yep agreed with roos. The premise is the extent of the injury dictates the penalty. It is ludicrous, logically and philosophically. People have been saying so for years, but instead of winding it back they are ramping it up. By this logic, anybody whoever hit des tuddenham or frances bourke would have got off. Someone who set out to knock someone into next week but doesn't quite connect gets $2k fine, someone who tries to shake an opponent off but clips them in the sweet spot (cough Bachar), gets 5 weeks.