Are you concerned by Draper's kicking? I see a player who has a tendency to kick floaters without much depth. Knowing FJ's penchant for good kicks I can understand the reluctance. Smillie is a better kick than Draper, that to me will be the deciding factor.
His kicking isn't a strength. It's certainly passable once you consider everything else be brings.
Guys with his power, strength, cleanliness and burst are gold. They put the opposition on the back foot and open the game up with scoring chains your way. Not many in this draft can and he's the best at it.
He also has a fantastic body of work behind him. Only Jagga rivals him.
SA under 16 and under 18 captain
SA under 18 MVP (in underage year)
Under 18 All Aus (in underage year) and also this year.
Captain South Adel under 18 premiership and was BOG in GF (in underage year).
He then had no pre-season (knee and hip flexor) that ate into the early rounds this season. Yet doesn't seem to get the alibies that Lalor and FoS get with similar (or less) setbacks. For a guy who's elite trait is power, agility and pace that shouldn't be under estimated - Dont forget he tested number 1 for agility in the country last year.
Finally, once he started to get fit his performances for South Adelaide are underrated. That is a strong comp (better than VFL) and he was almost a lone hand in a poor team. He averaged tick over 22 possessions, 4.7 clearances and 6.2 tackles. On that he's a ripper tackler and again one of the few this draft with the pace and strength to track back from a clearances and apply pressure.
Comparing him above to Smillie, he schools Big Willie for workrate. His repeat efforts when fully fit are outstanding. Rather take that and have slightly less kicking, which are largely down to the pace he is often going when kicking it anyway.
Seems the club doesn't agree but it would be a no brainer for leysy to take him ahead of Smillie if he gets through - which is an outside chance if Crows go Langford ahead of him. Said all year he deserves to be alongside the other very top end mids.
He'll also play and impact earlier than probably everyone else in this draft.