Trade talk 2019/20

[deedee]

Still not an answer. Markov was in the team until Houli returned. Whether he has another year or two in him is moot. Maybe, or could end abruptly too.

Edwards goes just fine of HBF, but yea I know what if he is injured too.

 

[zippadeee]

Just spoke to someone at the club.
*We will not be active this trade period.
*no new assistant coaches
*Xavier Clarke & Sam Longegan have been promoted.
*Kingsley will NOT go for North job.
*Stkilda will have a go at getting Treloar.
*Higgins Wants to leave.
*club isn't happy Markov left.
*Cj not going anywhere.
*stack not sure.
*Martyn and Dow players to watch in 2021.
*not convinced Naish or Cumberland will make it.

Higgins wanted out as soon as he was dropped.
There goes another first rounder.
Hopefully the club goes hard for a first rounder. Regardless if its this year or next year.
Really pissed off

 

[zippadeee]

Oh we just found a replacement for Oleg. I fast, overpaid, outside flanker with no heart to replace someone with athleticism, speed, and difficulty maintaining fitness but lots of heart who is significantly cheaper.

I know who I'd rather have.

Polec is 10 times better then Markov.
Polec on the G could be a perfect fit

 

[craig]

Higgins wanted out as soon as he was dropped.
There goes another first rounder.
Hopefully the club goes hard for a first rounder. Regardless if its this year or next year.
Really pissed off

He was never staying in ahead of Edwards or Prestia.

Still has a few flaws in his footy that are glossed over by his personality and a couple of freak goals.

Said it on another thread I'm not fussed if he goes and I'm not fussed if he stays.

If he does go we must get proper transaction for him.

Will also give the club a little bit of salary cap relief for a bigger off season next year to go with the retirees wages coming off the books.

 

[tiger76]

Egg is a very good kick, just needs to be tougher at the contest and a better defender.
Definite potential.

For sure.

I seem to remember Houli’s hardness and defensive capabilities being questioned often around here a while back.

 

[zippadeee]

Oh we just found a replacement for Oleg. I fast, overpaid, outside flanker with no heart to replace someone with athleticism, speed, and difficulty maintaining fitness but lots of heart who is significantly cheaper.

I know who I'd rather have.

I would take Dunstan and Stkilda 2021 2nd rounder for Higgins.

 

[mrposhman]

I would take Dunstan and Stkilda 2021 2nd rounder for Higgins.

Dunstan is useless. We already have better players than him in reserve not getting a game. We also don't need players, we are already struggling to hit expected list size levels.

 

[Smoking Aces]

I would take Dunstan and Stkilda 2021 2nd rounder for Higgins.

Dunstan is slower than Higgins and probably a worse kick.
And that’s why Higgins isn’t a game.

 

[TigerMasochist]

The suggestion you have isn't far off, a 1st for Higgo and Markov in a strong draft is a decent return for the 2 of them being as we need to drop at least 1 of them due to list size reductions.

How does this year rate as a strong draft when half the kids in it haven't played any footy this year? Vic kids usually make up about 50% of the drafted players n thanks to Dan the Man, they've all spent the year sitting on their arses n twiddling their dicks.

 

[TigerMasochist]

Polec is 10 times better then Markov.
Polec on the G could be a perfect fit

Lost the plot there zippers. Polec is the antithesis to a Richmond winger. Polec b flashy n pacy but only works one way, when he's got to work back he does so at shufflin Joe's pace. Even #lolnorf dropped him a couple of times this year 'coz he wouldn't do any defensive work.

 

[mrposhman]

How does this year rate as a strong draft when half the kids in it haven't played any footy this year? Vic kids usually make up about 50% of the drafted players n thanks to Dan the Man, they've all spent the year sitting on their arses n twiddling their dicks.

The suggestion was for a 2021 first for Higgins and the Markov pick, hence why I mentioned strong draft.

 

[mrposhman]

Lost the plot there zippers. Polec is the antithesis to a Richmond winger. Polec b flashy n pacy but only works one way, when he's got to work back he does so at shufflin Joe's pace. Even #lolnorf dropped him a couple of times this year 'coz he wouldn't do any defensive work.

I'm so glad that Zips isn't our list manager. Just today would have traded in Dunstan and Polec

 

[zippadeee]

Lost the plot there zippers. Polec is the antithesis to a Richmond winger. Polec b flashy n pacy but only works one way, when he's got to work back he does so at shufflin Joe's pace. Even #lolnorf dropped him a couple of times this year 'coz he wouldn't do any defensive work.

Ok would you take Aaron Fiora back?

