leon said:Yes, exactly illustrating my argument, that you refuse to comprehend no matter how many times I have attempted to convey it to you, because you are so full of your own conceited views. It is about the whole midfield team; not simply the ruckman. But if your ruckman is winning the HOs and your mids are sharp on winning the CLRs, then you have a powerful combination.
[size=14pt]But just because a ruckman is winning the HOs, it does not automatically mean his team win the clearances. [/size]So this time our mids (which includes Nank) in the 1st Q beat them even though Kreuz was winning the HOs. It totally proves what I have given up trying to convey to you; I know this will fail too. However, maybe read RC's article in the Age today. Fascinating reading. Most of the winning teams had losing rucks BECAUSE their midfields and other players won the contests from and after the HOs e.g. although Sandy dominated, Geelong thrashed Freo around the CLRs; same with the Pies and Dogs. Grundy dominated but, as Beveridge suggests, you can overcome this by winning turnovers. The exception was Dees where Gawn dominated as well as their mids taming Saints and then getting well on top.
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/new-afl-thirdmanup-rule-takes-effect--and-the-sky-doesnt-fall-20170326-gv7266.html
PS - And I thought of you while out driving listening to the segment on SEN with Luff and Champion Data. I wasn't able to stop and record the very interesting stats he revealed on Dusty's role in our midfield. It explained what I was struggling to understand. We all rate him as probably our top mid, but he's actually a poor CLR player. On stats, we actually do much better without DM in the centre. His value is as an outside mid running into attack and up forward. I had suspected for a long time that he does not have great anticipation nor read the play all that well; but once he is in a contest he thrives.
Exactly. Hit outs are irrelevant, midfielders matter. The ruckman is a full third of your midfield line. Your ruckman must be a capable midfielder. Ergo, Hampson goes in the bin.