Keys is a good player. Wouldn't sell him short.Once again smashed at the contest. Midfield obliterated by bush footballers like Keys.
Keys is a good player. Wouldn't sell him short.Once again smashed at the contest. Midfield obliterated by bush footballers like Keys.
Someone is drunk at the AFL if they thought Parker had a good game.Just looked at AFL match report and they had Parker in the best, (and no not for Adelaide ).
Not great when it is our old buggers that are best of a poor lot.
Richmond: Cotchin, Vlastuin, Prestia, Parker, Edwards
Not sure discipline was an issue tonight JK with the free kicks.Sonz should have played.
We are shocking when it comes to discipline. I was really disappointed in Parker. He isn't tackling or giving us enough pressure and he couldn't hit the side of a bus today.
Not sure Ross, Aarts, Parker should play next week but it's a big ask to blood a new player like Sonz.
Some home truths
Umpiring was bad, but we are an incredibly dumb side
Nankervis has been a *smile* ruckman this year
Tarrant is slow
Riewoldt is slow and oppo runs off him at every opportunity
Cotchin played well but can only bring it once a month
Ditto Edwards
Parker is VFL
Ross is VFL
Dow is timid in the contest
Aarts is VFL
We lack forward class
Lynch is dumb and slow
Graham is dumb, VFL
Balta has a future but is dumb
Hugo has a future but can’t kick
Overall we are unskilled. Our forward connection is the worst in the comp. Our work rate is terrible. Our discipline is terrible. Our tackling is terrible.
OUT: Riewoldt, Parker, Aarts, Ross, Miller
IN: Soldo, Sonsie, Lambert, Grimes, Stack
Three to one is pretty outrageous I agree.Not sure discipline was an issue tonight JK with the free kicks.
Unless the umpiring gets better for us and/or we improve the way we play/tackle, we are gone. We tackle and never gain advantage of it.Interesting times ahead for the club.
We are staring down the barrel of a 2-4 start and a likely second straight year out of the finals. The last time that happened was a decade ago. We are likely to lose near 900 games of experience at seasons end (Riewoldt, Cotchin and Edwards) and our best and most influential player is not certainty to play again.
All this on top of rule changes that have undermined our unique game plan and the continual targeting of our fringe players by other clubs (5 alone playing in GCS vs St Kilda today!) has rendered us very average indeed.
I think we need to prepare ourselves for some difficult times…
Yep , we have 14 best 22 players turning 29 or older next year...Interesting times ahead for the club.
We are staring down the barrel of a 2-4 start and a likely second straight year out of the finals. The last time that happened was a decade ago. We are likely to lose near 900 games of experience at seasons end (Riewoldt, Cotchin and Edwards) and our best and most influential player is not certainty to play again.
All this on top of rule changes that have undermined our unique game plan and the continual targeting of our fringe players by other clubs (5 alone playing in GCS vs St Kilda today!) has rendered us very average indeed.
I think we need to prepare ourselves for some difficult times…
Agree with your last two sentences.So disappointed in today’s effort.
We are clearly the better team based on that period of intent early in Q3 but instead of running on with it we threw it away with dumb footy and skill errors.
Too many hacks in the team atm
Soldo needs to play as tap ruckman and Riewoldt no longer has a place in this side
Parker Aarts Ross never to be seen again.
Dow on notice for being timid af