-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
When will Bernie go !!
- Thread starter Tigaman
- Start date
tigersnake said:
You can whinge about 'goal post shifting' as much as you like, but you still haven't explicitly laid out what you were 'right' about.
What did you get right?
Baron Samedi said:
Speak for yourself please, no attempts at bullying tactics. I have my own views on who and who isn't on a reasonably even mental keel.
Baron Samedi said:
you can read right? consensus pass mark? ergo, Dimma can coach? Club were right to back their man? etc etc? Its basic stuff.
tigersnake said:
So... we win a final and that vindicates the Hardwick extension.
Far, far too simplistic. This playing group needed a new game plan. It came from outside the club.
I'd say the likes of Harry and Lamby have shown far greater insight in their identification of the problems and possible solutions at Punt Rd than your bone headed "she's right, Dimma'll come good".
You really want kudos for being a fanboi?
Baron Samedi said:
far too simplistic for you because it means you're wrong, hence the GA of GPS. For the overwhelming majority, she's a pretty basic KPI. PRE, the media, everywhere, over and over again:, 'he's gotta win a final'.
tigersnake said:
As I said, the game plan came from outside the club.
So why does a finals win entitle you to gloat?
Shouldn't Harry and Lamby be gloating, since they were the ones who correctly identified both problem and solution?
Hint - it didn't require Dimma to suddenly become a coaching God.
Baron Samedi said:
had a quick look and found this, it was said by pretty much everyone at some point before or during the season, in different ways. I don't see this as any big gotcha or anything BTW, its just the way it was and is, 'he's gotta win a final'. Heard it on Fox all year, heard it on here all year.
tigersnake said:
Have you been reading today's debate?
Already said Dimma gets next year.
You're not bringing up anything new.
tigersnake said:
Cute, but you ain't making any sense.
How am I wrong?
Dimma got his PF berth so he survives.
Again - what did you get right that you need to unload a bucketload of whinge on this thread :hihi
(you whinge very, very well)
tigerlove said:
Yep. The claim he was a terrible coach, has no idea about modern football, pulls the handbrake blah blah blah ignores that we made finals in 2013-2015 winning 15, 12 and 15 games in the process.
"Oh, but we had a top 4 list", they say.
Well, if a coach that was that bad, that was that out of touch with modern football, was shackling the players every step of the way, was still able to take the team to those numbers of wins,then this list wasn't just top 4, it was one of the best of the modern era. It doesn't stack up. Compare this years team to that which played finals in 2015. Chalk and cheese.
Baron Samedi said:
not whinging, hanging *smile* is the correct term. I reckon I'm making myself pretty clear. But once you're done, you try and deflect, confuse and insult, its your modus operandi.
tigersnake said:
Ok - got it.
We win a QF in spectacular style and you jump on here to "hang *smile*" on folks.
Knock yourself out :hihi
