DirtyDogTiger said:Would the swannies tank, skip the double chance, but gain a home final?
Stylo said:Don't see why. Don't they get a home final in week 2 even if they lose in week 1? They'd essentially just be forgoing a shot at advancing straight to a prelim.
Ice said:yes, a flaw in the current system is that finishing 4th, is significantly better than finishing 5th.
DirtyDogTiger said:It wouldn't be a flaw if we didn't choke on an 8 point lead against freo last month
DirtyDogTiger said:It wouldn't be a flaw if we didn't choke on an 8 point lead against freo last month
Ice said:exactly, imagine if we finished 4th. Beat Freo in Freo week 1. week off. Prelim at MCG.
i was gutted after that Freo loss a month ago
DirtyDogTiger said:It wouldn't be a flaw if we didn't choke on an 8 point lead against freo last month
tigersnake said:That loss sucked though for sure, but not as bad as melb and Geel ones.
Ice said:Personally, I was hurt deeper by the Freo loss, because we actually outplayed them. The other games we deserved to lose and were outplayed.
Also, if we had won, 4th was a realistic option - and I know the huge advantage 4th has over 5th.
tigersnake said:We deserved to lose sure, but not because we were outplayed, we were slow, dumb and weak. We played like scared lettuce leaves. I saw my football barracking future flash before my eyes.
(I'd put the WC and Foots losses in the 'beaten by a better side on the day' basket).
The Freo loss was one we should have won yes. I'll take a narrow loss that is a moral victory over a top side over an insipid, consider ringing the chook manure delivery-dude never-in-the-hunt against middling to terrible sides effort anyday.
year of the tiger said:Can't live by what ifs ..... doesn't work that way
DirtyDogTiger said:Our first 11 games -
we conceded 121 goals at an AV 11 per game
Since then - 88 from 10 games. AV 8.8
We've lost just 2 games: Freo (12 goals) and adelaide -11 goals.
A big warning sign for us is 10 goals.
We've only won two games where we've given up 11 goals (swans and Collingwood r7).
Now the western bulldogs Suns swans Adelaide & hawthorn have all beaten North by keeping them to 10 goals.
We've improved defensively so we need to keep the brakes on their scoring and keep them under 11 goals.
Get the handbrake on Petrie brown Nahas and Thomas.
And it has to start in the midfield
North