Sen1116Harvey Langford a tiger supporter
Exactly.We'd have to be the slowest midfield in the comp.We also need speed and evasion out of the middle. Did you see the Giants just slice through us yesterday and we couldn't do it going back the other way? The only one that could was when Shai went into the middle in the final quarter when TT went down injured.
Our midfield is collectively too slow.
There is no problem having TT and Hopper in there, and Prestia used to be quick, but when you surround them with Graham, Baker etc, we are just too slow. If the latter 2 leave, then we have open spots to bring in speedier players. I think this is 1 of the reasons why Dow was given so much time, he has evasiveness, he just doesn't know how to really use it and generally has too many other deficiencies, but the type of player is what we need. Balancing a midfield going into next year with McAuliffe (after a big pre-season) and 1 or 2 of Smith, FOS, Draper, Reid, maybe even Hotton etc, changes the dynamic of our midfield and allows us to use Bolton as a burst midfielder in there for 5-10 mins per quarter to rip the game open.
Berry reminds me of the Swans pest Papley.Good stuff BT.
On why Lalor moved away from Mick Jagga. Far more likely he just doesn't have the tank to play long midfield minutes yet in a fast open game like yesterday.
Reckon that's why he has pretty divided opinions. Those that think he's fine aerobically and it's purely because of his limited prep Vs those who have a question mark on that area of his game and if it will translate to being a midfielder at AFL level or a forward who spends time in there.
And agree we need Kako's type. Am not convinced on him. Tidy little player sure - But is he actually that quick? Which he'll need to be.
Much prefer Berry in that type of role. He will probably go higher as well though.
Thanks Tobie.Hey all, first time poster.
I've followed the draft closely for a number of years (but defs not a know it all).
I love this draft, and I think it's the best depth I've seen for a very long time. There's a lot of players I'd be happy with for us, however I think Tobie Travaglia and his quality is being slept on a little bit.
He was massive as a defender for country, however for the pioneers he's been playing fwd / mid so he's one of the most versatile players in the pool. He kicked 3 from 28 touches and nearly got Bendigo home single-handedly in his last game for them. Excellent decision maker and skill level, has burst and speed and is awesome overhead. Also has been captain so highly regarded leader. He would be in my top 5 at the moment.
My view is we need either midfielders with burst and skill, any forward with craft, and more key fwd talent. This draft has great options in all those areas.
None whatsoever.
Theres a greater chance of joe bidenwinning the olympic 100m gold in parisremembering his name
Lalor walks on water will be next.lolyour jumping the shark now
you honestly must be watching the wrong bloke?
Blue No.9
Lalor walks on water will be next.lol
Agree with your reference to Shai.We also need speed and evasion out of the middle. Did you see the Giants just slice through us yesterday and we couldn't do it going back the other way? The only one that could was when Shai went into the middle in the final quarter when TT went down injured.
Our midfield is collectively too slow.
There is no problem having TT and Hopper in there, and Prestia used to be quick, but when you surround them with Graham, Baker etc, we are just too slow. If the latter 2 leave, then we have open spots to bring in speedier players. I think this is 1 of the reasons why Dow was given so much time, he has evasiveness, he just doesn't know how to really use it and generally has too many other deficiencies, but the type of player is what we need. Balancing a midfield going into next year with McAuliffe (after a big pre-season) and 1 or 2 of Smith, FOS, Draper, Reid, maybe even Hotton etc, changes the dynamic of our midfield and allows us to use Bolton as a burst midfielder in there for 5-10 mins per quarter to rip the game open.
Sundays game was the most he's kicked ,and looking at the replay again ,he was up against Langford for a fair bit of the match ,and easily beat him for speed around the stoppages and around the ground .jagga averaged 28 disposals and 3.5 tackles from 10 games in his bottom age Coates year
this year he's 31 disposals and 3 tackles average from 5 games.
over 2 years, he tackles 3.3 times a game
this is more than Dusty (2.7) or $hai (2.9).
close to Sam Walsh(4) and exactly the same as Zac Butters (3.3)
so hes not a prolific tackler (draper got 10 against men on weekend), but the data says he tackles commensurate with his role.
lets look at some kicking Penetration data?
a crude dividing metres gained by number of kicks.
jagga average kick length on Sunday was 27m.
on the same day, Lachy Whitfield was 18m, Jayden Short was 24m, Dion Prestia was 16m and dan Rioli 23m
that data set says myth pretty busted.
which brings us to weight?
they dont tell us weights anymore, but hes about Zac butters and Shai Bolton sized
none are colossal. But if its speed you need, you dont do bench press.
and I really dont see its relevant when a bloke is demonstrably prolific and durable
Langford is slow to react ,good work ethic ,but very one paced .I think Lalor is a ripper.
Could hardly be a more different mid to jagga though.
they're not comparable.
I'd like both.
but I do think Langford and Lalor are very comparable, and i'd take Langford first,
without much confidence
Sundays game was the most he's kicked ,and looking at the replay again ,he was up against Langford for a fair bit of the match ,and easily beat him for speed around the stoppages and around the ground .
The only one who contained him and kept pressure on him was Lalor ,and he struggled with it ,as he did against SA when the heat was on in the first half of that match .
The AFL as you know is a huge jump in pressure and physicality ,he is not going to get that sort easy free wheeling he gets at under 18 level,and a lot of his possessions are little dinky ones .
As for picking him at no 1 NO WAY ,we are going to disagree on Jagga ,,Bowie but thats life.
Langford is slow to react ,good work ethic ,but very one paced .
I need to see how the year finishes ,at the moment l could have up to 5 player's at no1.who would you take if you were picking at 1,
and who do you reckon Tigers would call out if the draft was this arvo?
I dont see him that way, but egg on my face with the > lalor call quite a possibility
ive seen enough of the mids now (except lalor and FOS and hotton, who complicate things)
im gonna try split the FF's namely Armstrong/sims/J whitlock
there seems a bit of chemistry between jagga and sims to me?
I heard him too on SEN, but then again so was Sonz.....Harvey Langford a tiger supporter
That was me. Takes a real good pressure mark. No problems when he has to stand under it. Can play ruck or forward.Someone previously mentioned Kayle Gerreyn.I’d love him at the tigers.Big,aggressive,lovely hands and neat disposal.Could shoot up the boards if he finishes strongly in the wafl.
Agree with your reference to Shai.
But TT and Hopper in together are just too slow to keep up with midfields like Port, Sydney, Brisbane, GC Collingwood, GWS even Melbourne. Throw Prestia or Graham in with those two and the net result is even slower. And you want to trade Rioli. No thanks.