2023 mid-season rookie draft | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2023 mid-season rookie draft

So what needs to be done to get George off the list FFS. He has retired, doesn't show up at the club, not playing. I will complete the form myself!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
. No point just picking a kid for the sake of if .

on the face of it, this seems obviously true.

but if we signed ben Miller until 2024,

and Gold Coast sign Tom Berry for 2 years,

then there sort of becomes a point in picking a kid just for the sake of it?

my point is,

there must be a talent shortage? tom berry, Patrick Naish, Josh Schache, Jake Stein, Jed Anderson, Rory Atkins, James Tsitas, Tyler Brown, Jack Bowes etc, etc, etc. VFL players on AFL wages. theres dozens of them.

and its going to get 5-10% worse from 2025 with the Tasmanian devils.

so its a numbers game.

I think a high rotation of kids would be a legitimate strategy to find talent.

reserve half a dozen spots on your list for speculative 2 year contracts, bring in 3 a year and probably 3 off every second year.

like gold panning

to many players get 8 years on $300K to demonstrate they aren't good enough when they were clearly never gonna be.

you come out way ahead if you speculate on someone like Ben Miller cheaply (in terms of draft picks - rookie, SSP, mid-season) and they are on and off the list in 2 years
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Squads for the 2 "Young Guns" games played in the lead up to the mid season draft.

"HOW TO WATCH: Both games in the 2023 Young Guns Series will be available to watch live and free here."

YOUNG GUNS SERIES – GAME 1
Young Guns vs Victoria Metro U18
Sunday, May 7 at 11:00am
Trevor Barker Beach Oval



YOUNG GUNS​

#NAMESURNAMEDOBHTSTATE LEAGUE CLUBCOMMUNITY CLUB
1BeauTedcastle20-03-04177Richmond (VFL)St Mary’s
2MitchSzybkowski09-01-04185Frankston (VFL)Beaconsfield
3JoziahNannup01-11-04183Dandenong StingraysDoveton
4TomBower20-08-04180Oakleigh ChargersGlen Waverley Rovers
5PaddyCross14-02-03182Casey Demons (VFL)Nar Nar Goon
6MichaelKiraly09-01-04186Bendigo PioneersMacleod
8RyePenny01-03-04186Calder CannonsGisborne
9ArchieSinnott28-07-04186Geelong FalconsNewtown & Chilwell
10JeddLongmire14-06-04188Collingwood (VFL)/Murray BushrangersBundoora
11NicholasNewton13-05-04187Murray BushrangersLavington
12JackCleaver22-05-04188Essendon (VFL)St Bernards
13EthanStanley13-11-03188Box Hill Hawks (VFL)Frankston YCW
14LukeTeal20-05-04190Richmond (VFL)/Oakleigh ChargersGlen Iris
15TomStern23-06-04191Gippsland PowerWarragul
18RyanMaric06-09-04193Gippsland PowerDrouin
20ZiggyToledo-Glasman15-04-04192Dandenong StingraysMt Eliza
21MitchDodos03-11-04196Bendigo PioneersKyabram
22HamishPierson03-11-04195Geelong FalconsGrovedale Tigers
24JovanPetric17-04-04197Western JetsKeilor
25ArcherMay27-08-04199Richmond (VFL)/Sandringham DragonsSt Kilda City
26LeviYoung15-01-04199Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
28WilliamElliott11-06-04203Oakleigh ChargersSurrey Park
29ClayTucker09-08-04204Eastern RangesRowville
30FlynnRiley05-04-04206Northern KnightsMontmorency


VICTORIA METRO​

#NAMESURNAMEDOBHTSTATE LEAGUE CLUBCOMMUNITY CLUB
1IsaacKako07-03-06175Calder CannonsPascoe Vale
2TajHotton17-06-06177Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
3TarkynO'Leary01-07-05178Sandringham DragonsParkdale Vultures
4JoshDocking14-10-05178Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
5CalebWindsor09-07-05183Eastern RangesLysterfield
6KynanBrown13-01-05180Oakleigh ChargersBlackburn
7MahmoudTaha04-11-05182Calder CannonsPascoe Vale
8NathanPhilactides10-01-05180Oakleigh ChargersBlackburn
9CameronNyko25-11-05180Eastern RangesHealesville
10ZakJohnson24-12-06185Northern KnightsSt Mary’s
11HarveyJohnston18-08-05184Sandringham DragonsParkdale Vultures
12ArchieRoberts18-11-05183Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
14LuccaGrego15-09-06183Western JetsBacchus Marsh
15CharltonHarrop13-07-05186Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
16JakeSmith24-07-05188Western JetsWilliamstown CYMS
17RyanEyre19-03-05191Calder CannonsKilmore
18CooperTrembath17-10-05192Eastern RangesPark Orchards
19WilliamBrown16-06-05193Sandringham DragonsEast Brighton
20CalsherDear04-08-05194Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
22RemyMaclean14-10-05194Eastern RangesEast Ringwood
23ChristianMardini18-06-05197Northern KnightsBundoora
24JordanCroft12-05-05200Calder CannonsMaribyrnong Park
26RileyWeatherill21-11-05195Eastern RangesEast Ringwood
27WilliamGreen08-09-05202Northern KnightsNorthcote
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
MID-SEASON DRAFT WHISPERS

"The fifth mid-season draft of the 21st century will be held at the end of this month. Although there seems to be less buzz and fanfare around it compared to past mid-year rookie drafts."

