zippadeee said:Lyon isn't any good.
It's interesting. From nine seasons, he's missed the finals once - 9th in his first year at St.Kilda. Six top four finishes, a 6th and a 7th.
He has the second-best record among 150-game coaches, but his win rate is inflated by fielding far older teams than his opposition. Have to wonder how far down the list he'd fall if he had to endure a rebuild (Roos quickly coming back towards a 50/50 record despite enjoying the second-biggest age advantage).
Coach M W L D Win % ADiff
-----------------------------------------------
Reynolds, *smile* 417 277 134 6 67.15 +0.15
Lyon, Ross 218 143 70 5 66.74 +1.10
McHale, Jock 714 467 237 10 66.11 -0.51
Hughes senior, Frank 378 244 130 4 65.08 -0.38
Hafey, Tom 522 336 182 4 64.75 +0.23
Clarkson, Alastair 258 162 96 1 62.98 -0.30
Jeans, Allan 575 357 216 2 62.26 +0.52
Joyce, Alan 150 92 56 2 62.00 +0.52
Thompson, Mark 283 173 106 4 61.84 -0.13
Bentley, Percy 414 253 156 5 61.71 +0.71
Clark, Norman 214 128 80 6 61.21 +0.16
Hickey, Reg 304 184 117 3 61.02 -0.22
Dyer senior, Jack 222 134 86 2 60.81 -0.13
Worrall, John 279 165 110 4 59.86 +0.67
Kyne, Phonse 272 161 109 2 59.56 -0.41
Parkin, David 518 306 210 2 59.27 +0.64
Matthews, Leigh 461 267 186 8 58.79 -0.06
Rose, Bob 282 163 115 4 58.51 -0.62
Kennedy, John J. 412 236 171 5 57.89 -0.44
Sheedy, Kevin 679 389 283 7 57.81 -0.09
Malthouse, Mick 718 406 305 7 57.03 -0.24
Smith, Norm W. 452 253 192 7 56.75 +0.13
Minogue, Dan 362 203 157 2 56.35 +0.33
Blight, Malcolm 250 139 111 0 55.60 +0.12
Williams, Mark M. 274 151 121 2 55.47 +0.31
Ayres, Gary 223 120 102 1 54.04 +0.39
Barassi, Ron D. 515 276 235 4 53.98 +0.31
Worsfold, John 281 149 130 2 53.38 -0.62
Craig, Neil 177 93 84 0 52.54 +0.60
Eade, Rodney 336 173 158 5 52.23 +0.43
Roos, Paul 246 127 117 2 52.03 +0.70
Sutton, Charlie 162 82 78 2 51.23 -0.36
Pagan, Denis 344 175 167 2 51.16 +0.38
Northey, John 315 157 154 4 50.48 -0.71
Daniher, Neale 223 108 114 1 48.65 -0.12
Wallace, Terry 247 116 127 4 47.77 +0.19
Walls, Robert 347 162 183 2 46.97 -0.11
Carter, F. Wally 219 98 120 1 44.98 +0.17
Hale, Jack 174 70 103 1 40.52 -0.23
Whitten senior, Ted 228 91 137 0 39.91 -0.81
Stephen, Bill 258 84 172 2 32.95 -0.08