Ivan Soldo | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Ivan Soldo

good game today. making progress. won the hitouts and starting to get connection with our onballers, a number of taps were well placed.
was involved when it hit the grass.
he is building
Best game Soldo has played for us.
Liked how he pressured and blocked.
Would be unlucky to be dropped, prefer him ever so slightly at this stage to Chol.
While he and Nank would make us a little lumbering, I wouldn’t mind seeing them up against Grundy. I reckon they would wear him down, which would give us a real advantage.
 
Last edited:
Good 2nd half by Soldo, did little around the ground in the first half. Need Nanks back for Grundy. He'll be better around the ground, Soldo will be destroyed. Credit though, Soldo has fought hard, if only he could do a lot more than tap ruck.
 
Good 2nd half by Soldo, did little around the ground in the first half. Need Nanks back for Grundy. He'll be better around the ground, Soldo will be destroyed. Credit though, Soldo has fought hard, if only he could do a lot more than tap ruck.

He took some key marks and was pretty good around the ground. even managed to hit a few spot up targets. Nank cant do the thing he is in the side for - ruck. Its fine if neither guys are the answer going forward but Nank cant escape the same criticism that Soldo gets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
He took some key marks and was pretty good around the ground. even managed to hit a few spot up targets. Nank cant do the thing he is in the side for - ruck. Its fine if neither guys are the answer going forward but Nank cant escape the same criticism that Soldo gets.

Nanks has proven himself over and over, that is why he doesn't and shouldn't get the same criticism. No doubt he's been beaten in some games and his performance is discussed. But surely you're not comparing Soldo to Nanks? Soldo had 2 disposals at half time. He improved immensely in the 2nd half but the game he played is the minimum he needs to do each week. As I said I was encouraged but I don't like his chances around the ground against Grundy. The only question mark on Nanks is whether he is fit enough at this stage. On that basis SOldo may still get a gig for Collingwood game.

Career starts thus far: https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy...2=15&type=A&pid1=4141&pid2=3952&fid1=C&fid2=C

Nanks is only 18 months older than Soldo.
 
He took some key marks and was pretty good around the ground. even managed to hit a few spot up targets. Nank cant do the thing he is in the side for - ruck. Its fine if neither guys are the answer going forward but Nank cant escape the same criticism that Soldo gets.

Dead on. Nank is decent around the ground, but his ruck opponent is routinely BOG.
 
Dead on. Nank is decent around the ground, but his ruck opponent is routinely BOG.
I'm another supporter of this viewpoint. We need a stronger first ruckman, Soldo has shown some promise of recent times.

For me Soldo stays in and the ruck/forward position is between Chol and Nank. I am torn on the choice here, Chol deserves the opportunity right now, but it would be good to see if Soldo and Nank can work against Grundy. Particularly given how GWS went with two genuine rucks against Grundy.

Nank would need have a really strong showing in the two's, otherwise I would leave it unchanged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Soldo at bounces,chol tagging grundy would be my plan,grundy has been beaten by tags before,ps nank got 29 touches again grundy in 2018 first match.
 
The big fella is a fine back up ruck. Euro Hampson. Moe Hampson. I like him. Made a good ruck in Lycett earns his cheque.


Cheap get via the cat B rookies. Need to go again in this field.
 
The big fella is a fine back up ruck. Euro Hampson. Moe Hampson. I like him. Made a good ruck in Lycett earns his cheque.


Cheap get via the cat B rookies. Need to go again in this field.
I would love for someone to compare the stats for this year comparing Nank v Soldo. In particular hit outs, hit outs to advantages, clearances etc etc. Soldo is a definitely a keeper and will get heaps better the more he plays
 
Would double team grundy this week with nank and soldo 50 50 game time. Rest up and hit him hard.
 
His improvement has been unbelievable.
He is dropping back and taking intercept marks.
He works hard both ends.
Ports ruckman cost port 600k and i reckon Soldo had him covered.
 
Lycett has had an awesome season. I reckon Soldo took the chocolates yesterday.
Nank likely comes back in but it's not so straight forward. Soldo has made the most of his opportunities over this period.
 
The big fella is a fine back up ruck. Euro Hampson. Moe Hampson. I like him. Made a good ruck in Lycett earns his cheque.


Cheap get via the cat B rookies. Need to go again in this field.

Lycett has had an awesome season. I reckon Soldo took the chocolates yesterday.
Nank likely comes back in but it's not so straight forward. Soldo has made the most of his opportunities over this period.

The reality of the footy world these days is that if blokes don't get game time where they're at.... they're gonna go looking for it elsewhere.
Using the 'crisis creates opportunity' philosophy and although he ain't no superstar, if nothing else little Ivan is building a bit of currency and should he or the club at some point decide his future is best served in other colours, we have some bargaining power.
Clubs always pay overs for ruckmen who've been in the system for a few years.
 
Hitouts should be viewed in the context of the multiple possessions that occur afterwards, as pressure around the contest has completely changed the game in recent years.

You’ve got a pack of fresh and focused players all watching the ruck contest waiting to pounce with a tackle, knock, or pressure. It’s nearly impossible for any ruckman to:

1. Tap the ball cleanly
2. down to a teammate
3. who delivers the ball to another teammate
4. forward of the contest.

This happens cleanly like once or twice a game and it seems to happen in reverse just as frequently:

1.Tap the ball cleanly
2. down to opposition
3. who delivers the ball to another teammate
4. forward of the contest.

Usually whenever this string of events occurs, it’s the result of randomness or an act of pure brilliance by a midfielder capable of turning randomness into favour.

It drives me nuts how blind I am at not seeing whatever a ruckmen is supposedly doing in ruck contests.

Null hypothesis not rejected.

In Soldo’s first game this year, I praised him for doing 5-6 unique things around the ground (big mark in defence, up forward, a tackle, a chain possession, etc). He didn’t do much, but everything he did required a different skill.

His marking and spoiling around the ground is getting better, and he’s still displaying a well-rounded range of other efforts at low quantity, so it’ll be promising if he continues this trajectory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
From “dud delist” to “keep him in the seniors” within weeks... Dramatic & abrupt change in sentiment
 
Null hypothesis not rejected.
Null Hypothesis used to run our local fish and chip shop in Oakleigh.

He used to pass mullet off as whiting – had a special recipe for batter that made one species taste like another. But it made scallops taste like Tarzan's Grip.

I still miss Null – he was run over by a neighbour driving a Valiant with purple seat covers and venetian blinds across the back window.

The Valiant was Null's, and the neighbour was stealing it when Null came home unexpectedly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users