"The AFL recently confirmed the Young Guns squad for its upcoming two-game series against Vic Metro and Vic Country Under 18 teams. Strong performances in these games by Jai Culley (West Coast), Massimo D‘Ambrosio (Essendon) and Max Ramsden (Hawthorn) helped the trio get drafted 12 months ago.

Of the players named in the Young Guns squad, Gippsland Power’s Ryan Maric (193cm) excites recruiters the most with his goal nous and efficient kick.

This time last year, the hybrid forward was playing country football for Drouin in the Gippsland League. At the end of this month, he could be among the first two players taken in the mid-season AFL draft.

There’s also some hype around 204cm Eastern Ranges ruck Clay Tuckerand 203cm Oakleigh Chargers big man William Elliott – the son of former Australian Test cricketer Matthew Elliott – considering the array of injuries to rucks at AFL clubs this season.

Beau Tedcastle (177cm, Richmond VFL), Rye Penny (186cm, Calder Cannons), Nicholas Newton (187cm Murray Bushrangers), Ethan Stanley(188cm, Box Hill Hawks) and Luke Teal (190cm, Richmond VFL) are other Young Guns players in the mid-season draft mix. Teal, a mid-sized defender, was considered one of the unluckiest not to get picked up in last year‘s drafts.

Of the state league players in the mid-season draft mix, luckless ex-Swan Sam Naismith is a good chance to get picked up."

After three knee reconstructions during his stint at Sydney, Naismith linked up with Port Melbourne, where he’s become one of the VFL’s most dominant rucks. He produced his best game yet against the Giants last weekend, finishing with 24 disposals, eight clearances, six tackles and 38 hit-outs. Recruiters linked Naismith to Geelong, Collingwood and even Sydney ahead of the mid-season draft.

Other VFL players clubs are reportedly keeping tabs on are Williamstown duo Oscar McDonald (ex-Melbourne and Carlton) and Marty Hore (ex-Melbourne), Frankston’s Ryley Stoddart (ex-Sydney) and Box Hill’s Callum Brown (ex-Collingwood), while Essendon could consider upgrading key defender Jack Cleaver from its VFL list.

North Adelaide 191cm forward Noah Casalini, who won the best on ground medal for six-goal, 10-mark display in an Anzac Day victory over Norwood, is one of the SANFL’s best chances, while 199cm Claremont key forward Jack Buller reportedly has interest from the two WA clubs."

 
Mitch Owens brother Kai (who plays at Frankston) is getting talked up too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Any WAFL watchers know anything about Rueben McGuire 196cm 94 kg 21 year old indigenous player from East Fremantle .
He has a good leap and strong mark ,l see the Bombers where interested in him training at the club,but he decided to stay and play at Easts .
 
What do people think of Oscar McDonald from Williamstown?

Playing a good intercepting game. Looks skilled. Can mark. Tall.
 
dont we have a spot with George's retirement ?
I'd bet we do have a spot.
The article is referencing the AFL list lodgement from the start of the season, and I'd guess its not officially updated until just before the msd.
That gives a better media release
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
So Hawks will take a big ruck.
North ?
Eagles ? Maybe Buller. They could do with a mature onballer to help cover their next few years which will be muserable
 
Squads for the 2 "Young Guns" games played in the lead up to the mid season draft.

"HOW TO WATCH: Both games in the 2023 Young Guns Series will be available to watch live and free here."

YOUNG GUNS SERIES – GAME 1
Young Guns vs Victoria Metro U18
Sunday, May 7 at 11:00am
Trevor Barker Beach Oval



