Nankervis !!

[davidc0055]

Mackay came back on so hopefully insufficient force or low impact

He should only get a week, as Mackay was clearly affected by the hit but was able to come back on.

 

[zippadeee]

Is a bloke who is on the board of football club (Ricciuto) allowed to say. "Your usually gone when do things like, aren't ya"
His commentary was disgraceful tonight. One eyed from the first minute
Dean kemp says hi. *smile*

 

[B1 and B2]

should get cleared!
Umpires are no help! should of got a free kick for holding behind play

B2

 

[Jumping Jack]

Is a bloke who is on the board of football club (Ricciuto) allowed to say. "Your usually gone when do things like, aren't ya"
His commentary was disgraceful tonight. One eyed from the first minute
Dean kemp says hi. *smile*

Was thinking the exact same thing... it was hard to listen to. What a flog.

 

[Mr T.]

Is a bloke who is on the board of football club (Ricciuto) allowed to say. "Your usually gone when do things like, aren't ya"
His commentary was disgraceful tonight. One eyed from the first minute
Dean kemp says hi. *smile*

Smug prick.

 

[TJsFurrow]

Copped a week.

 

[Mr Brightside]

Copped a week.

Was there much difference between Fyfes action, who got a fine

 

[leon]

Undeserved because he was restrained long after the ball had been cleared; although needed to keep the elbow down.

Anyway, a rest might do him good. Time to upgrade Soldo and start to see what he brings to AFL level. Think Eevan may be just past the pace of the game now.

 

[tigerlove]

Copped a week.

Probably end up being a blessing, the rest will do him good after being battered last few.

 

[LeeToRainesToRoach]

Undeserved because he was restrained long after the ball had been cleared; although needed to keep the elbow down.

Lockett sent Guy McKenna to the land of Nod when he tried it.

Have to cop the week but I hope Mackay has a sore face for a week.

 

[tigersnake]

Was there much difference between Fyfes action, who got a fine

nope.

 

[Brodders17]

i reckon we should have been looking to rest him anyway, tho i wouldve waited until the following week against Sandllands.

be interesting which Ivan comes in.

 

[zippadeee]

Maric to replace him..lol :rofl

 

[mrposhman]

Thought he would get intentional and low impact. Not sure how it could really be assessed as medium impact, Mackay definitely came back on and I don't think any blood was drawn. Very similar to Fyfes. Careless was a good outcome but I was surprised with the medium impact call. Anyone reckon we might challenge the medium impact at the tribunal? I think a low impact decision would reduce him to a fine?

 

[tigersnake]

should get cleared!
Umpires are no help! should of got a free kick for holding behind play

B2

exactly. Poor umpiring

 

[Leysy Days]

Thought he would get intentional and low impact. Not sure how it could really be assessed as medium impact, Mackay definitely came back on and I don't think any blood was drawn. Very similar to Fyfes. Careless was a good outcome but I was surprised with the medium impact call. Anyone reckon we might challenge the medium impact at the tribunal? I think a low impact decision would reduce him to a fine?

Do we risk a week if we do Posh?

 

[Mantikorr]

Thought he would get intentional and low impact. Not sure how it could really be assessed as medium impact, Mackay definitely came back on and I don't think any blood was drawn. Very similar to Fyfes. Careless was a good outcome but I was surprised with the medium impact call. Anyone reckon we might challenge the medium impact at the tribunal? I think a low impact decision would reduce him to a fine?

Fyfe got low impact and a fine, so you would assume so

 

[craig]

Week off wont hurt him, will give him a spell, hes gonna need one anyway with the lack of a chop out.

He is gonna get Ivanned if we don't look after him.

 

[mrposhman]

Do we risk a week if we do Posh?

Yep, its a 2 match ban down to 1 with an early guilty plea. What I'm not sure about is if he goes to the tribunal does he still get the early guilty plea if we win? Ie. does he have to argue to reduce to the same charge as Fyfe and therefore its 1 game down to a fine with an early guilty plea, or does he have to argue that it shouldn't be a suspension at all?

If the latter, then there is no way we will challenge it. If the former, we might do.

 

[Tigerfan]

So!!

Maric or cousin Iyvan?