lamb22 said:
You should tell Toby they don't have a top 4 list.
Do you really want to see us in another EF under Hardwick?
Although if we ever got past an EF we'd be very dangerous just on adrenaline.
Not too sure which Toby you are referring to, or the relevance. If Nank, well my previous point was, not making the top-4 did not stop the Dogs from winning the flag. But I made my point, proven by your last sentence.
I think Tiger supporters will be delighted if we make the finals this year, given the real frustration over last year's flop. Once there, anything can happen. Every game is different; you well know how different the team make-up this year is, not to mention the off-field staff. There's nothing to say we will lose another EF necessarily.
It would be fantastic to make that top 4 though. Playing a final at the G is a major factor in our favour. But, overall, my view is that we had to "take one step back (2016) to take two forward (2017) ..." Also that this IS "the best list Dimma has ever had". We had to go back and redraft the speedy and skilled youngsters that we were denied access to over the years where the expansion clubs raped the draft, then it takes time for them to step up etc.
Therefore, I believe there is plenty of improvement still to come from the likes of Rioli, Butler, Menadue, Markov, Bolton, Castagna, hopefully CEllis, Garthwaite, Graham and Drummond. Nankervis is still young along with other guys reaching their prime like BEllis, McIntosh and Vlastuin. If only Griffiths was well and firing, or Elton could finally impact at the level, we would be a greater threat in 2017.
As it is, I just see our window re-opening. If only we had succeeded with some KPPs. I am very positive about the years beyond, not 2017 so much. We might give a good account of ourselves if we do make any final this year, but the inexperience of so many young players I expect to be a factor. Even if we were to lose another EF, I think it will be a much closer and tougher match.