Andrew 'Mini' McQualter | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Andrew 'Mini' McQualter

My theory is that the pressure was getting to Dimma after almost 14 years in the job. Remember, it took a long time to get us out of the quagmire we had been in for decades, then lift the team to the middle and eventually the top. I reckon he was stressed and tired and it rubbed off on the players.

Dimma took on a really difficult and challenging role, it was always going to be a long term project. Once they had reached the top he was probably ready to collapse from exhaustion.

McQualter is not the permanent coach, in some ways he's on a hiding to nothing, but in others he gets a certain freedom. The players look to be enjoying the game more, they look less pressured, and so does Hardwick. I reckon Hardwick is likely realising now just how much stress he has been burying for a long time and he needed and needs a fair break.

DS
Agree and hence it'd be a mistake for Hardwick to jump straight into a head coach role somewhere else in 2024. I could actually see Hardwick going to another club in a Neil Balme type role.
 
My theory is that the pressure was getting to Dimma after almost 14 years in the job. Remember, it took a long time to get us out of the quagmire we had been in for decades, then lift the team to the middle and eventually the top. I reckon he was stressed and tired and it rubbed off on the players.

Dimma took on a really difficult and challenging role, it was always going to be a long term project. Once they had reached the top he was probably ready to collapse from exhaustion.

McQualter is not the permanent coach, in some ways he's on a hiding to nothing, but in others he gets a certain freedom. The players look to be enjoying the game more, they look less pressured, and so does Hardwick. I reckon Hardwick is likely realising now just how much stress he has been burying for a long time and he needed and needs a fair break.

DS
You’re probably near the mark with your theory, however, why couldn’t McQualter be the permanent coach? Is there something you’ve observed that says he shouldn’t, or can’t be? Do you think the teams performance will tail off once again as the year goes on?

Because if we keep playing like this, and keep winning, and possibly make finals, surely he comes into serious consideration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
My theory is that the pressure was getting to Dimma after almost 14 years in the job. Remember, it took a long time to get us out of the quagmire we had been in for decades, then lift the team to the middle and eventually the top. I reckon he was stressed and tired and it rubbed off on the players.

Dimma took on a really difficult and challenging role, it was always going to be a long term project. Once they had reached the top he was probably ready to collapse from exhaustion.

McQualter is not the permanent coach, in some ways he's on a hiding to nothing, but in others he gets a certain freedom. The players look to be enjoying the game more, they look less pressured, and so does Hardwick. I reckon Hardwick is likely realising now just how much stress he has been burying for a long time and he needed and needs a fair break.

DS
Brilliantly put.
 
My theory is that the pressure was getting to Dimma after almost 14 years in the job. Remember, it took a long time to get us out of the quagmire we had been in for decades, then lift the team to the middle and eventually the top. I reckon he was stressed and tired and it rubbed off on the players.

Dimma took on a really difficult and challenging role, it was always going to be a long term project. Once they had reached the top he was probably ready to collapse from exhaustion.

McQualter is not the permanent coach, in some ways he's on a hiding to nothing, but in others he gets a certain freedom. The players look to be enjoying the game more, they look less pressured, and so does Hardwick. I reckon Hardwick is likely realising now just how much stress he has been burying for a long time and he needed and needs a fair break.

DS
That's spot on I reckon. Look at his mate Clarkson. Took a year off and came back 'refreshed' but only lasted a few months. It would have to be a real burn out job for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
That's spot on I reckon. Look at his mate Clarkson. Took a year off and came back 'refreshed' but only lasted a few months. It would have to be a real burn out job for sure.
Just on that. Very few coaches take a break and come back as good as they were. Matthews is a rare exception.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Why have most of our senior players gone from looking like they are all cooked and should all retire, to looking almost back to their very best? Is Mini that good a coach? or were they sick of listening to Dimma?

I’m finding the stark difference to the team since dimma left as bewildering.
It could have a little to do with having a fit and firing ruckman back in the team.
 
Why have most of our senior players gone from looking like they are all cooked and should all retire, to looking almost back to their very best? Is Mini that good a coach? or were they sick of listening to Dimma?

I’m finding the stark difference to the team since dimma left as bewildering.
It’s all in the head I recon. Dimma was over complicating, mini has gone back to simplifying
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
A lot of it is we aren’t missing as many easy shots at goal (see Bolton). And kicking some really tough ones. (See short)

Ross kicks truly against bombers or kamdyn kicks it to one of three open players and we are ahead of Essendon on the ladder. Sometimes it’s just one or two moments and we try to read too much into it. Melbourne was bad kicking for goal and they got a few late when it was over. (11 12 to 15 6). Then we have the human need to create a story about the outcome. Sydney we kicked ourselves out of a five goal lead and then rolled when it was obvious we’d blown it again.

Carlton no different with McKay killing a few games for them.

Personally feel we’ve been the better team other than finishing in a majority of the games this year. Finishing is worth the most though so that’s where we have improved a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Mini says he hasn't changed much in the game plan but he has got the lads believing again so has to be doing something right
IMO theres been a huge change in the game plan we dont appear to be wanting to hold onto and defend a lead at all costs Sure we defend but we also attack as we did against the Sinners we didnt go into our shell we kept attacking thats what won us the game
Congrats Mini
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
IMO theres been a huge change in the game plan we dont appear to be wanting to hold onto and defend a lead at all costs Sure we defend but we also attack as we did against the Sinners we didnt go into our shell we kept attacking thats what won us the game
Congrats Mini
and/Or King and Higgins both missed their gettable shots at goal to draw it level and tarranto kicked a crazy good banana from 40. (just watched the last quarter replay before work this morning)

(Despite us completely outplaying them / getting screwed by umpires)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Tom Morris on SEN (yeah I know, I know), but I heard him say that the odds of success from an interim coach who becomes permanent coach are very low (only Poosy succeeded at the Swans), HOWEVER, word is that Mini's situation with the players is totally different and way better with his players as Rhyce Shaw and Teague were with their players when transitioning to permanent coach.
 
Two things I'm enjoying from Mini is he's playing players in their correct position and we're playing wet weather football much better under him. We seem to have played an inordinate number of games this year in the wet, earlier in the year we were over possessing and handballing too much when it was wet, now we're kicking off the ground and moving the ball more safely. It cost us a couple of games earlier on and the change has won us a couple lately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Weird presser.
(referring to what was shown on FTA as I assume it was only a portion of it)

Mini took first 2 or 3 questions then Cotch seemed to do most of the talking.

Typical to a Gilquarters style presser you could bearly hear the questions.
Don't know if they were ALL directed to Cotch or he was steeping in and answering them.

Couple of times I actually thought he was the Coach.
Mini certainly dried up towards the end.
Spent most of it looking down and straight ahead.
If they had covered up the scoreboard you would have thought we lost.

Very strange presser.