I haven't seen anything from him to command a first round pick.
Carlton are just a stupid club
800k for Williams and now 600k for sad. When they couldve spent less and just picked up Degoey.
He is 10 times better then both of them
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Trade talk 2019/20
- Thread starter tigertim
- Start date
Carlton are just a stupid club
800k for Williams and now 600k for sad. When they couldve spent less and just picked up Degoey.
He is 10 times better then both of them
How many of the best half backs in the game have come with a top 10 draft pick? Look at our 3. Houli (PSD) and Bakes and Shorty from the rookie draft.
Save your Top 10 picks for talls and exceptional midfielders.
And all 3 were forwards. Its why losing Markov wasnt such a big deal. We will find another player with speed and attacking instincts and teach them how to defend well enough.
Saad does fall in the gap between the Blues 1st and 2nd rd picks, hence their supposed want to swap pick 8 to get picks 18 and 19 from the Lions.
The academy bidding system is floored totally,u actually get a 20 percent discount for stealing a higher pick.
Carlton should just do what St.Kilda did last year with Freo/B.Hill and trade out their top pick and offer the leftovers for Saad.
That seems the most logical scenario however talk is that Essendon have enquired for the same thing to stop Carlton doing it so that they can still go for Pick 8., they are offering Pick 7 for the same 2 picks apparently). Bunch of wankers.
Spot on. Noah Balta had his detractors, but he may well now be one of our most valuable players. Noah looks and feels like he belongs.
Tell the blues that thet can play that game
Pick 20 and next years first round pick for the blues 8. Happy to help Carlton to screw the bummers
Carlton think they are GWS, they have had so many top 10 picks.
They are throwing them away and buying up half back flankeries
Saad and Tipa are second tier players.
Bumbers carry on like they are A grade.
And they wonder why they suck
Sounds like a good story but surely not true. U effectively saying there isn't really a salary cap and that the rich clubs can buy there way around the cap and go over it. This contradicts why the cap was brought in.
Not player salary 'hard' cap. Football department 'soft' cap.
The Bulldogs' interest in Treloar makes money sense. Strategic money sense. Their books would be tight. (TPP and paying the gardener.)
They are a star down from finals-competitive. And finals-competitive is where the money is at.
Dunkley is a busy lad. But a Supercoach champion. (I think he's a battler.) Treloar, for all his weaknesses, is a massive upgrade. Treloar, Bontompelli, McCrae, Smith, Hunter and no Dunkley. Looks miles better.
They'd need a ruck and a key back but minnows have to nibble at the big stuff.
Footscray should blackmail then rescue Collingwood. Treloar is a big talent boost for them.
They are a star down from finals-competitive. And finals-competitive is where the money is at.
Dunkley is a busy lad. But a Supercoach champion. (I think he's a battler.) Treloar, for all his weaknesses, is a massive upgrade. Treloar, Bontompelli, McCrae, Smith, Hunter and no Dunkley. Looks miles better.
They'd need a ruck and a key back but minnows have to nibble at the big stuff.
Footscray should blackmail then rescue Collingwood. Treloar is a big talent boost for them.
The smart play for Dodoro would be to sag off, let Footscray get the deal all but over the line then burn Dunkley and go for Treloar. Three-way trade simplified.
Treloar has little power in this IMO. "Premiership window"? He has nowhere near that currency. So if Esserdun made a late play they could pull it off.
That would be bold. But Dodoro is famous for vexatiousness and brinkmanship, not boldness.
Treloar has little power in this IMO. "Premiership window"? He has nowhere near that currency. So if Esserdun made a late play they could pull it off.
That would be bold. But Dodoro is famous for vexatiousness and brinkmanship, not boldness.
The only issue I see is length of contract and injury history which go hand in hand.
How he fits in our game plan..the guy is 20x the player RCD or Ross will ever be.
Culture...have u ever heard of a DeGoey type story with Treloar?
List Management ... priority at all times is get the best players available that u can afford. If he fulfill both criteria go for it.
Position...starting mid. Sort the others out.
You seem very confident about that. Stack, Naish and DES were all tried there this year. Every one of them came up short (Or not! But no pun intended!). All failed.
I've posed this question to others claiming Oleg is no loss, but haven't seen an answer yet. So we lose one of our Premiership HBFs or wingmen 1st round next year with a LTI, who has your full confidence to replace them immediately?
You need VFL games to "teach them how to defend well enough." Something no one got in '20. If you say Stack, take a LOL now.
Fair suck of the sauv. Twenty times might be a bit rich. Ross’ first year was elite until he got injured. We’d have to hope he can get back there.
You have that "what if" with every position, the next guy in is not as good (yet) otherwise they would have been in the team in the first place, no team ever has a "first" 44.
