MRP | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

MRP

Christian....... he's taking the *smile* isn't he?
That front on charge to Max Gawn by Mathieson was a 2k fine!

C'mon Michael. ... turn the *smile* lights off and don't let the door hit ya in the arse on the way out!
Arguably worse and more dangerous than what Pickett did
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Or being a rascal or a lovable rogue.
All part of the mummy package isn’t it? Don’t you just love it when the media just laugh off his “antics” but crucify others for doing less?
Same commentators that never question Brisbane players sneaky shots, or Connor Rosee's diving.
And hows that wanker Daniher breaking up Melbourne goal celebration when he can't get a kick himself. Back to his Essendon laughing boy antics.
 
In yesterday's game there should be two suspensions - Stringer for the sneaky punch during a push and shove (not a jumper punch at all like the commentators said) and Merrett for a sling tackle on Liberatore. Both should miss week one next year.........but of course they wont.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Greene will get weeks which is unfortunate as they could beat geelong with him in the side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Posted in the finals thread so apologies as I feel it should be on this thread.


Unfortunately has cost his side a shot to win their game against the Cats.

- An example will be made.
- 2 plus weeks
-cannot be tolerated
- could have walked around him
-deliberate
-former players defence of him a terrible look
-any angle I look at.. does him no favours. Forceful.
-not the captain to approach an umpire
- can’t defend him
-can’t compare with Neales incident
-filters down
- would not be shocked if it’s more than 2
-his action now has me not defending him anymore of late. No respect for him. Thought he had turned the corner with his role as captain but Cogs comes back in and Toby back to his terrible shelf.
- will it cost Toby more
-had forgotten the incident of the nightclub ..

AFL can’t defend this act.

Just my final word and please don’t think I’m trying to defend Toby but Stevic shouldn’t have been near the vacinity of the GWS players. The umpires as I’ve seen on numerous occasions( any level ) walk together and away from both teams players. Stevic is an experienced umpire. Could have defused any likely situation that could have arisen.
 
Yep, he'll cop a couple of weeks, thanks to the media.
Then when Selwood or Hawkins does it, the media will ignore it and continue on their marry way.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 1 users
Yep, he'll cop a couple of weeks, thanks to the media.
Then when Selwood or Hawkins does it, the media will ignore it and continue on their marry way.
nah, he get weeks because of his stupid action, cant blame the media at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Over the years one has seen quite a lot inane actions by players in the AFL but this latest by Toby takes the cake. Toby is not just a new kid on the block but into his 10th season & with a track record of indiscretions. The Giants led by upstanding coach Leon Cameron players Davis ,De Boer,Taranto,Ward,Haynes & Mummy to name a few hold their head up high week in week out yet this suffocating pompous brain dead twit must frustrate them no end. Trade him to Lol Norf but doubt if Lol Norf would put out the welcome mat.
 
Over the years one has seen quite a lot inane actions by players in the AFL but this latest by Toby takes the cake. Toby is not just a new kid on the block but into his 10th season & with a track record of indiscretions. The Giants led by upstanding coach Leon Cameron players Davis ,De Boer,Taranto,Ward,Haynes & Mummy to name a few hold their head up high week in week out yet this suffocating pompous brain dead twit must frustrate them no end. Trade him to Lol Norf but doubt if Lol Norf would put out the welcome mat.

Someone above mentioned Phil Carman, so similar.

I have to say though, Carman head-butting an umpire takes more cake, possibly the whole cake shop.

But what Toby Greene did was simply stupid.

DS
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Bloody hell. Carrying on like this is a murder case. Quite obvious he'll get suspended as there seems to be no twist in the evidence. I'd say 2-3 weeks.
 
Huge contrast in both QCs views. This seems more based on protecting the flogs than what Toby actually did.

Gleeson wants no less than 6 weeks and Ihle wants a fine. I'm not sure how this incident shows aggressive or demonstrative. Disrespectful yes, but not those other two, even going by what Stevic said.