Not sure desperation is the right term. Lots of clubs need to find types of player in the pre season and trade for them.
Blair Hartley doesn’t strike me as someone who works in a state of desperation.
We needed another tall and we targeted one who has shown some ability to play at AFL level in the past. He has also been coached by Yze and Newman before and if they thought he was a dud you would suspect they would have said so.
I am not saying he will be successful, he may or may not be. All I am saying is sometimes players thrive at new clubs and saying a player is no good just because he is let go cheap or delisted is not always the right analysis. I like to use the example of Peter Wright for big guys, kicked 50 goals in a season at Essendon and was traded for a bag of chips by the suns.
We will have to agree to differ. It was certainly desperation or something close to it.
Our forward line last year without Lynch and with Jack cooked, was the worst performed we have fielded since pre Richo.
Dima didn't have any faith in Cumberland and Dan had been sent back after his own form slipped.
Dusty was understandably distracted, following his Dad's passing, and a long dispute in regard to the (harsh) Govt position on his father's right to remain. And Shai by his own lofty standards, was patchy.
Dima himself had lost the faith and it seems now, was already planning his next move. In result our team was a bloody mess and although it stabilised after Dima's departure, our forward line made very little or no progress until late, when Balta was finally moved in.
Players we had wanted and expected to keep in Stengel and Coleman-Jones were also gone and as I said earlier, Himmelburg changed his mind, as we slipped and GWS improved. Plus money tight and very little on the market and no 1st rounder in play.
So 100,000 members and an impressive array of hard won sponsors, and we were heading towards a cliff.
No criticism of Hartley or Gale as they did well and look to have got the best result possible from a very average hand. Good luck to all.