As you know, SCOOPer, turf matters. (Mott should trail Dunaden IMO.)
I developed a simple rule of punting, SCOOP, that has not let me down - the bigger the price, the bigger the bet. And if they blow I go again.
Jamie Mott might just lose his sh!t out there tomorrow. Bad luck. But Sadler will have a plan and the barrier may prove to be an advantage if your pony can go early. Or if the G1 big field random pace factor emerges. They may just go hard anyway.
But you're a voice in the wilderness on this race and your case has merit. That's when you go. Take your lumps or clean up. You've almost talked me into this chaffburner. The weakness is the jockey. Jockey's are crucial IMO. Barriers are incidental.
Remote Tiger, told me on this very thread, that he keeps an eye out for signposts. What you are noticing, SCOOP, are signposts.
Voice in the wilderness. It's time to have a go. If you fail go again. Intuition.
The trainer is a very powerful plus - a genius with geriatrics and cripples; the rider is a minus redeemed in part by the fact that the trainer chose him. (If Nash were on your horse you'd be insane not to load up - year's biggest bet.)
My tip is rough and risky. He is an 80% chance of not winning IMO. There is a fifty percent chance he will go bust due to lack of hard racing (I think he needs the break as tested by the trainer) or not be good enough. And then there is a chance that he won't get the galloping room he needs (are inside draws an advantage? Depends who's riding, mainly.)
I don't know what the jockeys are doing. Or the trainers. But I'll be taking a tip from the horses - and when they're half way up the straight and my boy gets the split I'll call out triumphantly "Who's on the Gear?" (I hope Winchester runs second. ;D) If Dunaden possies I'll have a fight.
Caulfield Cup tris for me: 17, 2, 4, 12; 15, 5, 9. 20.
And something for the bookmakers -