Sydney Stack | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Sydney Stack

Well well well
His sister says different
As does the family Instagrams account which shows the funeral 14 weeks ago
Fact !!!
Time to move on
Might further add Peter Sumich says the kid don’t lie . Please spare me !!
Wasn't it Sumich that sacked Sydney from the WA U18 team?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Well well well
His sister says different
As does the family Instagrams account which shows the funeral 14 weeks ago
Fact !!!
Time to move on
Might further add Peter Sumich says the kid don’t lie . Please spare me !!

I will spare you.

Not interested in ever reading your bull crap again
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Well well well
His sister says different
As does the family Instagrams account which shows the funeral 14 weeks ago
Fact !!!
Time to move on
Might further add Peter Sumich says the kid don’t lie . Please spare me !!

Can you post a link or pic of the Instagram account?

Or even a search term I can chuck on to google.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
We knew the kid had issues before we picked him up. Stacka's obviously struggled to rectify / control those same issues in recent months.
Reckon part of being a great footy club is the bit where enough guidance and support, with a bit of tough love thrown in helps grow the young doofus rat bag kid into a reasonably well adjusted adult.
I've got a feeling that spending Xmas / New Year in iso in the big house would put a fair sized hurricane up nearly anyone's arse. Hoping the club and especially the other indigenous players wrap their arms around Stacky when he gets out. Guide him n push him, make him earn back his place in the team and some respect back from his team mates.
Easiest thing in the world would be to dump the young fella in the bin n just walk away. Not sure I'd like to read about what would likely become of another young kids life if he loses all support. Young Stacka needs to buy in as well and start to learn from his stuff ups and improve his behaviours in a hurry coz no club can constantly carry someone who refuses to walk for himself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
hQ6L6eB.jpg
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 1 user
I think the statement on twitter by former St Kilda assistant coach Jason Mifsud questioning the decision to put Stack behind bars is very very pertinent.

"Challenge the behaviour, support the person. Not sure incarcerating a vulnerable young person is the only solution in a case such as this. Seems unimaginative and unnecessarily punitive,"
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10 users
I think the statement on twitter by former St Kilda assistant coach Jason Mifsud questioning the decision to put Stack behind bars is very very pertinent.

"Challenge the behaviour, support the person. Not sure incarcerating a vulnerable young person is the only solution in a case such as this. Seems unimaginative and unnecessarily punitive,"
Gotta have the same rules for everyone. "Vulnerable" is subjective. Mifsud has made some questionable calls in the past and is expecting far too much of the authorities here.

Unless he's suggesting Syd needs a mental health facility?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I reckon and hope we will stand by him.
He needs structure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I've been thinking about this all day and my view has settled on that I hope the RFC keeps Stack on the list.

There's no doubt he needs the sort of rocket that makes some real change and if it doesn't this time then he is definitely out of chances. I'm not sure how many weeks he has left of the suspension but I'd look at upping it to 10 weeks out of next season and during that time send him to a day job and be only part of the seconds list squad (whatever the VFL is called now).

The way I see it is we have to live our own message. I know I make people aghast when I call culture complete *smile* but whether you agree or disagree there's not doubt we have firmly tied our flag to that mast over the past few years.

To me, if you are going to clap on about being a Richmond man and mindfulness and the amazing love and care for each other, the incredible culture, and puff out your chest when you take a couple of indigenous guys with troubled pasts who start playing well because of the amazing environment you brought them into, then you have to be prepared to stick fat the other way.

If we cut Stack now, then all of that stuff becomes *smile* and wind. If your so-called elite culture can't handle supporting a young indigenous kid who has made a group of relatively harmless yet awful decisions (mind you, not even close to anything as bad as your marquee player did at the same stage of his career) then don't ever say another word about it, and admit that all you did was luck out on a group of guys who became great players at the same time and the culture malarkey is just a nice way to feel like you can own that success.
Richo, you're being a bit soft. This isn't about us having a great culture or not being supportive.

You can't just let someone continually repeat the same mistakes, without giving them boundaries.

His behaviour could come back on the club.

Would you like to see draft penalties, fines, or loss of premiership points because someone can't obey rules (that he's repeatedly broken)?
At some point the club has to put its position ahead of the individual.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
start to learn from his stuff ups
IF he can do this he will have a very good career, and after thinking about it for the last couple of days I still think he is a tool and needs a good slap around the head but I now hope the Tigers give him 1 last chance. Surely 2 weeks in the slammer will force him to have a good long hard look at himself. But having said that 1 more stuff up no matter how small I would have him gonski.
 
2020 and its assault on the normality of our lives has resulted in increased suicides and mental health issues across the population.
People have dealt with stressors thrust upon us in many ways. I know I struggled at times with lockdown here in Victoria and I am a mature man with a wealth of life experience and good people in my life.
Stacky has had very little mentoring or guidance in his short life to draw from, and he constantly , at this stage in his life,makes poor decisions. He really defaults to what he knows which isn't much. Marlion did the same thing for many years too. Stacky is still learning and this is a huge learning curve for him (I hope). Keep him close and set tight boundaries. Only of course if he decides he does want to be a footballer, and not just a celebrity
Forgot what I was going to say!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 1 user
We knew the kid had issues before we picked him up. Stacka's obviously struggled to rectify / control those same issues in recent months.
Reckon part of being a great footy club is the bit where enough guidance and support, with a bit of tough love thrown in helps grow the young doofus rat bag kid into a reasonably well adjusted adult.
I've got a feeling that spending Xmas / New Year in iso in the big house would put a fair sized hurricane up nearly anyone's arse. Hoping the club and especially the other indigenous players wrap their arms around Stacky when he gets out. Guide him n push him, make him earn back his place in the team and some respect back from his team mates.
Easiest thing in the world would be to dump the young fella in the bin n just walk away. Not sure I'd like to read about what would likely become of another young kids life if he loses all support. Young Stacka needs to buy in as well and start to learn from his stuff ups and improve his behaviours in a hurry coz no club can constantly carry someone who refuses to walk for himself.
Stacky's situation at what is still the beginning of his career, reminds me very much of Ben Cousin's situation when he was near the end of his.

Both players were recruited by the club when it was known there had been difficulties, that had not been overcome and which had turned other clubs off.
Both were also recruited because it was believed the potential value of each to the club was such that any risk of failure was worth taking on.
Don't wish to open old wounds but as I argued at the time it was wrong for us not to keep Cousins in some capacity and offer him the support that a football club full of individuals with a similar make up and intent, could offer a team mate with his demons still to overcome.

Fully support TM, TM and Richo's view that the club should press on and go hard with Stacky and give him the environment he needs to get up.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user