Changes V Brisbane | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Changes V Brisbane

I don't think Ryans form can be judged on how he plays on a very wet day. Very difficult conditions for a man of his size.

Ryan has so much ticker, he is a VIP.

I dont want him to ever play vfl again
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Obviously its a fair time to the Brissy game, but at this stage I'd probably be:

Out Ryan (injured), Clarke
In Pickett, Hopper

Clarke to sub. Huog must play 2's next weekend. Has barely played any footy recently and was rubbish when he came on on Saturday.
 
Just having a sook about the fixture. We are coming off a bye, while they are on a 6 day break. I think that’s wrong. We should be playing a team that is also returning from the bye. It’s a massive advantage to Brisbane and we have been slow starters this year. We could potentially give Brisbane a 4-5 goal head start and its all over.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 5 users
Just having a sook about the fixture. We are coming off a bye, while they are on a 6 day break. I think that’s wrong. We should be playing a team that is also returning from the bye. It’s a massive advantage to Brisbane and we have been slow starters this year. We could potentially give Brisbane a 4-5 goal head start and its all over.
Only 1 team has won coming off the bye. And that was the Saints who defeated Sydney whom were also coming off the bye.

I cant understand why they need to span the bye's over 4 weeks. It should be 2 weeks max.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 2 users
Only 1 team has won coming off the bye. And that was the Saints who defeated Sydney whom were also coming off the bye.

I cant understand why they need to span the bye's over 4 weeks. It should be 2 weeks max.

I hate split rounds with a passion, and I’ve been saying for years everyone should have the bye on the same week. But the AFL are greedy and won’t allow a stand alone week. But there is a simple solution to this… start the AFLW season during AFL bye week. To me it’s a no brainer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
That's just not gonna happen CT, Pickett, and Hopper will come into the side.
Yeah, I know.

I don't think we should though.

Who goes out of the midfield for Hopper? Cotchy can't go forward again. And Hopper's been out for 5 weeks with a calf. Does it hurt for him to play a half in the VFL?

Pickett is a conundrum. For a lot of reasons. The best option is for him to replace MRJ as the pressure forward. How much of a bonus is that?

I just don't like unforced changes to winning sides.
 
Yeah, I know.

I don't think we should though.

Who goes out of the midfield for Hopper? Cotchy can't go forward again. And Hopper's been out for 5 weeks with a calf. Does it hurt for him to play a half in the VFL?

Pickett is a conundrum. For a lot of reasons. The best option is for him to replace MRJ as the pressure forward. How much of a bonus is that?

I just don't like unforced changes to winning sides.
Good problem to have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Yeah, I know.

I don't think we should though.

Who goes out of the midfield for Hopper? Cotchy can't go forward again. And Hopper's been out for 5 weeks with a calf. Does it hurt for him to play a half in the VFL?

Pickett is a conundrum. For a lot of reasons. The best option is for him to replace MRJ as the pressure forward. How much of a bonus is that?

I just don't like unforced changes to winning sides.

You make some valid points but you just know Pickett comes in. It's a tough one as much as I think MRJ should stay in, he or Juddy make way. Hopper, I would start at half-forward. Sure it wouldn't hurt for one game back in the ressies but I think the match committee will put him straight back in.

Ralphsmith needs a full game and no doubt he will go back to the ressies.

Ryan, I rate highly but he may go out due to injury. Also, miller can't go out after that performance, played a very good game.

It could well be Pickett and Hopper in (I expect Cumberland will play a full game in the ressies) and Juddy and Ryan out.

Good to see more players coming back, adds to our depth. Players competing for spots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I reckon it will be:
Out- Ryan (inj) MRjr
In- Hopper, PIckett.

Sub will be interesting- couldnt be Hugo again, surely (and probably shouldnt be a half back flanker anyway).
That leaves MRJr, Sonsie, Cumberland, Banks, Brown, Dow, Green, Tresize and Coulthard.

Assuming its not a debutante, or Dow, leaves Sonsie, Cumberland or MRJr.
I'll guess Cumberland.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I reckon it will be:
Out- Ryan (inj) MRjr
In- Hopper, PIckett.

Sub will be interesting- couldnt be Hugo again, surely (and probably shouldnt be a half back flanker anyway).
That leaves MRJr, Sonsie, Cumberland, Banks, Brown, Dow, Green, Tresize and Coulthard.

Assuming its not a debutante, or Dow, leaves Sonsie, Cumberland or MRJr.
I'll guess Cumberland.

I would drop Juddy to sub. Hugo a full game in the magoos. Leave MRJ in
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Out - Ryan (Inj) & Clarke

In - Pickett & Hopper

Hopper is a pro and his clean hands and big body will be useful in close at the Gabba. Cotch gets used for impact because that's what he does, impact.

MRJ is finally fit and well overdue for a breakout game. Having Marlion helping bring the ball to ground and his creativity gives us a very scary look in the forward line. I'm looking forward to Marlion and Maurice working in tandem.

Clarke sub.

Ralphsmith, Sonsie, Cumbo, Banks, Brown and the others need to smash the door down in the twos and/or be ready to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I’m really looking forward to what Hopper brings when he comes back. He has seen his mate killing it and I hope he wants to follow.
His form pre injury was pretty good, not stellar, but I suspect he is capable of much more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Only 1 team has won coming off the bye. And that was the Saints who defeated Sydney whom were also coming off the bye.

I cant understand why they need to span the bye's over 4 weeks. It should be 2 weeks max.

Broadcast rights.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I hate split rounds with a passion, and I’ve been saying for years everyone should have the bye on the same week. But the AFL are greedy and won’t allow a stand alone week. But there is a simple solution to this… start the AFLW season during AFL bye week. To me it’s a no brainer.
Totally agree. Turn it into a support local footy week or have an AFLW all stars game. There’s a lot they can do with it. That way everyone comes back fresh and no one whinges about playing a team off a short break. They used to do it this way. They’ve got an extra round now with Magi…sorry Gather Round, so they don’t lose revenue, either.