Disco08 said:Not touching the fact he only had 5 frees paid against him while in possession this year? You'd reckon a player who has simply no awareness would get caught and penalised a lot more no?
Now, keeping that in mind, can you tell me how these stats somehow damn Tambling and prove he simply has no awareness?
Scribblar said:Have you ever really watched Tambling?
Scribblar said:Ever watched Tambling run around the ground like a beheaded sheep dog, lost and not knowing who he should be on, where he should position himself, which team-mates he should support in play, which packs he is close enough to enter and which pack he should stay clear of?
That's what I call NO AWARENESS.
And do we have a stat for the times Tambling has given a 'hospital disposal' to a team-mate or the amount of times he has killed a flowing piece of play?
Scribblar said:Have you ever really watched Tambling?
Ever watched Tambling run around the ground like a beheaded sheep dog, lost and not knowing who he should be on, where he should position himself, which team-mates he should support in play, which packs he is close enough to enter and which pack he should stay clear of?
That's what I call NO AWARENESS.
And do we have a stat for the times Tambling has given a 'hospital disposal' to a team-mate or the amount of times he has killed a flowing piece of play?
:
Scribblar said:Have you ever really watched Tambling?
Ever watched Tambling run around the ground like a beheaded sheep dog, lost and not knowing who he should be on, where he should position himself, which team-mates he should support in play, which packs he is close enough to enter and which pack he should stay clear of?
That's what I call NO AWARENESS.
And do we have a stat for the times Tambling has given a 'hospital disposal' to a team-mate or the amount of times he has killed a flowing piece of play?
:
Disco08 said:I've seen him play in the flesh 5 times. Exaggeration is an understatement.
Maybe you can explain to me why other clubs would show interest in such a pathetic player Redan?
Disco08 said:Unbelievable the way you keep repeating inane points that have been disproved time and again.
Disco08 said:I've seen him play in the flesh 5 times. Exaggeration is an understatement.
Maybe you can explain to me why other clubs would show interest in such a pathetic player Redan?
Disco08 said:Not touching the fact he only had 5 frees paid against him while in possession this year? You'd reckon a player who has simply no awareness would get caught and penalised a lot more no?
tigertim said:Simple. He went no 4 in the 2004 ND. He's played 100 games. Every club thinks they can "turn around" a top 10 pick career when it has't been going so well.
GoodOne said:AND, we havent seen what's on offer yet. I don't think we'll get for Tambling what some seem to think he is worth. If we were very lucky we might get a late 2nd rounder, which is what late 30s early 40s. Not sure that the Tigers would give him up for that. I'm warming to the straight swap for Sherman.
zippadeee said:Ive had enough of him not preforming, but to say a straight swap for Sherman is not going to happen. We need to off load him in the same way Melbourne off loaded Mclean. a pick under 20. or swap him for a player with a higher calibre then Sheman.
In the famous words of Survivor "its time to go Richie"
GoodOne said:Exactly what I was talking about, over-rating our own. McLean had a decent history behind him. Tambling whilst improving every year has now had 6 years of AFL footy behind him. What has he REALLY achieved? No-one is going to pay what you are asking. Let's wait and see whats on offer.
Agree totally zips. In my opinion, as a small, if you arent making an impact of some sort after 6 years then there is a high chance that you never will, at least not at that club. I think Tambling may have something to give (obviously not to the level we had hoped for when we picked him up at #4) but often it takes a new environment to get the best out of them. Can we seriously say that we missed Raines, Schulz and Pattison this year? All were in and out of their respective sides just as they were at Richmond. With Tambling it appears we may be at that junction.zippadeee said:To tell you the truth Goodie, i would just be happy for a pick in the 20's for him, St.kildas or doggies picks will do.
You cant wait 6 years and ask for any more. This needs to change at the club, you dont preform in 4-5 years see ya later.
we cant keep hold of players that just give 3-4 games a year. I hope he goes to another club and proves me wrong,