DirtyDogTiger said:If cotchin goes.
Well morris will come in.
Like for like you think?
DirtyDogTiger said:If cotchin goes.
Well morris will come in.
AstuteTiger said:Surely Newman 12 disposals, Hunt 9 and Lambert 8 possies have to be in line to be dropped.
I Like Lambert but 2 average games = back to ressies.
Newy lucky to get promoted in the first place when he had an average game in the 2'nds a few weeks back against Footscray.
Hunt well let's just say it's got to the point where he is being gifted games.
For a player with his running ability doesn't do enough and looks scared out there.
Macintosh only played a qtr and a bit had 9 disposals and gave us run.
Lennon, McDonough and Arnot just to name a few have been hard done by, they've had good games in the ressies and not rewarded....
antman said:You want to drop blokes from a side that's won 5 from 6 and replace them with guys in a VFL team that sits second last on the ladder.
AstuteTiger said:Surely Newman 12 disposals, Hunt 9 and Lambert 8 possies have to be in line to be dropped.
I Like Lambert but 2 average games = back to ressies.
Newy lucky to get promoted in the first place when he had an average game in the 2'nds a few weeks back against Footscray.
Hunt well let's just say it's got to the point where he is being gifted games.
For a player with his running ability doesn't do enough and looks scared out there.
Macintosh only played a qtr and a bit had 9 disposals and gave us run.
Lennon, McDonough and Arnot just to name a few have been hard done by, they've had good games in the ressies and not rewarded....
AstuteTiger said:So what if we've won does that entitle players who aren't performing a free ride to stay in the side.
Ur logic is flawed just cause they are near the bottom doesn't mean certain players can't get their chance to get a senior gig if they are playing well....
McBean kicked 4 today surely he gets looked at at the selection table for this coming weeks game V the blues....
antman said:You want to drop blokes from a side that's won 5 from 6 and replace them with guys in a VFL team that sits second last on the ladder.
mrposhman said:Was with you there for a bit until you mentioned Arnot!!
Seriously though, there won't be any change unless they are forced into it. Potentially may change Griff anyway for a small if its wet this week as we looked so much better in the final quarter without such a tall lineup.
Personally think we may have to bring someone in for Maric but hoping they see it as careless contact to the head and low impact hence $1500 fine but reckon he may get 1 week. I'd be surprised and very disappointed if Cotch gets rubbed out. They paid the 50 correctly, there is no need to rub him out for that.
jb03 said:Think you said something similar before they rightfully dropped Morris
UKTiger said:From VFL reports Dea and McBean are pressing hard for selection. Donut only played half a game. IMO only injury or suspension will be the reason for any change otherwise Dimma will keep it as it is whatever we think
pervian said:I find this a strange topic because when you look at the VFL side there isn't a lot of talent there maybe Mc Donut