Liam McBean | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Liam McBean

Leysy Days said:
Hawthorn & Geelong do both fine.

Give me the numbers and I might agree.

But fine tuning my point: even with reasonable player rotations it's going to be really hard to find space to give McBean and co a decent amount of games. Fast tracking may have stopped with Vlaustin. We could lose him and others as a result.
 
I havent seen enough of Beanie as i live abroad however based on what i have seen and reading what 165 pages of mostly demi god status, and with the club currently showing Ty he wont be gifted games, why wouldnt you put Jack back in the square with Beanie playing forward with Griff on one wing so to speak and Maric on the other (mainly rucking but break it up on zones) with the ruck being somewhat shared between Ivan and Griff.. Jack has 2 colemans out of the square and hes still mobile and young'ish..

Im of the opinion VFL basically hit as hard, yes its slower so impact may be slightly less, but hes shown enough in VFL based on goals to get a chance for some weeks, the rest is up to him!
 
My thoughts are McBean won't make it !!! He will be pushed out or traded next year ...
 
Beanie at the RFC Family Day last weekend

4417181258_funny_Jesus_statue_pointing_finger_answer_3_xlarge.jpeg
 
Interesting to see the great white hope for the Dee's last night play against the dockers his return was very similar to beanie .it will be interesting to see how they develop after being very comparable at VFL level .I 'm still a big believer in the bean .
 
He seems to me just another player who is too good for VFL but will struggle in the AFL.

I'm comparing him to JOE DANIHER ATM, same draft year similar hight but really chalk and cheese.

Good luck McBean.

B2
 
Beanie n Bazza, both next gen key forwards.. Beanie's easy got another season of pure development in him n young Bazza three or four. As Jaaack perhaps starts to creak n fade or Ty maybe struggles for form Beanie will get some limited senior games this year n maybe next. Griff covers a slightly different role as he's high forward, ruck n hole filling key defender all rolled into one, a big mobile swingman.
Beanie wants more opportunity he's gunna need to grow a body n tank n offer a tandem to Griff as the Eevan slows down, give himself another string to his bow. Jaaacks only 27 late this year so got some time to go, Eevan's turned 29 earlier this year, heading for creakiness, n Beanie turns 21 late this year. Beanie needs to find a way to bypass the Hamster n be in position to take a support / share mobile ruck combo role with the Griffinator. If Ty holds some form perhaps a threesome combination, all capable of swinging ruck / forward n at least Griff a bit of defence.

If the game swings back with slightly less rotations with the fatigue factor opening up games then the old fashioned power forward will come back into play in a big way. There's always a place for the likes of Tomahawk, Tippet, Cloke type forward beasts, a solid two or three years while building himself into an AFL player could see Bazza Mckenzie become such a type.
 
B1 and B2 said:
He seems to me just another player who is too good for VFL but will struggle in the AFL.

Would have thought a player would have needed to debut for that comparison to be made.
 
Leysy Days said:
Would have thought a player would have needed to debut for that comparison to be made.
He did last week against the Doggies, flamin mediocre DUD delist. Was even worse in his first debut game against the Dees last year, obviously kept the useless bugger a year to long, DUUUUUUUUUUD.
 
Baloo said:
Beanie at the RFC Family Day last weekend

4417181258_funny_Jesus_statue_pointing_finger_answer_3_xlarge.jpeg

Buddy Christ might have been a good nick for Beanie, Baloo. In any case you're right to remind us of the other champion full forward.
 
antman said:
Here's hoping the World's Tallest Small Forward can live up to the hype.
Sadly no chance of that happening. But he can still be a very very good elite player.
 
Tigers of Old said:
Hoping he plays again tomorrow so we can shed further light on actual performance.

Port's fielding a weaker team so it should be a bit easier for Beano to perform.