I'm guessing that was being addressed to Momentai?If you didn’t know that it does put some doubt on a lot of your comments as that is very common knowledge yet you seem to speak with authority on so many things ??
I'm guessing that was being addressed to Momentai?If you didn’t know that it does put some doubt on a lot of your comments as that is very common knowledge yet you seem to speak with authority on so many things ??
When Richmond trade in A Grade players from other clubs, as distinct from drafting through a draft selection, I reckon that Clarke and his team plus Hartley and Gale and sometimes even the Board (think Ben Cousins), would be part of the process. Think about TPP allocation...and of course doubt whenever you see fit.If you didn’t know that it does put some doubt on a lot of your comments as that is very common knowledge yet you seem to speak with authority on so many things.
Agreed.I'd like to see a new thread, pinned at the top called -
Take It Somewhere Else! where discussions on the merits of recruiting a player, known injuries, known personal issues, length of contract etc can be debated. There will always be differing views on whether a player should or shouldn't be recruited (or traded).
I'm more interested (especially at this time of year) in how Hopper is tracking and what his role will look like in Ooz's game plan
Blair Hartley is List Manager.When Richmond trade in A Grade players from other clubs, as distinct from drafting through a draft selection, I reckon that Clarke and his team plus Hartley and Gale and sometimes even the Board (think Ben Cousins), would be part of the process. Think about TPP allocation...and of course doubt whenever you see fit.
There is a whole forum for that. Its called "Race, Religion and Politics."Agreed.
I’d also like to see a thread called I don’t know the facts but I’ll debate it incessantly anyway
Yes it wasI'm guessing that was being addressed to Momentai?
The traffic on that one, would close the site down, or blow it up.Agreed.
I’d also like to see a thread called I don’t know the facts but I’ll debate it incessantly anyway
'I reckon', is not me being assertive and according to you I have got it pretty much right. Every one has a bit to say on players traded in.Blair Hartley is List Manager.
He has a detailed profile on every single player in the AFL.
He identifies talent, identifies holes in our list and negotiates with player managers.
He needs his football department superiors to sign off but he’s on par with Tim Livingston in seniority, so directly under Brendan Gale.
Clarke is involved in junior recruitment. He leads a small team of draft watchers. He does not recruit outside of the draft. His job is to rate all junior players in order and turns up to draft night with the hand he is given. The football department and coaches will have an input into the type of players they value.
'Don't Argue'. Is that a message to yourself, or to every one else.Agreed.
I’d also like to see a thread called I don’t know the facts but I’ll debate it incessantly anyway.
Yes, you got it correct except for the bit about blaming Clarke for Hopper’s recruitment.'I reckon', is not me being assertive and according to you I have got it pretty much right. Every one has a bit to say on players traded in.
'Don't Argue'. Is that a message yourself, or to every one else.
All of us hope he has a cracker!I cannot see the sense in bagging the club for Hopper based on results for one year of a seven year deal.
Granted Hopper had an average year and granted one could rate it a failure based on what we gave up to get him and then giving him a long contract.
Hopper was OK in 2023. Preseason reports all positive. So looking for him to stay injury free and to get his disposal average up over 25 and with him kicking goals. His best return over a year has been 10. Hope he exceeds that maybe even double would be a bonus
Good well I hope you enjoyed that.Yes, you got it correct except for the bit about blaming Clarke for Hopper’s recruitment.
He has no say in it
Hope you enjoyed his game yesterday.Good well I hope you enjoyed that.
I did.Hope you enjoyed his game yesterday.
Plenty more where that came from and best thing is you’ll get to enjoy it for another 6 years.
This happening has shortened up considerably after yesterday.Adding an A grade mid version of Hopper versus the 2023 model, could change everything.
Hopper represents our easiest pathway to an A grade mid that isn’t on the list right now.