-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Luke McGuane
- Thread starter Tigers of Old
- Start date
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
suggesting to trade anyone is dumb, just bcos a kid who has played 10 games is showing something
its called depth. players fight for the same spot. it creates a good teamTigerForce said:
suggesting to trade anyone is dumb, just bcos a kid who has played 10 games is showing something
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Trading is dumb?? First time I've heard that.
If our coaches need someone more skilful and strong bodied in defence, then he's the 1st trade IMO.
We've had too many sticks in defence for too long. Moore has been the only KPD player to beef up in the last few years when starting with us.
the push up king said:
Trading is dumb?? First time I've heard that.
If our coaches need someone more skilful and strong bodied in defence, then he's the 1st trade IMO.
We've had too many sticks in defence for too long. Moore has been the only KPD player to beef up in the last few years when starting with us.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
let astbury become established before any trades are made thats all. i used to bash him around, but luke has improved a fair way, defensive skill cannot be put up against muscle size. your born with talent, players can build muscle, they can compete for the same spot, what happens if moore, will or ast gets injured, once luke is traded like you suggested, who steps in??
let astbury become established before any trades are made thats all. i used to bash him around, but luke has improved a fair way, defensive skill cannot be put up against muscle size. your born with talent, players can build muscle, they can compete for the same spot, what happens if moore, will or ast gets injured, once luke is traded like you suggested, who steps in??
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
You would hope that Astbury was improving, I certainly like him, but as back he still has a way to go. Sorry TF, can't buy that one yet!
TigerForce said:
You would hope that Astbury was improving, I certainly like him, but as back he still has a way to go. Sorry TF, can't buy that one yet!
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Yep, always had you picked as a Bi-lo shopper :hihi
How's the scratches on the Range Rover :-X
TigerForce said:
Yep, always had you picked as a Bi-lo shopper :hihi
How's the scratches on the Range Rover :-X
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Not on exposed form, hope maybe, but not on exposed.,,,,,
skybeau said:
Not on exposed form, hope maybe, but not on exposed.,,,,,
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Perhaps, but name any team who can effectively cover the loss of multiple players in a particular position (Geelong aside, perhaps). And the only way we'll find out whether these hopes have basis is to play the buggers!
The thing is, we're in a position where we have a few key defenders and could afford to trade one. McGuane (or maybe Rance) would be the ones with currency that we could replace.
Phar Ace said:
Perhaps, but name any team who can effectively cover the loss of multiple players in a particular position (Geelong aside, perhaps). And the only way we'll find out whether these hopes have basis is to play the buggers!
The thing is, we're in a position where we have a few key defenders and could afford to trade one. McGuane (or maybe Rance) would be the ones with currency that we could replace.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
Agree with playing them, no reason not to in this and next season, but you don't have to trade one to play another.
So you trade away your notes but keep your coins? I doubt we'd trade for someone better, sadly.
skybeau said:
Agree with playing them, no reason not to in this and next season, but you don't have to trade one to play another.
skybeau said:
So you trade away your notes but keep your coins? I doubt we'd trade for someone better, sadly.
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I don't drive lounge room army tanks on the road. ;D
Why should it be? Two different people. Comparing their 1st years, I reckon Astbury's shown more value
Phar Ace said:
I don't drive lounge room army tanks on the road. ;D
se7en said:
Why should it be? Two different people. Comparing their 1st years, I reckon Astbury's shown more value
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I have to admit, the fact that the back 6 look settled without him and they're throwing him up forward to experiment means he'd be ideal tradebait.
With Grimes & Gourdis developing as additional younger defenders, we'd be crazy not to trade him for a decent pick
I have to admit, the fact that the back 6 look settled without him and they're throwing him up forward to experiment means he'd be ideal tradebait.
With Grimes & Gourdis developing as additional younger defenders, we'd be crazy not to trade him for a decent pick
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
I can feel another Tuck-trade moment coming on......................
ZeroGame said:
I can feel another Tuck-trade moment coming on......................
Re: Luke McGuane = Guts
The back 6 looked much more solid in the third term when Luke was back there taking the most dangerous forward. Agreed he wasnt brilliant up forward but is still a vital part of our team in the future. Sometimes wonder whether people actually watch the game or just post rehearsed comments on here.
The back 6 looked much more solid in the third term when Luke was back there taking the most dangerous forward. Agreed he wasnt brilliant up forward but is still a vital part of our team in the future. Sometimes wonder whether people actually watch the game or just post rehearsed comments on here.
<
Changes v Freo
|
The news cycle
>
