Pick 29: Shai Bolton | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Pick 29: Shai Bolton

Fremantle Dockers CEO Simon Garlick promises aggressive approach to trade table to secure more elite talent​

Craig O'DonoghueThe West Australian
Tue, 27 August 2024 4:00AM

Fremantle chief executive Simon Garlick has promised to be as aggressive as possible at the trade table to secure more elite talent, saying his team’s poor finish to the season showed they need to add more class to the list.

The Dockers slid from third on the ladder in round 20 to 10th just four weeks later after failing to win another game.
Coach Justin Longmuir said the 20-point defeat form Port Adelaide on Sunday summed up their season as the players fumbled under pressure, missed shots at goal or gave away free kicks at crucial times.

Fremantle have three first round picks this season and have been heavily linked to Shai Bolton, Liam Baker and Chad Warner.
Garlick said the club had a clear plan for how to take the next step.

“We won’t hesitate in doing whatever we need to improve our list and our ability to close out games,” Garlick told The West Australian.

“Clearly, we have some opportunities with a strong draft hand, and how that eventuates will obviously be clear in in time.

“We’ve put together a list that we think has the foundations to challenge for premiership, and there absolutely needs to be improvement in that. We won’t be backwards in exploring every option we’ve got.

“We’ll certainly be going hard at the targets we think are appropriate. But we won’t be doing it at all costs.

“We’ve got to make sure that if you do have the opportunity to bring experienced talent into your club, it’s got to be at the right price. It can’t be at the complete expense of culture.

“There’s numerous considerations we’re going to make, but we certainly won’t be shy in ensuring we give ourselves the best opportunity to continue to grow and improve.”

The Dockers have had a stable defence for several years led by captain Alex Pearce and All-Australian backman Luke Ryan. The midfield’s power was on show all season with Caleb Serong, Andrew Brayshaw and Hayden Young constantly winning the ball.
Fremantle showed an improved ability to score this season with key forward Josh Treacy making huge improvements, but the team still ranked 10th in attack at the end of the home and away season.

“It’s just not being able to finish and execute and capitalize on the opportunities that we provided,” Garlick said.

“We were a top four defence and an elite contested ball team and clearance team within the middle of the ground. So us being able to finish with class under pressure when the moment demands it, is something we need to continue to get better at.”

Garlick backed coach Justin Longmuir after the club extended his contract by 12 months before the season began.
Fremantle have made the finals just once since Longmuir and Garlick joined the club in 2020 and the Dockers have fallen short of an ambitious Strategic Plan to have three top-four finishes and a premiership by the end of next season.

The Dockers’ re-build began in 2016 and they’ve been overtaken by several clubs including Hawthorn this season. But Garlick said they were following their own plan.

“We’re certainly not shying away from putting ourselves on the hook to achieve our ultimate aim, and that is to win premierships. That’s what we’re here for. So we’re not looking to make excuses or rationalise why we haven’t hit that mark yet,” he said.

“We set this at the end of 2020, so judge us upon that timeframe and what we were looking to achieve then.

“We are as impatient as anyone. I know our members and fans quite rightfully are also. Whilst we want it to happen yesterday or a soon as humanly possible, we want to set ourselves up to have a sustained crack at contending for premierships.

“There’s precedents of clubs like Geelong and Sydney and a number of others who continually contend. So every decision we made has been made with a long term outlook.”

Freos problems are clearly in the forward half, and mainly against the best opposition. Freo played 11 games against teams in the top 8, winning just 3 games and losing 8.

Against the top 8, their defence ranked ok at 8th in the AFL (av points against 87.5), but only ranked 14th for scores for with an average of 75.4, pretty much on par with perennial underachievers St Kilda (73.5) and Essendon (76).

The top 4 scores for teams (against the top 8) were Carlton (91.1), Sydney (90.0), Port Adelaide (88.1) and Geelong (86.6), so for Freo to jump up and probably compete at the top of the ladder, they need to be scoring at least a couple more goals per game.

Comparing their forwards to Geelong, their talls / mid sizers aren't too different.

Cameron, Hawkins / Neale and Henry combined for an average of 5.6 goals per game.
Treacy, Amiss and Sturt combined for an average of 5.51 goals per game

But its the smalls that you see the real difference

Close and Stengle combined for an average of 2.92 goals per game
Banfield and Frederick combined for an average of 2.15 goals per game

Goals from their smalls, and goals from their midfield are where they need to improve. Hence why they should be doing everything they can to get Shai this year and set themselves up to get Warner next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Shai Bolton's premiership medals have been found by Victoria Police.

1724730493416.png
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 15 users
Freos problems are clearly in the forward half, and mainly against the best opposition. Freo played 11 games against teams in the top 8, winning just 3 games and losing 8.

Against the top 8, their defence ranked ok at 8th in the AFL (av points against 87.5), but only ranked 14th for scores for with an average of 75.4, pretty much on par with perennial underachievers St Kilda (73.5) and Essendon (76).

The top 4 scores for teams (against the top 8) were Carlton (91.1), Sydney (90.0), Port Adelaide (88.1) and Geelong (86.6), so for Freo to jump up and probably compete at the top of the ladder, they need to be scoring at least a couple more goals per game.

Comparing their forwards to Geelong, their talls / mid sizers aren't too different.

Cameron, Hawkins / Neale and Henry combined for an average of 5.6 goals per game.
Treacy, Amiss and Sturt combined for an average of 5.51 goals per game

But its the smalls that you see the real difference

Close and Stengle combined for an average of 2.92 goals per game
Banfield and Frederick combined for an average of 2.15 goals per game

Goals from their smalls, and goals from their midfield are where they need to improve. Hence why they should be doing everything they can to get Shai this year and set themselves up to get Warner next year.
SOLD!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Thats what they look like?
At least someone's 12 year old had fun with the art project.
It's not about how they look, it's about what they represent!

... Is what I imagine AFL House said when they decided to pay $20 to Gill's nephew to draw it after kindy
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
It's not about how they look, it's about what they represent!

... Is what I imagine AFL House said when they decided to pay $20 to Gill's nephew to draw it after kindy
You're kidding. They gave someone they went to school with $1 million.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Then the weak flimsy media will attack us.
'What they get in return?"
"Why couldn't they get this out of him?"
"Sometimes you need to say NO and keep them"

I guarantee next year round 5 or 6, What have Richmond done? It let go if a kid 25yrs old and on still 3 more years on a contract and he would have 9 brownlow votes in the 1st 5 games.

He is a star footballer. But he couldn't forge a relationship under Yze and then he wants out. It doesn't help when your best mate is going too.

He will be better at freo then Farmer was.
I don’t accept that he has to go but if he is permitted to go we should be talking about a pick 3 rather than picks 10 and 11.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
If a player publicly states he want a trade out of Richmond and we say no, does anyone really expect the player to put in the hard yards for the remainder of the time he is at the club when he clearly wants out?
Papley says yes. They have incentives in contracts for a reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user