Dean3 said:
mb64 said:
iitb said:
Dean3 said:
jb03 said:
No, Franklin is a better player than all of them on what we have seen to date.
Mate, Steven Sziller is a better player than Riewoldt or Hughes, on what we have seen to date.
What an absolutely dumb comment. Seriously, did you think before typing that? Just dumb.
Agree ,but Dean's thread not surprising.
Ho hum, if you guys can't understand my point, maybe I'll have to pitch things a bit lower in future. :
No we understand but your point is just plain stupid. Considering they are all youngsters, with Pattison even taken in the same draft as Franklin, I think having an opinion that one is better than the others, and as such would be preferable as a RFC player than the others is valid.
If you like assessing Reiwoldt as an AFL player can be excused but knowing we know about Franklin I would still prefer Franklin over an untried Reiwoldt.
Yes Sziller may also be better than the players you mention at the moment but I wouldn't think anyone would prefer him on the list to them.
If you want to maintain unrelenting faith in every decision made by the RFC that is fine. But so is having an alternative view.