Luke McGuane | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Luke McGuane

My apologies Luke.
The Tenacious Curse has struck.
I was quite genuine when I wished you well at the Cocktail Party on Tuesday night and congratulated you on the 100 games.
Keep plugging away son!
 
Was never going to last. A hack is a dud is a hack. Shame we've replaced him with a lazy washed up hack and not the force of nature and future superstar that is McBean.

Having said all that, would rather McGuane our back-up third tall than Edwards next year, though would probably prefer neither remained on the list.
 
Luke McGuane changed. So did the world for him. He was given a chance and didn't take it. He failed. We all do sometimes. He served a purpose while we replaced him.

Funny thing is that if Cale Hooker had been asked to play forward with Muscles on him our man would only have marked, never spoiling.

I won't mind at all if Luke McGuane gets one more game.
 
Like Tivendale and Pettifer before them, Luke and Nahas are the last of the perceived valued trade bait from deluded Tiger fans.

No currency and no interest means no Dom Tyson or Taylor Adams.

Give it up, they will be gone at years end for nothing.
 
Tough game AFL.

As Dyer has pointed out, this puts of lot of eggs in the Vickery basket because he will need to play as a focal point in the forward line, provide defensive pressure and be second ruck.

Who are we playing this week? The team with the best second ruck in the AFL. Welcome to the big time Tyrone.
 
Col.W.Kurtz said:
Dropped before your 100th. Tough game AFL.

II assume your referring to his number of games, of which his milestone passed three weeks ago. I went and congratulated him too on his 100th game, so hoping i didn't look too much like a fool.

Probably needed to be dropped on form, but I think he could find some more form in the 2's and find his way into the team again. I still dont think A Edwards is going to be the answer and i will be interested to see what posters think of his game if its less than satisfactory.

I think we'll see him at least one more time in the Yellow and Black before years end.
 
BT Tiger said:
II assume your referring to his number of games, of which his milestone passed three weeks ago. I went and congratulated him too on his 100th game, so hoping i didn't look too much like a fool.

Probably needed to be dropped on form, but I think he could find some more form in the 2's and find his way into the team again. I still dont think A Edwards is going to be the answer and i will be interested to see what posters think of his game if its less than satisfactory.

I think we'll see him at least one more time in the Yellow and Black before years end.
Fair point, it's still early, I corrected my post.

I fully expect him to be back. He will play hard in Coburg because he's playing for a new contract here or elsewhere
 
I was under the impression he hurt his knee last week, so he's not been omitted but out due to injury...?
 
it's interesting how so many people take the p!ss out of mguane on this thread, by calling him mcgun, demanding that his contract be extend, etc, but are always howling when we lose games due to having so many passengers in the team.

Jukes Extended said:
Hopefully his last game for the club.

exactly.

dimma, if you don't do anythig else this year, please stamp the papers 'never to play again' of this out and out dud.

Arghoslent said:
A hack is a dud is a hack.

i still prefer Claw's 'a dud is a dud is a dud' line :hihi
 
Tigers of Old said:
;D

At least he's played senior footy this year Collo Days.

As has been the norm, he's barely played a game at any level Tooheys.

Anyways, leysy's long given up that ghost. After 9 long years it might be time to put your hands up on this one as well. ;D