-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
The Brownlow (Merged)
- Thread starter Phar Ace
- Start date
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
No doubt he was unlucky. I reckon Cooney robbing Ablett was a bigger farce though.
GoodOne said:
No doubt he was unlucky. I reckon Cooney robbing Ablett was a bigger farce though.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Seems unusually low. Out of interest where did Juddy sit by comparison?
GoodOne said:
Seems unusually low. Out of interest where did Juddy sit by comparison?
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Out of interest thought I'd compare Judd's position in the above stats last year:
Tackles 27th, Goal Assists 33rd, Scoring Assists 22nd, centre bounce clearances 4th, contested possession 3rd, 1st possession 3rd.
If he could win the Brownlow last year, then he's a shoe in this year as he's kept his clearance and contested possession very much the same but has improved markedly on his tackling and scoring assists. Backs up my feeling that Judd did have a much more creative season this year.
GoodOne said:
Out of interest thought I'd compare Judd's position in the above stats last year:
Tackles 27th, Goal Assists 33rd, Scoring Assists 22nd, centre bounce clearances 4th, contested possession 3rd, 1st possession 3rd.
If he could win the Brownlow last year, then he's a shoe in this year as he's kept his clearance and contested possession very much the same but has improved markedly on his tackling and scoring assists. Backs up my feeling that Judd did have a much more creative season this year.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Judd was 22nd for scoring assists (2.0 a game). Swan was just behind (1.9). For goal assists Judd was 33rd (1.1) and Swan (0.9). It is quite an interesting stat as Judd was 3rd for inside 50s in 2010 and Swan was 5th. Seems to indicate they weren't creating chances very well for their temamates bringing the ball into the 50metre arc. This year Swan was 7th for inside 50 and Judd only 19th. Yet Judd increased his scoring assists to 2.8 and goal assists to 1.7 meaning he was much much more efficient this year.
Tigers of Old said:
Judd was 22nd for scoring assists (2.0 a game). Swan was just behind (1.9). For goal assists Judd was 33rd (1.1) and Swan (0.9). It is quite an interesting stat as Judd was 3rd for inside 50s in 2010 and Swan was 5th. Seems to indicate they weren't creating chances very well for their temamates bringing the ball into the 50metre arc. This year Swan was 7th for inside 50 and Judd only 19th. Yet Judd increased his scoring assists to 2.8 and goal assists to 1.7 meaning he was much much more efficient this year.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Can't see Judd not getting it.
A better question for mine is who should win the Brownlow.
I reckon Pendlebury is that player.
Can't see Judd not getting it.
A better question for mine is who should win the Brownlow.
I reckon Pendlebury is that player.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
I still think McLeod being pipped by Aker was the vfl at its worst.
Tigers of Old said:
I still think McLeod being pipped by Aker was the vfl at its worst.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
If you want to talk matchwinners, why aren't we mentioning Swan? He's only marginally behind Judd for score/goal assists, 2nd in the league for score involvements, even with Judd for score launches all while getting it 5 times more per game and kicking 18 more goals for the year. He should absolutely *smile* it in. How many games were his efforts clearly a major factor in a Collingwood win? 34 touches, a couple of goals and a couple of assists is almost an average game for him.
If you want to talk matchwinners, why aren't we mentioning Swan? He's only marginally behind Judd for score/goal assists, 2nd in the league for score involvements, even with Judd for score launches all while getting it 5 times more per game and kicking 18 more goals for the year. He should absolutely *smile* it in. How many games were his efforts clearly a major factor in a Collingwood win? 34 touches, a couple of goals and a couple of assists is almost an average game for him.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Because there's a perception with Swan Disco. Perception is reality sadly. I agree with you FWIW. If Judd played some of the games Swan did people would cream themselves. Although I reckon Pendles was a little bit better than him.
Because there's a perception with Swan Disco. Perception is reality sadly. I agree with you FWIW. If Judd played some of the games Swan did people would cream themselves. Although I reckon Pendles was a little bit better than him.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Judd won AFL MVP tonight by a mile. The umps might not be the best judges but your colleagues and opponents, in any award, usually know it best.
Judd might not win the Brownlow but he was easily the best player in the league this year.
Judd won AFL MVP tonight by a mile. The umps might not be the best judges but your colleagues and opponents, in any award, usually know it best.
Judd might not win the Brownlow but he was easily the best player in the league this year.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Agree. 1347 votes to next best Pendlebury's 456 says it all.
scottyturnerscurse said:
Agree. 1347 votes to next best Pendlebury's 456 says it all.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow?
Dooesn't matter what I think, the opponents who play against him every week think Juddy's a freakin gun.
Barnzy said:
Dooesn't matter what I think, the opponents who play against him every week think Juddy's a freakin gun.
<
Jack Gunston
|
Granny poll
>