YOUNG GUNS​

#NAMESURNAMEDOBHTSTATE LEAGUE CLUBCOMMUNITY CLUB
1BeauTedcastle20-03-04177Richmond (VFL)St Mary’s
2MitchSzybkowski09-01-04185Frankston (VFL)Beaconsfield
3JoziahNannup01-11-04183Dandenong StingraysDoveton
4TomBower20-08-04180Oakleigh ChargersGlen Waverley Rovers
5PaddyCross14-02-03182Casey Demons (VFL)Nar Nar Goon
6MichaelKiraly09-01-04186Bendigo PioneersMacleod
8RyePenny01-03-04186Calder CannonsGisborne
9ArchieSinnott28-07-04186Geelong FalconsNewtown & Chilwell
10JeddLongmire14-06-04188Collingwood (VFL)/Murray BushrangersBundoora
11NicholasNewton13-05-04187Murray BushrangersLavington
12JackCleaver22-05-04188Essendon (VFL)St Bernards
13EthanStanley13-11-03188Box Hill Hawks (VFL)Frankston YCW
14LukeTeal20-05-04190Richmond (VFL)/Oakleigh ChargersGlen Iris
15TomStern23-06-04191Gippsland PowerWarragul
18RyanMaric06-09-04193Gippsland PowerDrouin
20ZiggyToledo-Glasman15-04-04192Dandenong StingraysMt Eliza
21MitchDodos03-11-04196Bendigo PioneersKyabram
22HamishPierson03-11-04195Geelong FalconsGrovedale Tigers
24JovanPetric17-04-04197Western JetsKeilor
25ArcherMay27-08-04199Richmond (VFL)/Sandringham DragonsSt Kilda City
26LeviYoung15-01-04199Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
28WilliamElliott11-06-04203Oakleigh ChargersSurrey Park
29ClayTucker09-08-04204Eastern RangesRowville
30FlynnRiley05-04-04206Northern KnightsMontmorency


VICTORIA METRO​

#NAMESURNAMEDOBHTSTATE LEAGUE CLUBCOMMUNITY CLUB
1IsaacKako07-03-06175Calder CannonsPascoe Vale
2TajHotton17-06-06177Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
3TarkynO'Leary01-07-05178Sandringham DragonsParkdale Vultures
4JoshDocking14-10-05178Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
5CalebWindsor09-07-05183Eastern RangesLysterfield
6KynanBrown13-01-05180Oakleigh ChargersBlackburn
7MahmoudTaha04-11-05182Calder CannonsPascoe Vale
8NathanPhilactides10-01-05180Oakleigh ChargersBlackburn
9CameronNyko25-11-05180Eastern RangesHealesville
10ZakJohnson24-12-06185Northern KnightsSt Mary’s
11HarveyJohnston18-08-05184Sandringham DragonsParkdale Vultures
12ArchieRoberts18-11-05183Sandringham DragonsHampton Rovers
14LuccaGrego15-09-06183Western JetsBacchus Marsh
15CharltonHarrop13-07-05186Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
16JakeSmith24-07-05188Western JetsWilliamstown CYMS
17RyanEyre19-03-05191Calder CannonsKilmore
18CooperTrembath17-10-05192Eastern RangesPark Orchards
19WilliamBrown16-06-05193Sandringham DragonsEast Brighton
20CalsherDear04-08-05194Sandringham DragonsBeaumaris
22RemyMaclean14-10-05194Eastern RangesEast Ringwood
23ChristianMardini18-06-05197Northern KnightsBundoora
24JordanCroft12-05-05200Calder CannonsMaribyrnong Park
26RileyWeatherill21-11-05195Eastern RangesEast Ringwood
27WilliamGreen08-09-05202Northern KnightsNorthcote

Does it strike anyone else as odd,

That there isnt a single young gun outside the state of Victoria?
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 1 users
Not necessarily related to this draft but in general when I look at the Essendon team it reminds me that too often clubs and supporters fall into the trap of judging players too harshly.
Essendon had Wright last year kicking over 50 goals after an underwhelming career with the suns. They now have Wiedeman playing the best footy of his career.
I think we need a kpf who can just be a back up. Sometimes a new club makes a lot of difference.
There are a few around still at other clubs playing 2nd tier footy
Himmelberg at Adelaide , Riccardi at the giants. There are probably others
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
A game yesterday between Vic Metro and the “Young Guns”, which included plenty of players eligible for the mid season draft. Some notes in the article below


Archie May, Beau Tedcastle, Tom Bower and Luke Teal
IMG_0683.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
A game yesterday between Vic Metro and the “Young Guns”, which included plenty of players eligible for the mid season draft. Some notes in the article below


Archie May, Beau Tedcastle, Tom Bower and Luke Teal
View attachment 19148
#25 ;)
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Yes I’m a big fan but he’s very raw still! I feel like at the stage the club is at we may need a more mature key forward, maybe early to mid 20s? Like Buller who has been mentioned on here.
 
Yes I’m a big fan but he’s very raw still! I feel like at the stage the club is at we may need a more mature key forward, maybe early to mid 20s? Like Buller who has been mentioned on here.
If we had 2 picks Why not both?
we’re desperate for 2 tall forwards
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Has any club successfully petitioned the AFL to be allowed to take another player onto its list when a player has retired before the season even started ? eg like Castagna did with us.

Has it happened before ?
 
Has any club successfully petitioned the AFL to be allowed to take another player onto its list when a player has retired before the season even started ? eg like Castagna did with us.

Has it happened before ?
If it did it would probably been the Cats seeing they had other draft trade rules changed for them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user