Trade Period Rating Poll

[Rosy]

I haven't followed trade week too closely. Interested to know how others think we performed. Were there trades other clubs did that people would have loved us to do? Have we ended up addressing major needs?

 

[tigersnake]

C+

If we'd got Treloar, who we only just missed, it would been A.

 

[TigerForce]

I picked C-. Twitter shows it too.

I reckon we could've done better. Was Yarran the only big (fish) target??

We only have pick 12 and then way too deep with 52, 88, 106, 120 & 124. Hopefully there's a diamond in the rough.

 

[Rowdy]

I'll go with C+ as well, went ok but not great

 

[zippadeee]

B

Got was there. Didn't over pay
Still got a good first rounder
Would've been a A if they got treloar
It's not chase anything with legs anymore. Which I like

 

[WesternTiger]

D.

Needed to bring in something with a package of 12 and round 1 next year.

 

[mrposhman]

Went with a B. Reckon we impacted 2 of our key areas that we struggle in, contested footy / tackling and speed and still managed to keep our 1st rounder. Would have liked to have traded Astbury so we were back into the 2nd round next year but overall reckon we have done ok. Get someone like Moore from Port as a DFA and delist Thomas and maybe Gordon and reckon we will be fine.

Main list
Out
Foley
Newman
Petterd
Knights
McDonough
Gordon??

In
Yarran
Pick 12
Pick 52
Townsend
Moore
Lambert - upgrade

Rookie list - Add 3 more.

 

[Ian4]

D. a couple of pickups, but no big fish puts us borderline failure.

We only have pick 12 and then way too deep with 52, 88, 106, 120 & 124. Hopefully there's a diamond in the rough.

2 picks in the top 80 is a worry. is someone able to list how many spots we have available on our list, including rookies?

 

[mrposhman]

It's not chase anything with legs anymore. Which I like

Thats Carlton now. There list now looks shocking. Absolute max 2 wins next year.

 

[pumped]

B-

didn't land Treloar.

Yarran not a big fish but elite.

Townsend fills a need without over-spending.

 

[The Mole]

Went with a B. Reckon we impacted 2 of our key areas that we struggle in, contested footy / tackling and speed and still managed to keep our 1st rounder. Would have liked to have traded Astbury so we were back into the 2nd round next year but overall reckon we have done ok. Get someone like Moore from Port as a DFA and delist Thomas and maybe Gordon and reckon we will be fine.

Main list
Out
Foley
Newman
Petterd
Knights
McDonough
Gordon??

In
Yarran
Pick 12
Pick 52
Townsend
Moore
Lambert - upgrade

Rookie list - Add 3 more.

When did we get Moore???? Did I miss something?

 

[Rosy]

........
In
Yarran
Pick 12
Pick 52
Townsend
Moore
Lambert - upgrade

Rookie list - Add 3 more.

As I said I haven't followed this much. How did we get pick 12 in? What was our first round pick and where is it now?

 

[tigertim]

C.

Yarran was a good get, Townsend, who knows.

Thought we were due to go hard in the trading period, seems not.

Don't think we are going hard in the ND, Picks 12 & 50(?) and rookie upgrades.

 

[Tigers of Old]

C = Average

Needed to do better from this period IMO.

 

[ryan]

C - just

We also gave away our second round pick next year

We have to have at least 3 picks in draft and our third pick is number 88

should have done deals with the new clubs and mixed up some picks like Collingwood & Bulldogs did

We have 4 retirements n one delisting in McDonough - Arnott was a rookie.

Lambert & Castagna will be promoted plus we have brought in Yarran & Townsend.

So 5 off list and possibly 4 on - unless we go 40 on main list and 4 rookies

we had 39 on main list last year & 5 rookies.

Another player may be delisted - Gordon?

 

[TigerForce]

As I said I haven't followed this much. How did we get pick 12 in? What was our first round pick and where is it now?

Finishing 7th after the EF loss.

 

[The Mole]

As I said I haven't followed this much. How did we get pick 12 in? What was our first round pick and where is it now?

12 was always our first round pick Rosy. We Traded this year's 2nd round and next years 2nd round for pick 19 (end of first round this year) which was then on-traded to Carlton for Yarran.

 

[toby64]

D.

But we will be better next year. :spin

 

[Saladin]

just wating for the club statement around "natural improvement" from the list that will continue to carry us forward.. :blah :blah :blah

 

[mrposhman]

When did we get Moore???? Did I miss something?

We haven't. Thinking we might get him as a DFA.