Noah Balta - Welcome to Tigerland | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Noah Balta - Welcome to Tigerland

Give him time folks he’s played one game so far.
He looks promising physically but remember Rancey took 3 mistake riddled years to develop into the player he is now.
 
bringbakflemmo said:
Give him time folks he’s played one game so far.
He looks promising physically but remember Rancey took 3 mistake riddled years to develop into the player he is now.
And didn’t Rance miss one of his early years after he ran face first into a Brisbane players knee?
 
Rancey is 29 and will be coming back next year from a major knee reconstruction.
Do we bite the bullet now through necessity and develop Balta as our next mobile CHB? Not sure of his intercept marking but understand that a key plank to our game plan is attacking from defence. If not Balta then who, as Garthwaite looks more of an Astbury type?
Watching the VFL game on Thursday night before the mishap, I remarked to a fellow poster here how thin we are for KPD in the twos. Marsh was an ideal addition to the squad until listed by St Kilda. Don't think Miller is a long term prospect unless they can teach him to compete in the air rather than hanging back to crumb. If Garthwaite gets promoted then our key position defenders will most likely be VFL listed players like Beasley and Coffield.
 
Dont Argue said:
Rancey is 29 and will be coming back next year from a major knee reconstruction.
Do we bite the bullet now through necessity and develop Balta as our next mobile CHB? Not sure of his intercept marking but understand that a key plank to our game plan is attacking from defence. If not Balta then who, as Garthwaite looks more of an Astbury type?
Watching the VFL game on Thursday night before the mishap, I remarked to a fellow poster here how thin we are for KPD in the twos. Marsh was an ideal addition to the squad until listed by St Kilda. Don't think Miller is a long term prospect unless they can teach him to compete in the air rather than hanging back to crumb. If Garthwaite gets promoted then our key position defenders will most likely be VFL listed players like Beasley and Coffield.
it's an interesting point & we get the whole year to start the transition.
 
I wouldn’t be rushing to sign him up.
Can’t be one eyed. On what I’ve seen he is miles away.
He reminds me of Terry Keays,
 
zippadeee said:
I wouldn’t be rushing to sign him up.
Can’t be one eyed. On what I’ve seen he is miles away.
He reminds me of Terry Keays,

Terry Keays had child bearing hips. Balta is a specimen.
 
zippadeee said:
I wouldn’t be rushing to sign him up.
Can’t be one eyed. On what I’ve seen he is miles away.
He reminds me of Terry Keays,

Not sure what you have been watching but he is nothing like Terry Keays who was a 186cm undersized foward with limited pace but a good leap
played 40 games for 2 clubs and kicked 45 goals.

Happy to go out on a limb and bet that Balta atleast triples Keays games and Goals
 
turk-d-tiger said:
Not sure what you have been watching but he is nothing like Terry Keays who was a 186cm undersized foward with limited pace but a good leap
played 40 games for 2 clubs and kicked 45 goals.

Happy to go out on a limb and bet that Balta atleast triples Keays games and Goals

You will lose. We can’t delevop talls.
The ones we draft are like baby Giraffe, they struggle to stand up, they constantly fall over and remain like that all their career.
 
Need to give Balta a 2 year extension ASAP
He's only 19 and has shown enough to be offered a new contract
 
bringbakflemmo said:
Give him time folks he’s played one game so far.
He looks promising physically but remember Rancey took 3 mistake riddled years to develop into the player he is now.
Who will forget alleybabe and the Benny Hill music for Rance which was just prior to 5 consecutive AAs

Beware early calls on players like Balta
 
Happy to have him offered a 3 year $1 mil deal , would not regret it and will be a bargain in 12 months time
 
Dropped after 1 game Why?.....? :don't know :don't know
Allowed Nankervis to have a break and play forward and kick 3 goals
 
Shame to see him dropped but his contribution was modest last week and we looked top-heavy against the blues, let alone a team of runners that we will face the Pies. I think it is partly horses for courses.

Will be good to see how he goes at VFL level and if he is ready to dominate at that level.
 
I really liked his level of effort and intensity when chasing, even though it didn’t pay off. He’ll be back soon enough.
 
I find it odd. The leap of Balta against Grundy was going to be interesting.

We changed the game by going small up forward in 2017, reckon we are trying something similar in 2019 with the backs.
 
back to VFL to learn some more defensive structures and craft, its called development & I reckon its a great move.

Stop thinking for the now only, its game 2 out of 22, 23, 24 or 25