothing more than a band aid until a better skilled player can be found
bullus_hit said:Building nicely is Ricky, the yips have been largely eliminated and his positive attributes are coming to the fore. I'm especially looking forward to some cameos in the forward line, his versatility will be invaluable down the track.
Tigersub said:Gee, a few on here going with the recycled "therefore a wasted spot on the list" rubbish. Done his business well and will be in next week.
Jason King said:He was close to best on ground on reflection. The amount of times he marked their inside 50, spoilt a contest and then disposed of it and hit his targets was awesome to watch. Not bad for a bloke who has missed a lot of footy.
lamb22 said:Petterd is a bloody good footballer 90% of the time.
Good pace, speed, skills, lateral movement, evasion, leap. Very good at killing an aerial contest third man up.
Where he has had problems in the past is the occasional muddled thinking or error either under real or inferred pressure. The dropped marks against Collingwood (only 2 but you'd think is was 50 by the comments on here)
Also the hit and miss on his kicking and the hesitation at times which leads to poor disposal.
In short I think Petterd is very good in 'continuous' play as his instincts are good. His errors usually show themselves when he overthinks or over worries a situation.
Some of that might be the result of the siege mentality of playing for Melbourne.
I see him as a confidence player. If he really thinks he belongs and takes first options more often he could tear it up in a finals series.
Tigermad2005 said:So what do we do with him next year?
Does he come onto the list or does he stay as a rookie?
No he has just been upgraded for the year.Stylo said:My understanding is he's already on the list along with Stephenson and Lonergan - I don't think we have to spend a pick on upgrading him.