Week 1 --- 2019 --- The Other Finals ! | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Week 1 --- 2019 --- The Other Finals !

If Geelong do go out in straight sets, some tough calls to make on some great players for the club: Taylor, Ablett, Selwood, even Hawkins perhaps.
Kelly gone too.
I'd say Selwood and Hawkins play 1 more year, but do little.
Henderson replaces Taylor and so its more of the same. Jack Steven to replace Kelly.
I think while they have danger they'll aim for a flag and not bottom out.

They need to be brave and completely change gamestyle in 2020.
problem is that they've been drafting the wrong type for too long
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Flossy for Stephenson

Finally, collingwood’s backline comes down to Moore and Howe. Roughead is a spud who Lynch will exploit.
no way Flossy plays on Stephenson who is hit up on fast leads.
Flossy plays off for intercept marks so tot different style.
Maybe Broad. Ideally Grimes but he is prob on Elliott.

Howe plays on Jack. Always does and does well. it's a fascinating contest.
Roughead goes to big Tom, leaving Moore to play floater and 3rd man up.
That's ok as we will run it in.
but it would be a tight battle
 
Anyone like to start a Game day thread.....?
happy to do so because but as I don't have enough credits in the bank I can't add a picture to the heading!
Something appropriate like say one of Dusty in full flight or a team pic?
Who's up for the challenge?
 
Anyone like to start a Game day thread.....?
happy to do so because but as I don't have enough credits in the bank I can't add a picture to the heading!
Something appropriate like say one of Dusty in full flight or a team pic?
Who's up for the challenge?
The way Ablett avoids contact at all costs must be cancerous. If has any pride he’d retire, lucky the media aren’t exposing him
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
You wouldn't want to be doing an exam with Nathan Buckley sitting nest to you. He'd be grabbing your writing hand and pulling it out the way for a better look.

He copies the Tigers in 2018. Get's rolled by the WCE in that year's GF so comes out this year with a careful ball movement plan. It works for a time while the nemesis of this plan, the Tigers have most of their list injured, and the Lions still try to figure out how to stop a team rebounding through their press if they play too balistic.

Once Richmond string 10 wins together and the Lions almost as many, mainly through stiffling their attack slightly to protect their back half, Nathan see's that the writing is on the wall for the slow ball movement teams and looks like he's reverting more towards our game style again.

The small forward line has worked fantastically against the Crows and last night less so against the Cats, but the cats were pathetic last night.

The Crows have ZERO pressure as you come out of their forward half, which is perfect for a team with a small forward line ie run through the middle, little or no pressure, get it in quick with a pass to a lead up forward. But if pressure is applied, then this don't work so well. Kicks going forward to a team that applies forward half and mid field pressure are more likely to be rushed and lobbed in, and then picked up with intercept marks.

4 of the first 5 goals tha cats conceded last night were from spastic defensive efforts ie spoiling the ball away from 3 of your own team straigfht into the hands of a Pies opponent. Laying a pathetic bump, andf then effectively shepparding your own team mate away from his direct opponent etc. Let's not even mention missing 3 or 4 shots in this time from 15m out, plus a dodgy goal review which i guess you can expect bearing in mind that McGuire media now runs the score review bunker!

The Pies were lucky to get over a side that simply is out of it's depth in finals due to the hand up it gets from it's home ground advantage, hence their pathetic finals record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Yep, if we can all just get past our fear of Collingwood, which trust me I know is hard, there’s little to suggest Collingwood will win this year’s flag.

First and foremost, their forward line is severely flawed without an imposing big man. They need to run and spread it in every time. If you have speed, which we have, you can neutralise them. If you have endurance, which we have, you can cover them. Finally, if our midfield pressures hard, they will find space in midfield on turnover, particularly in the first quarter when Collingwood like to establish scoreboard pressure.

Stephenson, Elliot, De Goey. These are the dangers. The latter may not even play again. Flossy for Stephenson, Grimes on Elliot. Baker, Broad, Astbury, Houli and Short won’t have too many problems and should be able to lend aerial support and link up.

Collingwood’s midfield is dangerous but so is ours. If our pressure game is on and Dusty exploits the lack of hard tag (Greenwood out) then we can match their inside 50s.

I would sit on Sidebottom. Scrag him, get in his face. Graham is the man. Soldo can smother Grundy.

Finally, collingwood’s backline comes down to Moore and Howe. Roughead is a spud who Lynch will exploit. Most importantly, we aren’t Geelong with a slow, inept attack. We routinely score 90+ points a game. We will separate Moore and Howe and make them accountable to their men.

Who will take Nankervis down there? We can seriously threaten Collingwood with something we didn’t have last year - two extra talls.

Collingwood have no small backs worth a damn. Rioli, Castagna and Bolton will have plenty of opportunities. If we play them high and run into space, Moore and Howe won’t get a look at it.

I think we’ll play Collingwood in the grand final. My heart is fearful, but only because of the PF trauma. My head says we can win comfortably.

If we actually look closely at our team, we are much better than last year.

