Umpire farce - Getting worse by the minute! | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Umpire farce - Getting worse by the minute!

Crap umpiring, really crap. That goal denied to Dusty was shocking. Player falls over and waves arms in the air and gets a free, and a tremendous goal doesn't count. I agree with Dyer'eres comment, thats the kind of next step that good sides take, becoming quickly aware of which way the wind is blowing ump-wise, and responding. Its high concept stuff, we aren't quite at that level yet, (maybe we are? but I doubt it, still too young).

Indulge me a second, how hard can it bloody be to get 50m penalties consistent? All the umps have to do is have a training run on the G or docklands, any stadium. Get some reference points and away the go. Its a professional game, a 50m penalty can be anywhere from 35-70m. (45-55m is acceptable) Its drives me up the wall. A shot to them from a 50 against Luke today went from a 30% shot (what it should have been) to a 70% shot. Just shouldn't happen.
 
bowden4president said:
My favorite was when Maric stood still, a bulldog rams his head in to his legs and gets a free for high contact ::)

Yeah that was a doozy. I like the head high tackle rule generally, but surely the offending player has to actually move.
 
Comparing the total free kick count from today's game to the other games this round, either us and the bulldogs are doing something very wrong or it highlights the inconsistency week to week in the way the games are umpired depending on who gets rostered to do your game.

Cats vs Blues: 33 total
Pies vs Hawks: 35 total
Dockers vs Bombers: 45 total
Crows vs Power: 49 total
Suns vs Lions: 35 total
Roos vs Swans: 39 total
Dees vs Eagles: 38 total
Giants vs Saints: 41 total

Tigers vs Dogs: 63 total
 
Big Country said:
Comparing the total free kick count from today's game to the other games this round, either us and the bulldogs are doing something very wrong or it highlights the inconsistency week to week in the way the games are umpired depending on who gets rostered to do your game.

Cats vs Blues: 33 total
Pies vs Hawks: 35 total
Dockers vs Bombers: 45 total
Crows vs Power: 49 total
Suns vs Lions: 35 total
Roos vs Swans: 39 total
Dees vs Eagles: 38 total
Giants vs Saints: 41 total

Tigers vs Dogs: 63 total
Took the words out of my mouth. The first stat I looked at, at the end of the game was the total free kick count as you knew the game was completely over-umpired.
 
Terrible umpiring today, so over-officiated for no good reason. Some of the decisions were so perplexing, you didn't even know who was getting the free-kick.
 
i have watched and played a lot of football in my life...never have i seen a game so over umpired...it was terrible both ways...no one knew what 75 percent of the frees were for
 
dewinton said:
i have watched and played a lot of football in my life...never have i seen a game so over umpired...it was terrible both ways...no one knew what 75 percent of the frees were for

The Leper did enough to back up next week against the filth. I expect Stevic and Chamberlain to round off Geisch's dream team.
 
Let's just be thankful we got away with an 11 goal win in what will be the most over umpired game for 2013, what made it bearable was that we were never threatened, could you imagine what the crowd would have been like if it was close.
 
Big Country said:
Comparing the total free kick count from today's game to the other games this round, either us and the bulldogs are doing something very wrong or it highlights the inconsistency week to week in the way the games are umpired depending on who gets rostered to do your game.

Cats vs Blues: 33 total
Pies vs Hawks: 35 total
Dockers vs Bombers: 45 total
Crows vs Power: 49 total
Suns vs Lions: 35 total
Roos vs Swans: 39 total
Dees vs Eagles: 38 total
Giants vs Saints: 41 total

Tigers vs Dogs: 63 total

Incredible stat, even more so given the fact it was played in an enclosed arena with no weather elements.
 
i was at the game and the umpiring was bloody terrible. mainly against tigers,

jack was crucified and they cost us 5 goals
 
worst umpiring I've seen in living memory..so trigger happy give them free,s for any little thing....but yeah they seen to really hate luke n jack
 
#11 killed us today.

Went to the game today and Dogs supporters were laughing with the free kicks they got early on for no reason - they weren't laughing much longer after the first qtr though...

Could only imagine neutral supporters watching the game on Foxtel - surely they would have switched the game off with the umpiring??

Worst umpired game I have seen - ever.
 
Won't improve until they change the umpire coach.
The more they change the game the worst these peanuts get.
 
zippadeee said:
Worse I've seen in 25 years. They were plucking them from every where.

Absolutely shocking today - probably the worst for a year or so.
 
Let's put it this way. I hope today's maggs are exempt from jury duty.

They assumed what had happened a lot of the time, and penalised accordingly. At least one throw was paid - in the centre, can't remember who - and he was directly behind the play. If it was a throw (i was facing it and it didn't look like it) he couldn't possibly have known.

Don't get me started on the tackle on Jack after he marked.
 
Only reason I'm prepared to cop the reaming we got from the maggots today is that we were on the receiving end last week.

63 frees...only three games in the last decade have had more (2 x 64 and a 69).
 
I've never heard so much moaning about free kicks than what the crowd where doing even before they knew who it was going too just because there seemed to be a free paid every time there was a contest.
 
Now this is a game I'm scared of.

Spot fires of melted cheese breaking out all over Australia now Richmond are 3-0.

The umpires being just the same have the power in their hands to stop the Tiger juggernaut.

Very worried about the Maggots.

They had a real good crack Doggies game.

Jack this time will put his little finger in the back of a player and get pinged?

YOU'VE BEEN WARNED GIESH!!!!!!!!!!

;D :D