The whole density thing in and around transport hubs makes sense on face value eg Camberwell, Ringwood whatever. But the reality is that unlike places like NYC, Paris, London etc we do not have the high level PT coverage like they do. You can just about get anywhere in those cities on PT. Not so in Melbourne.
To that end, people in apartments still require a car - or at least they seem to feel they do.
Must admit, pretty hard to go to Bunnings or IKEA or take the kids to some schools out in the burbs on a train or tram, or get to a golf course or whatever on PT.
Places like Camberwell - Bourke Road are traffic disasters already so can't imagine what'll be like with heaps of 9 storey apartments. You won't be able to get in or out by car. You won't be able to park anywhere if you can.
Real issue is a lack of PT investment that should have started 50 years ago (or more).
The thing is that they need to have a look at what is being built.
In my area they have built a couple of 12 storey apartment blocks on a main road. They were talking about this on the radio and someone rang in stating that most of the apartments in the latest high rise have not sold, they can't get rid of them at the price they are willing to sell. Now, you have to ask, why is this? Well, look at the apartments they build. Little 1 bedroom closets that no-one buys to live in and no-one wants to rent.
What they need to be looking at is how we get more density without completely screwing up the suburbs.
They need to look at European cities. In the middle of Paris or Madrid you see 6 storey apartment blocks. They are built around a courtyard which means natural light from both directions. They have 2 and 3 bedroom apartments where you can actually raise a kid or two. That is what can fix the housing crisis, not the profit driven crap that is being put up at the moment.
Also, the development needs to be appropriate. My street is mainly houses. There are a couple of 70s, 80s apartment blocks (3 storeys) but the rest is mainly single storey houses dating back to the 1880s/1890s boom, plus some later ones which look to be 1930s-1940s. But, we are close to a main road. Now our council, or more accurately the development is good bureaucrats, want to see high rise apartments all over the place. When we object they claim we don't understand the housing shortages. But just about everyone I have talked to has no problem with, say, 4 storey apartments with decent sized dwellings, along main roads. It is the high rises full of 1 bedroom cupboards that we all object to.
Plus, the way that Australian governments have abandoned social housing was always going to be a disaster. And, so it has turned out. Build more social housing. Not far from me they pulled down some of the old 3 storey commission flats and replaced them with new 3 storey flats, I hope they are still social housing. This is what needs to be done on a very large scale - build social housing, heaps of it, now.
DS