Luke McGuane | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Luke McGuane

Tigers of Old said:
Worst game for the year easily.
Makes me laugh though how some clowns come out of the woodwork after his first genuinely bad game. Where they been all year? :blah
Click to expand...

Wasn't great against Geelong and Fremantle either. First 3 games were his best. Steadily downhill from there. 0 frees for, 7 against in the last 4 weeks. Sums unp McGuane in a nutshelll. Hope he can find that early form but with players like McGuane, once the opposition put some homework into him, he can easily be controlled.
 
GoodOne said:
Wasn't great against Geelong and Fremantle either. First 3 games were his best. Steadily downhill from there. 0 frees for, 7 against in the last 4 weeks. Sums unp McGuane in a nutshelll. Hope he can find that early form but with players like McGuane, once the opposition put some homework into him, he can easily be controlled.
Click to expand...

Agree.

Only 2 goals the last 2 weeks and people weren't on his back because of his start to the year but now a 2 disposal 0 goal game. So 2 goals in 3 weeks after 11 in the first 5.
 
GoodOne said:
Wasn't great against Geelong and Fremantle either. First 3 games were his best. Steadily downhill from there. 0 frees for, 7 against in the last 4 weeks. Sums unp McGuane in a nutshelll. Hope he can find that early form but with players like McGuane, once the opposition put some homework into him, he can easily be controlled.
Click to expand...

he is at his 'best' as a forward when he leads into space, which today was non-existent for us, hence no impact. still works hard defensively.
i do wonder though if they are getting closer to wanting to try Edwards in his place.
 
Brodders17 said:
he is at his 'best' as a forward when he leads into space, which today was non-existent for us, hence no impact. still works hard defensively.
i do wonder though if they are getting closer to wanting to try Edwards in his place.
Click to expand...

Why/How fail against such weak opposition? Really disappointed in him today, as I was hoping he'd kick a bag....decoying Jack someway.

I just wish we could try him and Edwards together rather than swapping as they are both different players.
 
Brodders17 said:
he is at his 'best' as a forward when he leads into space, which today was non-existent for us, hence no impact. still works hard defensively.
Click to expand...

Yet Vickery managed 9 marks (3 Inside 50) and Reiwoldt 6 (4)? Even King managed 2 marks inside 50. There was plenty of space, he just dropped everything tonight. It happens.
 
GoodOne said:
Yet Vickery managed 9 marks (3 Inside 50) and Reiwoldt 6 (4)? Even King managed 2 marks inside 50. There was plenty of space, he just dropped everything tonight. It happens.
Click to expand...

He was ineffectual in the air still made a contest.
I thought our small forwards were worse than our talls. Nahas had a shocker in particular.
For the amount of times the ball went inside 50 and crumbs were there where the hell was he?
 
Tigers of Old said:
He was ineffectual in the air still made a contest.
I thought our small forwards were worse than our talls. Nahas had a shocker in particular.
For the amount of times the ball went inside 50 and crumbs were there where the hell was he?
Click to expand...

Please! McGuane had 2 disposals, 1 was ineffectual and he gave a free kick away. I counted at least 3 marks he should have taken but yes he did make it a contest. Yes Nahas was shocking as well. We could have just played a 4 man forward line and might have had a better result.
 
GoodOne said:
Please! McGuane had 2 disposals, 1 was ineffectual and he gave a free kick away. I counted at least 3 marks he should have taken but yes he did make it a contest. Yes Nahas was shocking as well. We could have just played a 4 man forward line and might have had a better result.
Click to expand...

??? Please? You've basically agreed with me.
 
evo said:
Classic Richmond spanner that plays a couple of good games every 20 and gets to dine out on it for the whole season.
Click to expand...

So true. Last three weeks have produced 2 goals and 21 touches.

Deserves to be chopped. Battler at best.
 
Ah, McGun is back to being McDud and we'll never win a premiership withi him in the side.

PRE normality has been restored.
 
Baloo said:
Ah, McGun is back to being McDud and we'll never win a premiership withi him in the side.

PRE normality has been restored.
Click to expand...


I almost couldn't hear this post over all the champagne corks popping.
 
I have been a supporter of him this year but today he was terrible. That 50 metre penalty was inexcusable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< Changes v Freo | The news cycle >
Official PRE merch now on Redbubble!
Top Bottom