Re: Tambling [Merged]
Hawthorn won't give us anything special. That Pelchen is a tight arse.
Hawthorn won't give us anything special. That Pelchen is a tight arse.
mad_doggy911 said:Hawthorn won't give us anything special. That Pelchen is a tight arse.
ToraToraTora said:It would actually be painful to see Tambling play better elsewhere. But it'll be a lot lot less painful with a second round pick and a development player in trade.
totally agree. anyone who thinks differently has obviously got their heads in the clouds. id take anything DECENT for tambo for sure!Disco Stu said:Having been to all Melbourne games this year... I am sick of having to watch below par efforts from Tambling. We can have the excuses such as niggles, sleepless nights & what ever else, it doesn't help the fact that he isn't positively affecting the outcome for the Tigers. If we can trade him, do it. If he tears it up at his new club, good for him. No point holding on to him just in case he comes good.
People talk of his 'purple patch' last season.... that wasn't a purple patch, it was what is expected of a guy who has played 100 games (the majority gifted). He strung together half a season of reasonable football. For what ever reason he was terrible again this year. I'd at a guess suggest if he has played 100 games, no more than 15 would have been above mediocre.
If a trade is available, take it Tigers, whether it is Houli or a draft pick, I reckon it is a win.
WesternTiger said:Don't think North would agree with you. Got a decent result from the Gibson deal.
mad_doggy911 said:Hawthorn won't give us anything special. That Pelchen is a tight arse.
Disco08 said:You reckon trading him after his worst season is striking while the iron's hot? If we wanted to do that we should have done it last year.
Tigers of Old said:Some clubs out there might believe his lack of form this year is injury related. I think he still has reasonable currency.
You obviously still think he's worth plenty.
CptJonno2Madcow2005 said:Tambling for pick 30ish To0?Id rather keep him.
U2Tigers said:I wouldn't be suprised if our club thought his injuries had something to do with his poor form.
Put it this way To0.Pick 30ish this year is like pick 40ish in terms on whats available.No way id do it.Tigers of Old said:Yeah maybe a touch lower if we're lucky.
I think he is very replaceable.
CptJonno2Madcow2005 said:Put it this way To0.Pick 30ish this year is like pick 40ish in terms on whats available.No way id do it.
Id hope thay have an eye on someone in the teen picks ;DTigers of Old said:Depends who the recruiters have their eye on.
CptJonno2Madcow2005 said:teen picks ;D
rosy23 said:I wonder what all the talk of Tambo will do to his mind-set and self-esteem if he stays at Tigerland. He seems to be a bit of a confidence player to me. I hope he can come out next season and let his footy do the talking, wherever he might be playing.