-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Luke McGuane
- Thread starter Tigers of Old
- Start date
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Our backline is gonna look vulnerable.....Astbury & Thursfield/Grimes.
Need Moore back badly.......but don't see him coming back for another 7-8 weeks.
Our backline is gonna look vulnerable.....Astbury & Thursfield/Grimes.
Need Moore back badly.......but don't see him coming back for another 7-8 weeks.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Tigerdog,
I think your last comment was very average, and downright wrong.
I thought McGaune played really well on Reiwoldt tonight.
Unlike many players from both teams, McGuane puts in 100%.
I('m happy to take this up at the next Club80.
Shers.
Tigerdog,
I think your last comment was very average, and downright wrong.
I thought McGaune played really well on Reiwoldt tonight.
Unlike many players from both teams, McGuane puts in 100%.
I('m happy to take this up at the next Club80.
Shers.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
McGuane was crucial in the last seconds and earned us a draw rather than a loss by his positioning and got hte last kick to save the game. HE deserves credit for this. I ahve no problem with his bump. Against the rules but we arent being thrown around like oily rags any more.
McGuane was crucial in the last seconds and earned us a draw rather than a loss by his positioning and got hte last kick to save the game. HE deserves credit for this. I ahve no problem with his bump. Against the rules but we arent being thrown around like oily rags any more.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I've never been a big fan. But this guys couldn't catch a break on this site if it was his smoko and lunch hour combined. He was fantastic tonight.
I've never been a big fan. But this guys couldn't catch a break on this site if it was his smoko and lunch hour combined. He was fantastic tonight.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Fact is we don't have any other player on our list currently who could have done a better job on Roo.
FitenFitenWin said:
Fact is we don't have any other player on our list currently who could have done a better job on Roo.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Really?Rattled Ray enough for Ray to drop a mark in our foward line which resulted in a goal to us.But hey you can go with the rest of the sheep that think Mcguane can,t do anything right. :Tigerbob said:
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Had Nick covered tonight, and thought he had a good game. Still scary with the ball, but his defensive work is excellent.
Will see him in 4-5 weeks I reckon. Particularly with all these concussion issues currently in the media - the AFL will want to respond harshly.
Had Nick covered tonight, and thought he had a good game. Still scary with the ball, but his defensive work is excellent.
Will see him in 4-5 weeks I reckon. Particularly with all these concussion issues currently in the media - the AFL will want to respond harshly.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I say if a player is there to be hit, then hit him.
The quicker St Kilda slides down the ladder the better.
I say if a player is there to be hit, then hit him.
The quicker St Kilda slides down the ladder the better.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I think McGuane is a spud but he did very, very well last night on Nicky. But just to prove that he's not the most intelligent guy around he goes and rubs himself out for the next few weeks.
As previously mentioned still scary when he gets the ball, panics and often handballs to the nearest person without knowing whether they are clear or not.
I think McGuane is a spud but he did very, very well last night on Nicky. But just to prove that he's not the most intelligent guy around he goes and rubs himself out for the next few weeks.
As previously mentioned still scary when he gets the ball, panics and often handballs to the nearest person without knowing whether they are clear or not.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Ray didn't to his credit wimp off the ground but got up and carried on. So yes he is going to go but shouldn't be for that many. Still I didn't expect Rance to go and he got four.
While on shirtfronts did you see Dawson take out Nahas. Dawson almost looked apologetic that Nahas presented himself so cleanly for it. That is the way its supposed to be done.
Ray didn't to his credit wimp off the ground but got up and carried on. So yes he is going to go but shouldn't be for that many. Still I didn't expect Rance to go and he got four.
While on shirtfronts did you see Dawson take out Nahas. Dawson almost looked apologetic that Nahas presented himself so cleanly for it. That is the way its supposed to be done.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
With 10secs to go and any score by the Saints would win them the match.The ball spills towards the Saints goals 15mtrs out with Saints ready to pounce.Who had the sense to stay behind the play and clear it?Yep he,s pretty Dumb.
With 10secs to go and any score by the Saints would win them the match.The ball spills towards the Saints goals 15mtrs out with Saints ready to pounce.Who had the sense to stay behind the play and clear it?Yep he,s pretty Dumb.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Luke had some help from the appalling St Kilda gameplan but he was great last night.
In any sort of even aerial contest he was all over Saint Nick
Luke had some help from the appalling St Kilda gameplan but he was great last night.
In any sort of even aerial contest he was all over Saint Nick
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Yes he is pretty dumb. Never said he wasn't valuable, and I have stuck up for McGuane a lot, but the simple fact he is a dumb footballer. How you can deny that is laughable.
I was happy with his effort and performance on Riewoldt, but take a close look and see that McGuane lacks the fundamental footy smarts. He is still our best tall defender but boy, does he do some really stupid things.
Also there was no need for that hit on Ray, cost himself and us a few weeks and a goal in a game where we drew. Buddy and Roughy and Hale next week, no surprise our two tall defenders are going to be missing for reasons they could of prevented. No surprise both have a negative trait of not being the smartest footballers.
I knwo you have a deep love for him mate, but if you do not think he is a dumb footballer than you quite simply are not paying attention.
Yes he is pretty dumb. Never said he wasn't valuable, and I have stuck up for McGuane a lot, but the simple fact he is a dumb footballer. How you can deny that is laughable.
I was happy with his effort and performance on Riewoldt, but take a close look and see that McGuane lacks the fundamental footy smarts. He is still our best tall defender but boy, does he do some really stupid things.
Also there was no need for that hit on Ray, cost himself and us a few weeks and a goal in a game where we drew. Buddy and Roughy and Hale next week, no surprise our two tall defenders are going to be missing for reasons they could of prevented. No surprise both have a negative trait of not being the smartest footballers.
I knwo you have a deep love for him mate, but if you do not think he is a dumb footballer than you quite simply are not paying attention.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Love the way the term "dumb footballer" is trotted out by the so called experts.
Surely "dumb footballer" is a codition that can't be fixed because it implies some inherent mental deficiency.
Other players who have been labelled "dumb":
Jackson, White and King - to date, our best players this year.
Makes me womder if this dumb labelling is a case of Dumb and Dumber
Love the way the term "dumb footballer" is trotted out by the so called experts.
Surely "dumb footballer" is a codition that can't be fixed because it implies some inherent mental deficiency.
Other players who have been labelled "dumb":
Jackson, White and King - to date, our best players this year.
Makes me womder if this dumb labelling is a case of Dumb and Dumber
<
Changes v Freo
|
The news cycle
>
