Toby Greene | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Toby Greene

Whilst i agree with many of the posts about Greene being a thoroughly unlikable player there is no doubt to me he is also a seriously good footballer

The job Grimes did on him in the prelim went a long way to winning us that game, especially in the first half when we were up against it for a period.
 
Sintiger said:
The job Grimes did on him in the prelim went a long way to winning us that game, especially in the first half when we were up against it for a period.
The job Trent did on Dylan Shiel was major reason for me. Their key mid IMO.
 
Sintiger said:
Whilst i agree with many of the posts about Greene being a thoroughly unlikable player there is no doubt to me he is also a seriously good footballer

The job Grimes did on him in the prelim went a long way to winning us that game, especially in the first half when we were up against it for a period.

Broad played on Toby Greene in the Prelim for much of it and beat him.

Broad didnt get much of the ball at all in that match he had a shut down job on Greene and did it well.
 
He's done it again.

Gave Broad a boot to the chest. Got off with a $1,500 fine for a boot to Luke Dahlhous' face. I thought the head was sacrosanct. The guy could have lost an eye.

Now he's stuck the studs into two Sydney players.

AFL needs to address this before someone gets seriously injured.
 
Yep. If we saw this at a junior level you’d be ropable. Kids copy their stars. Needs to be fixed ASAP.
 
zippadeee said:
I hope they dont suspend him, he will.slap Collingwood
I understand where you're coming from, Zipps.

I just can't stand the bloke. The grub spat at Miles. Stuck his boot into how many players now? Only a matter of time before someone gets a serious injury from this type of action.

Will the AFL act? No. Might hurt their plastic team's chances.
 
Quickdraw said:
He's done it again.

Gave Broad a boot to the chest. Got off with a $1,500 fine for a boot to Luke Dahlhous' face. I thought the head was sacrosanct. The guy could have lost an eye.

Now he's stuck the studs into two Sydney players.

AFL needs to address this before someone gets seriously injured.
I don't understand all the "experts" saying that there's no rules against it???

Last I checked there are rules against kicking. At the very least he should be charged with that given he is deliberately using his feet against other players???

.....and there are rules for dangerous play and misconduct.
 
Taken from another thread.....and summed up much better than I could do it....


Mac said:
Good call. The rules are actually quite clear. Basil is 100% wrong - there IS a clear difference between ‘holding the man out’ in a marking contest with your hands as compared with your feet.

Section 15.4.3 of the laws of the game talks about permitted contact with hips, shoulders, chest, arms and open hands. No mention of feet - therefore NOT permitted. Again - FEET NOT PERMITTED

Section 15.4.4 talks about charging.

Section 15.4.5 (as you have already highlighted) talks about PROHIBITED contact. Even if there’s an argument that Groin didn’ ‘kick’, his actions clearly have the potential to injure (eg stops in Dahlhaus’s face).
In addition, most agree that ‘it’s not a good look’. Rule 15.4.5 (k) states “...rough conduct against an opposition player that in the circumstances is unreasonable”
It certainly isn’t a stretch to award a free against Groin for an unreasonably rough action. Stops in the ribs could easily crack a rib.

I reckon the current rules allow an interpretation that outlaws what Groin did 3 times last night. All the AFL has to say is that they will not allow it under the existing rules and will be cracking down on it so be warned.

And yeah, Michael Long did it a few times in his career too. It was a bad look then and still is. Don’t know why umps find it difficult to call it out.
 
As far as I am concerned it is kicking and kicking another player is a dog act and the fact he is kicking someone to avoid contact makes him a coward. Don’t know what he is like as a person but if he is anything like he comes across on the field(cowardly dog) then he is probably a real sh!t bloke.

The AFL will do nothing or at worst a fine if he can get away with kicking someone in the face then they will do nothing and as has been said can’t have GWS’s chances diminished.
 
All this crap about contact allowed in marking contest. Its only allowed if its incidental to the marking contest. Sticking your foot up into another player is not incidental to trying to get to the ball.
 
Would be real interesting the reaction if someone like Rance did the same thing to Greene.Free to Toby? Toby cracks it and kicks Rance?What would Razor Ray have done?
 
Quickdraw said:
Only a matter of time before someone gets a serious injury from this type of action.
Simon Madden in a ruck contest many years ago got Graham Johns? Ruck from Sydaknee in the throat with the stops, if I recall it correctly. Wrecked the blokes larynx. Bit of old school footy that's still allowed that *smile* me is obviously Greene getting away with extending the stops, but also the likes of Waite n Hawkins constantly driving knees first from a long way behind at marking contests. It's one thing to use the knees to help elevate, it's altogether something else when the knees are used as a battering ram.
Most of the raised knees n feet from days gone by were used simply to protect from incoming opponents, but with the front on contact rules that have been in place for years it's almost irrelevant now unless your deliberately trying to nail someone.