-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Luke McGuane
- Thread starter Tigers of Old
- Start date
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
you need not leave this site to read: "Gaspar Kellaway Kellaway dud dud dud"
in defense of that opinion they have little to show for being a star-studded backline
looking forward, even Thursfield and Moore are less value than McGuane in my opinion
the differing opinions are interesting to say the least
Sir said:
you need not leave this site to read: "Gaspar Kellaway Kellaway dud dud dud"
in defense of that opinion they have little to show for being a star-studded backline
looking forward, even Thursfield and Moore are less value than McGuane in my opinion
the differing opinions are interesting to say the least
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
It's not like the St Kilda key forwards had a day out.
Milne was the difference. Didn't see McGuane line up on him.
It's not like the St Kilda key forwards had a day out.
Milne was the difference. Didn't see McGuane line up on him.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
its quotes like this that show people cant watch objectively.
yep mcguane had a shocker, but kosi, who mcguane was on kicked 2 goals for the game. who had a day out against him?
also according to the H-Sun he didnt turn the ball over once. not once.
SCOOP said:
its quotes like this that show people cant watch objectively.
yep mcguane had a shocker, but kosi, who mcguane was on kicked 2 goals for the game. who had a day out against him?
also according to the H-Sun he didnt turn the ball over once. not once.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
5 frees against, and as usual, majority completely unnecessary. Gone backwards.
5 frees against, and as usual, majority completely unnecessary. Gone backwards.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I feel for anyone who plays in our backline, the way it comes down there. Especially times like tonight. Gee its easy to blame players that have to play down there when its pumped in there without too much pressure from other players upfield.
I feel for anyone who plays in our backline, the way it comes down there. Especially times like tonight. Gee its easy to blame players that have to play down there when its pumped in there without too much pressure from other players upfield.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Pretty harsh Scoop, but sadly I think you are on the money.
Being consistenly led to the ball by Kosi is a bad sign. Luke had a shocker last night, his poor decision making was really exposed. He was directly responsible for 2 Stkilda goals in the first quarter and he didn't get any better from there.
People are right when they say that he didn't get many goals kicked on him, but make no mistake Kosi flogged him last night. Kosi provided the structure for Milne to do as he pleased. McGuane was unable to restrict Kosi in anyway and as a result their forward line functioned very well.
He has to go.
SCOOP said:
Pretty harsh Scoop, but sadly I think you are on the money.
Being consistenly led to the ball by Kosi is a bad sign. Luke had a shocker last night, his poor decision making was really exposed. He was directly responsible for 2 Stkilda goals in the first quarter and he didn't get any better from there.
People are right when they say that he didn't get many goals kicked on him, but make no mistake Kosi flogged him last night. Kosi provided the structure for Milne to do as he pleased. McGuane was unable to restrict Kosi in anyway and as a result their forward line functioned very well.
He has to go.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Luke is a req player for the time. We need other key backs, we have been saying this for years. We a crying out for a full back, luke,will,and kel are not good enough to play full back!
Luke is a req player for the time. We need other key backs, we have been saying this for years. We a crying out for a full back, luke,will,and kel are not good enough to play full back!
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
That's what killed us (as well as some poor, poor umpiring)
I thought the same Tubs. The backline get belted. But the main cause is the overlap and poor midfield pressure and defence. Too many still only running one way. There is a big emphasis on forward (frontal) pressure, but that falls down if the midfield aren't prepared to run back, man up and defend. Causing loose men to use the overlap.Tubytiger said:
That's what killed us (as well as some poor, poor umpiring)
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Nah don't agree. McGuane is playing above is weight. Won't get any better. Moore's best was a couple of years ago. Last year was a wipeout due to injury. I have seen some promising signs from Moore again this year and he will continue to improve as long as he can stay injury free.
tigertrue said:
Nah don't agree. McGuane is playing above is weight. Won't get any better. Moore's best was a couple of years ago. Last year was a wipeout due to injury. I have seen some promising signs from Moore again this year and he will continue to improve as long as he can stay injury free.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Amazing stat (well I think so). Saints had 19 free kicks. Our two key position players gave away 8 of those, 5 to McGuane and 3 to Thursfield. That's alot of free kicks in their forward line. At the other end Gilbert and Fisher had 1 free against between them. Why the discrepancy?
Amazing stat (well I think so). Saints had 19 free kicks. Our two key position players gave away 8 of those, 5 to McGuane and 3 to Thursfield. That's alot of free kicks in their forward line. At the other end Gilbert and Fisher had 1 free against between them. Why the discrepancy?
<
Changes v Freo
|
The news cycle
>