1) Dusty cherry ripe and running amok
2) Bolton adds class
3) baker down back, courage and verve
4) Soldo as primary tap ruck, giving us clearances. Yep, you heard right. Clearances!
5) Nankervis as relief ruck and angry tall forward. What a luxury.
6) Lynch. Lynch. Lynch. Riewoldt plotting all kinds of evil under less scrutiny.
7) Prestia in the form of his life.
8) the trauma of last year will steel our boys like you wouldn’t believe.

We ain’t dropping this cup. It’s ours.

I thought they'd gone past us?
 
You wouldn't want to be doing an exam with Nathan Buckley sitting nest to you. He'd be grabbing your writing hand and pulling it out the way for a better look.

He copies the Tigers in 2018. Get's rolled by the WCE in that year's GF so comes out this year with a careful ball movement plan. It works for a time while the nemesis of this plan, the Tigers have most of their list injured, and the Lions still try to figure out how to stop a team rebounding through their press if they play too balistic.

Once Richmond string 10 wins together and the Lions almost as many, mainly through stiffling their attack slightly to protect their back half, Nathan see's that the writing is on the wall for the slow ball movement teams and looks like he's reverting more towards our game style again.

The small forward line has worked fantastically against the Crows and last night less so against the Cats, but the cats were pathetic last night.

The Crows have ZERO pressure as you come out of their forward half, which is perfect for a team with a small forward line ie run through the middle, little or no pressure, get it in quick with a pass to a lead up forward. But if pressure is applied, then this don't work so well. Kicks going forward to a team that applies forward half and mid field pressure are more likely to be rushed and lobbed in, and then picked up with intercept marks.

4 of the first 5 goals tha cats conceded last night were from spastic defensive efforts ie spoiling the ball away from 3 of your own team straigfht into the hands of a Pies opponent. Laying a pathetic bump, andf then effectively shepparding your own team mate away from his direct opponent etc. Let's not even mention missing 3 or 4 shots in this time from 15m out, plus a dodgy goal review which i guess you can expect bearing in mind that McGuire media now runs the score review bunker!

The Pies were lucky to get over a side that simply is out of it's depth in finals due to the hand up it gets from it's home ground advantage, hence their pathetic finals record.

^^^
 
The Geelong v Collingwood game was thrown away by Geelong in the first quarter in front of goal and from 25 metres out. Bolton, Castagna and even Jack can do the same thing. We need to not otherwise it will be Hardwick saying the same thing in his presser as Scott.

I think we should all petition the AFL to let WC play Geelong in Geelong. Only way I can see Geelong getting up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Kelly gone too.
I'd say Selwood and Hawkins play 1 more year, but do little.
Henderson replaces Taylor and so its more of the same. Jack Steven to replace Kelly.
I think while they have danger they'll aim for a flag and not bottom out.

They need to be brave and completely change gamestyle in 2020.
problem is that they've been drafting the wrong type for too long

Relax wirh Kelly man
When they were flying he was everywhere
As soon as things go bad he has jumped ship.
If gets more them 600k
It will be like him winning tatts
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Never change Geelol. They lost this match a couple months back. A lot would need to go right for them to win it from here.

Also, I wouldn’t be surprised if they end up like Adelaide within a couple of years. I don’t think they’re a tight playing group.
With their age profile and the likelihood of losing Kelly, someone’s about to fall off a cliff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
The gutless media was too scared to ask scott any decent questions.
Zips questions,
*You must be under pressure now,
*do you fill your negatively playing here set up failure.
*do u think that you have taken this side as far as it can go.
*what part of recruiting Rohan you didnt know he doesn't preform in September
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
Danger aside, gee geel are ordinary. Minor premiers? Ablett shocking. So many fumbles. Best game I've seen Stewart play, still not a patch on Grimes.

Cwood start well then play that tempo footy. If we meet them, we have got to start well. No degoey is handy. Moore stood up.
Need to remember the Cats lost half of their last 10 H&A games.
Not top form running into the finals.
 
The gutless media was too scared to ask scott any decent questions.
Zips questions,
*You must be under pressure now,
*do you fill your negatively playing here set up failure.
*do u think that you have taken this side as far as it can go.
*what part of recruiting Rohan you didnt know he doesn't preform in September
Spot on zips.

In a nutshell, the media personal are too scared to rock the AFL boat that provides them sustained employment.

Heard a person a couple of weeks ago on Sen ( a lecturer in media/journalism) said AFL is right up there against the big names in web traffic, news & things realated to that area. Big source of employment.

Its a 2 edge sword Ive come to accept.
Essedrugs saga typified the BS of going as far as they could without asking the bigger Qs.
Only a few long term journos with job security elsewhere could ask from time to time
 
The Geelong v Collingwood game was thrown away by Geelong in the first quarter in front of goal and from 25 metres out. Bolton, Castagna and even Jack can do the same thing. We need to not otherwise it will be Hardwick saying the same thing in his presser as Scott.

I think we should all petition the AFL to let WC play Geelong in Geelong. Only way I can see Geelong getting up.
Actually think Scott threw it away a few weeks ago by choosing to focus on off field issues that were out of his control and inadvertently getting into his own players heads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
With their age profile and the likelihood of losing Kelly, someone’s about to fall off a cliff.

And to think they are going after 29 year Jack Stevens who will be 30 in march next year :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 2 users