 

[zippadeee]

He was never staying in ahead of Edwards or Prestia.

Still has a few flaws in his footy that are glossed over by his personality and a couple of freak goals.

Said it on another thread I'm not fussed if he goes and I'm not fussed if he stays.

If he does go we must get proper transaction for him.

Will also give the club a little bit of salary cap relief for a bigger off season next year to go with the retirees wages coming off the books.

Craig he would be in 180-220k at the most.
Where not Collingwood.
It was a very odd selection from the start. The recruiting team must've been pissed.
We missed Oscar Allen, Taylor from GWS, liam Ryan and McCartin Sydney.
It was a solid group that went in the next 10-15 -,picks.
Where lucky Balta was still there with our 3rd pick.
Huggins to ok, but slow

 

[zippadeee]

I'm so glad that Zips isn't our list manager. Just today would have traded in Dunstan and Polec

We cannot accept a 2nd rounder.
The kid was pick 17 3 yrs ago, 2nd in the rising star. 50+ games in a top 4 side.
We just giving him away same as we did Bulter.
I would've tried to convince Gresham to leave and we could've given them our pick 18 and Higgins.
I would rather swap for a player then accept a pick past 25 for Higgins.

 

[zippadeee]

I'm so glad that Zips isn't our list manager. Just today would have traded in Dunstan and Polec

3 way trade
Stkilda get Higgins
We get Ed Richards
Footscary get Stkilda's 2nd rounder 2021. *pick 32
Or
Stkilda get Higgins
We get Alex Sexton
GC get Stkilda's 2nd rounder 2021

 

[zippadeee]

Higgins to stkilda
Fyfe to Richmond
Stkilda's 2nd rounder 2021 And our first to freo..

Or

Higgins to stkilda
Hopper to Richmond
Our first pick 2020 And Stkilda 2021 2nd rounder to GWS.

Or

Higgins to stkilda
Jed Anderson to Richmond
Stkilda's 2021 2nd rounder and our 2nd rounder this year 2020 to North

Or

Stack to freo
Higgins to 2nd Stkilda 2nd rounder 2021
Cerra to Richmond for our 1st 2020.
Freo's 2nd 2020 to Richmond

 

[mrposhman]

Higgins to stkilda
Fyfe to Richmond
Stkilda's 2nd rounder 2021 And our first to freo..

Or

Higgins to stkilda
Hopper to Richmond
Our first pick 2020 And Stkilda 2021 2nd rounder to GWS.

Or

Higgins to stkilda
Jed Anderson to Richmond
Stkilda's 2021 2nd rounder and our 2nd rounder this year 2020 to North

Or

Stack to freo
Higgins to 2nd Stkilda 2nd rounder 2021
Cerra to Richmond for our 1st 2020.
Freo's 2nd 2020 to Richmond

I think you've lost your mind!!

As I've said elsewhere, we should be looking to get the Dogs Pick 14 involved. Dogs want Lonie so that sorts the Saints side out (ie. they pay Lonie and their 2nd next year), we have pick swaps with the Dogs to get us Pick 14 and trade us out of the 2nd round of this years draft.

Far more likely than whatever you've just posted. What the hell is that 3rd one? North get 2 2nds for Jed Anderson??

 

[zippadeee]

I think you've lost your mind!!

As I've said elsewhere, we should be looking to get the Dogs Pick 14 involved. Dogs want Lonie so that sorts the Saints side out (ie. they pay Lonie and their 2nd next year), we have pick swaps with the Dogs to get us Pick 14 and trade us out of the 2nd round of this years draft.

Far more likely than whatever you've just posted. What the hell is that 3rd one? North get 2 2nds for Jed Anderson??

You reckon ive lost my mind.
Lonie is delist material, how the *smile* do you accept the dogs to use pick 14 on lonie.
He was dropped twice this year.
He is the most selfish footballer in the comp.
At best a 3rd rounder would get lonie.
Pick 14

 

[zippadeee]

I think you've lost your mind!!

As I've said elsewhere, we should be looking to get the Dogs Pick 14 involved. Dogs want Lonie so that sorts the Saints side out (ie. they pay Lonie and their 2nd next year), we have pick swaps with the Dogs to get us Pick 14 and trade us out of the 2nd round of this years draft.

Far more likely than whatever you've just posted. What the hell is that 3rd one? North get 2 2nds for Jed Anderson??

Anderson is a bull in the middle.
He is exactly what we need.
Tackles and hurts the opppstion.
I would give 2nd rounders for him because we will most likely use them on duds any way...