Vickery has done more in the AFL than McBean, and did more in the VFL when he went back there this year. But that's irrelevant, that's the point. I'm the first to say that McBean has played waaay too much VFL, but the outcome of that, is that he's going to have a more impressive VFL portfolio than Vickery, over the last three years. Pretty simple logic. You can't compare McBean's AFL form to Vickery's, or Vickery's VFL form to McBeans. It's stupid.
Riiight, the "he hasn't performed, unless you include the games he has performed". Can't argue with that.
Well. Playing without Heart is a made up Carter intangible. I think he plays with lots of heart. And lots of head. I think his deficiencies are: Concentration, reaction after a contest, running toward goal rather than away from it at times, repeat running. Those are some of things he needs to work on.
Tigersnake's covered this one. I guess Cotchin, Riewoldt, Rance, Deledio are also players we can't afford to carry seeing we haven't won 11 flags with them either.
Is Dimma too forgiving or not forgiving enough? He's blind, but clearly sees Tyrone had some deficiencies to work on? Dimma's an idiot for not dropping anyone, but Tyrone's terrible for getting dropped by Dimma.
Who are you having a go at here? Dimma clearly managed it well, and Tyrone clearly responded well. As far as I can make out here, you tried to take potshots at too many of your whipping boys at once, and proving their mutual success.
