At least the MRP didn't fine or suspend any of our team for making contact with the ball in last weeks game so that is a bonus!
Yeh, just serendipity that for years players have managed to get out of the way of the umps. Stevic should be demoted for his insolence.This is complete BS.
35 other players on the ground and not one other managed to touch an umpire.
The guy is a gun but a dumbarse one at that.
Reckon they take public reaction into consideration on these things, and there's enough who believe 3 weeks is about right. But if the AFL believes it was worth 6 minimum and he only got half, they are compelled to appeal. I suspect they won't.The AFL are considering an appeal.
Shades of Houli.
No love for umpires, but he was very fair at the hearing. Thought he tried his best to help GreeneYeh, just serendipity that for years players have managed to get out of the way of the umps. Stevic should be demoted for his insolence.
AFL have to do this. Its been said many times before but you just cant be running into an umpire when you are looking at him. Can guarantee Greene would not have done this if it were the female umpire.No love for umpires, but he was very fair at the hearing. Thought he tried his best to help Greene
Ok..... but where were they when Hawkins swatted the umpire away who clearly was aggrieved at the time by yelling. .."Don't touch me!"...AFL have to do this.
Ok..... but where were they when Hawkins swatted the umpire away who clearly was aggrieved at the time by yelling. .."Don't touch me!"...
And again, Neale aggressively made contact earlier this year for a *smile* weak fine!
Where was the McLachlan outrage then?
Completely agree and on the weekend there was contact with an umpire much worse than Greene's in the Bummers Doggies game.Ok..... but where were they when Hawkins swatted the umpire away who clearly was aggrieved at the time by yelling. .."Don't touch me!"...
And again, Neale aggressively made contact earlier this year for a *smile* weak fine!
Where was the McLachlan outrage then?
Agree TOO.Honestly think Greene was lucky not to get more.
Fair enough. There should have been an outcry when Neale got off with a fine with something not much less than Greene.One of the worst things about the World Game version of football is the players up in the grill of and constant pawing at the ref after a perceived wrong. This needs to be avoided at all costs.
I don't care for umpires. It should be there responsibility to get out of the way and stay out of the way. They have a function to ensure the rules as written are not breached. That's it. Too much "stay out of it", "don't do that", "let him go". Enforce a proper rule or shut up.
If a player accidentally bowls an umpire over in general play, bad luck I say. Umpire shouldn't have been in the play.
However, deliberate contact is different and should be penalised. No way Toby didn't deliberately nudge the umpire. My 2c.
Inconsistency and utter confusion are the hallmarks of the AFL.Fair enough. There should have been an outcry when Neale got off with a fine with something not much less than Greene.