Welcome to Tigers: Jason Castagna | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Welcome to Tigers: Jason Castagna

tigertim said:
If Dimma said he was terrific then he wont be dropped but that was one of the worst games ive seen played.

Dimma exposes his sarcasm a bit too much.
 
getbacktoglorydays said:
Ok I have tried being patient with this guy, but enough is enough and I am not talking about just tonight's game, he has plenty of games similar to tonight. This kid needs to go back to the VFL team to sort out his finishing and goal-kicking, he has been giving plenty of patience due to being a part of the premiership side. Dimma just said he was terrific and played really well. Hope he is not saying the same behind closed doors. Why doesn't Sam Lloyd and Jacob Townsend get extended opportunities like Costanga does, both of them can put as much pressure on as Costanga, have a higher skill level and are more efficient in front of goal.

1 goal from Lloyd or Townsend and you have George covered. I'd be happy to leave Shai in for a week to run and chase till he blows up, and omit George for Lloyd and play him deep. Dimma up for it?

What I really love given his ups and downs this year is how much I mean this thought. Dan come back to us - all is forgiven!
 
He won’t get dropped and nor should he. Yes he cost us the game tonight but he will be backed to turn it around against the Saints next week and I think he will.
 
Ridley said:
He won’t get dropped and nor should he. Yes he cost us the game tonight but he will be backed to turn it around against the Saints next week and I think he will.

Last chance.
 
Ridley said:
He won’t get dropped and nor should he. Yes he cost us the game tonight but he will be backed to turn it around against the Saints next week and I think he will.

This... good to hear some common sense.
 
A quality forward requires high skills - see Toby Greene. You might hate him but the difference in composure and kicking ability is just stark. The draft selection difference is all there to see. Castagna played a lot of his junior footy as a defender; for obvious reasons. Seriously doubt he can develop the skill-set needed to make a reliable forward at this stage. I would hate to see this guy cost us a final. He lacks the mental strength.

Time for Stengle.
 
[quote a



uthor=3121FC link=topic=50620.msg2254361#msg2254361 date=1531572177]
He's training schedule should be just having shots from 35 out all week
[/quote]

he already does this so maybe it is a lost cause?
 
Brettstigers said:
1 goal from Lloyd or Townsend and you have George covered. I'd be happy to leave Shai in for a week to run and chase till he blows up, and omit George for Lloyd and play him deep. Dimma up for it?

What I really love given his ups and downs this year is how much I mean this thought. Dan come back to us - all is forgiven!

Lloyd = no pressure.
 
Ridley said:
He won’t get dropped and nor should he. Yes he cost us the game tonight but he will be backed to turn it around against the Saints next week and I think he will.

Agree. His positives outweigh the negatives.
 
Has matchwinning ability.

Show him a montage of every goal he’s kicked in the past 12 months and ask him to kick the matchwinner next week.

He looked frustrated in the first 10 minutes of the game, he’ll bounce back over the next few weeks.
 
123kid said:
Has matchwinning ability.

Show him a montage of every goal he’s kicked in the past 12 months and ask him to kick the matchwinner next week.

He looked frustrated in the first 10 minutes of the game,
he’ll bounce back over the next few weeks.

That's the main question. Why? Looked like a monster was gonna eat him. Fear all over his face all night.
 
TigerForce said:
That's the main question. Why? Looked like a monster was gonna eat him. Fear all over his face all night.

12 months ago he was the same. Whatever it is, it can be fixed. Maybe our energetic, positive, happy culture turns those nerves into excitement in front of our roaring finals crowds? Not sure.

One different way to take the pressure off is by judging him on number of scoring shots each week. Don’t label him 0.5, pump him up for being +5 in one match! That’s awesome stuff. Next time he is taking a shot, get all his teammates to take the p!ss out of him and tell him he just needs to score (making him laugh) so he doesn’t feel like everyone is quietly thinking “oh god, not him again”. He just needs to score and he’s already succeeded. Make it a running gag.

Or maybe get him to embrace the fact he’s the worst kick for goal in the team, he’s that kid in The Mighty Ducks who can hit the puck like a king but has abysmal accuracy... and wouldn’t it be a fitting fairytale to finish the season with him being the one to kick the matchwinning goal to get chaired by his teammates after the siren? Plant some new stories in his head.

Whatever they do, I’m confident they’ll succeed with him. He’ll come good by finals. These situations are largely what the club’s culture seems to be about and why we’re so successful now.
 
Wow!
A loss and the wolves are out. A *smile* result but you can't be up 100%.
Chill out ffs. We are still top
 
zgod said:
Wow!
A loss and the wolves are out. A sh!t result but you can't be up 100%.
Chill out ffs. We are still top

And if he did the same in a final would you tell everyone to chill out then?

Likewise if we miss out out by one game a double chance or a home final because of this loss?

Why the wolves? Because people have been warning for a couple of years now that his kicking is so utterly unbelievably crap that one day he'll cost us a match. Well it finally happened and it's pretty annoying especially since his apologists had constantly assured us that he's still young and his kicking skills will definitely improve. Well four years on the list and has it improved? Is that still the line or is this as good it's ever going to get? Does anyone hold out any serious hope for improvement or are we just going to have to get use to yelling out 'don't kick it to castagna' for the rest of his career at Richmond?
 
Does something good, then does 5 *smile* things and then does something good then does 5 *smile* things.