To a point, so am I. Just careful not to fall in love with a past player as coach. Yes Tommy worked well. However, our procession of ex players weren’t great. Possibly for a number of different reasons. Tony Jewell got us a flag but didn’t have a long stint as coach. John Northey got the best out of our list. But we have had a lot of others with not much success. Bones Richardson, KB, Paul Sproule, Saint Francis etc. By all accounts though, Newy has been going ok and he would be strong on discipline. Pretty sure he initiated the “jumper does not touch the floor after a game as it has to be respected”.
Most of the successful coaches of late have coached well at clubs where they did not play. Matthews, Sheedy, Malthouse, Hardwick.