Game Day - Geelong V Richmond | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Game Day - Geelong V Richmond

It's far from ridiculous. The positions are like chalk and cheese, I've played them both, although you don't really have to have played it to understand the substantial difference. Ross is an inside midfielder, we all know that. His best position is not wing, which he has by the way done admirably considering he only recently learnt the position. All Ross's best games have been in the middle.
been discussed elsewhere at length. He played well today, we can agree on that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Out of character for Stewart he seemed to show some remorse. Looked bad at the time but I don't believe he meant to take him out, accidents do happen. Remember Houli?
It was very late. I don't think any player purposely tries to knock someone out but he had ample time to pull out. Has to be a severe punishment but probably won't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I didn't and still don't buy the line that Ross was only being held back by being played out of posi. its ridiculous IMO. For a stack of reasons that have been discussed by me and others on his thread.

I'm still not sure of your point. Ross has been played on the wing as he isn't better than our 2 defensive midfielders in Cotch and Graham. Today he was given that chance due to injury and he played the role well.

What is your point exactly? That he hasn't been playing wing? That he didn't play the mid role? Or something else?
 


Try theses Cats go for 15 odd mins and ours for a lousy 6
Chris Scott feels he has to bang on and on because he doesn't really believe what he's saying. He's a fraud.

Dimma just didn't wanna be there
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7 users
I like Dimma’s comment in the presser, “We learnt something about ourselves tonight and about the opposition, and we look forward to meeting them again”.

Prestia + Cotchin together with the heat the team brought from the middle of the 2nd Qtr onward would have gotten the job done this evening.

Geelong are a good team but are no match for the X-Factor the Tiges are capable of bringing, and Scott knows it.

They can take tonight as their grand final win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10 users


Try theses Cats go for 15 odd mins and ours for a lousy 6
Scumbag praises Stewart for what he did. States it wasn't deliberate, but if he brings it up with no-one asking, it WAS deliberate. Just hides all *smile* on what really happened.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
It was very late. I don't think any player purposely tries to knock someone out but he had ample time to pull out. Has to be a severe punishment but probably won't.
Under Scott I wouldn’t be surprised they’re after any advantage also tried to get Bolton a few times
Pussies were out to belt Us in the 1st qtr
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Chris Scott feels he has to bang on and on because he doesn't really believe what he's saying. He's a fraud.

Dimma just didn't wanna be there
Just a *smile* stick of a bloke.
He is preparing his team for 6-8-10 weeks what's he going to do, when the capitulate in September again.
Talks sooo much shitt. The gutless weak media lick the bowl he is pissing in
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
Out of character for Stewart he seemed to show some remorse. Looked bad at the time but I don't believe he meant to take him out, accidents do happen. Remember Houli?
Rubbish! He‘s showing remorse coz he knows he’s missing the next 4 weeks. It was intentional, he was far away enough to avoid contact. He intentionally charged at him and took him out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8 users
I like Dimma’s comment in the press or, “We learnt something about ourselves tonight and about the opposition, and we look forward to meeting them again”.

Prestia + Cotchin together with the heat the team brought from the middle of the 2nd Qtr onward would have gotten the job done this evening.

Geelong are a good team but are no match for the X-Factor the Tiges are capable of bringing, and Scott knows it.

They can take tonight as their grand final win.
Yep, we learnt from round 1 against Carlton and turned the tables last week, we'll do the same against the Scats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
At least we got 50 games worth of experience into Ross, Ralphy, Gibbo, MoJu and Clarke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Out of character for Stewart he seemed to show some remorse. Looked bad at the time but I don't believe he meant to take him out, accidents do happen. Remember Houli?
The two incidents were nothing alike.

Stewart lined him up. It was deliberate. Houli was trying to shrug of a serial pest tagger and an errant fist hit him in the head when he wasn't even looking at him. Houli deserved his two weeks but then we got the AFL "manifestly inadequate" garbage and it was increased to 4. A complete miscarriage of justice; just unbelievable of what the AFL does to Richmond. In my decades of watching football I struggle to think of a fairer player than Houli but he was given no credence by the AFL or the media. Witch hunt to the extreme.

But you watch with Stewart. It'll be "oh he's a top bloke", "oh he's remorseful", it wasn't deliberate blah blah blah. The ironic thing he will get less than Houli did. Do you think the AFL will call it "manifestly inadequate".

But it's all good. His actions won Geelong the game so both they and the AFL are happy little campers. "*smile* Richmond" they will snigger behind their hands. Gil and Shocking and Salty and Pepper will all be circle jerking as we speak.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 11 users
Rubbish! He‘s showing remorse coz he knows he’s missing the next 4 weeks. It was intentional, he was far away enough to avoid contact. He intentionally charged at him and took him out.
That's 4 weeks that include Nth Carlton Melbourne and Port.
Geelong would be thinking Deep down it was worth knocking out prestia
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Rubbish! He‘s showing remorse coz he knows he’s missing the next 4 weeks. It was intentional, he was far away enough to avoid contact. He intentionally charged at him and took him out.
He said it reminds him of the 2020GF....there you go. Vloss incident.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Under Scott I wouldn’t be surprised they’re after any advantage also tried to get Bolton a few times
Pussies were out to belt Us in the 1st qtr
I spotted some ‘clumsy’ play from that *smile* Cameron.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 2 users
Salty doesn't believe in punitive actions. Full stop. That is what he said :rolleyes:

He knows Stewart will get rubbed out but he thinks he shouldn't. He also knows he will get half the penalty a RFC player would get for same action.

If it wasn't for Gil and Shocking he would be the biggest *smile* in the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users