2024 Draft Thread | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2024 Draft Thread

Yes he can for sure. The thing with Jagga is he has been the best kid for his age since age 10 and every other kid and parent has known who he is since that time. When he demands the ball other players give it to him regardless of best option or not. If he wants to run into the forward line and get in the way of the leading forward then that’s okay and probably the forwards fault!
Once he gets in an AFL program he won’t be the big man on campus and won’t get the 1-2’s he’s built his game on and will have to mould to the teams game style. Through this i feel he would automatically become more damaging as he’ll run to those positions rather than hang around getting cheapies behind the ball.
Maybe. Or is it ingrained in him to run around all game gimme, gimme, gimme I'm the figjam? Might have difficulty adjusting?
 
How many disposals did he give to Ashcroft, Smillie, moraes etc to enable them to have score involvements?
Wouldn't he be counted as being in those score involvements already, as the involvement is from being part of a chain of possessions that creates a goal???
 
A bit. He’ll need to work really hard to put some body armour on. But his strength is his running not being an in/under bull
Fiora wasn't bad at running either... and Menadue.

Gotta be able to put on size and strength if going to play in the middle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Fiora wasn't bad at running either... and Menadue.

Gotta be able to put on size and strength if going to play in the middle.

A bit. He’ll need to work really hard to put some body armour on. But his strength is his running not being an in/under bull

Both are true. But as Ross Lyon would say "don't let the narrative deceive you"

He was the best clearance and contested ball player in the match last week (and has been all year) - By a large margin.

Just because he turns a contested situation into a clean possession so easily - don't confuse that with The Bomb always getting cheap touches.

He's elite at the coalface.

The good debate on here is will that transition to the big league.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Definitely Guy Smiley for me.

I reckon Vontae O'Cotchin is a clear #1, then Guy, LL Cool J and Canelo Duckcroft are next. Currently.

Jagga in the next group along with Hotton, Reid, Lalor, Draper, Allan. Hotton could have pushed into the top 5 but might slip outside 10 now. The rest of that group can, and there's time for others.

Do you like Jagga better than Reid? Than Hotton? Not sure I do.

Watched both live and Jagga better than smilie is the hill ill die on
 
Just as an aside. Little doubt we finish ahead of West Coast. We will get on a run - likely starting tomorrow.
This is a strong possibility if we can keep (get!) footballers on the park. It made me think: if we have pick 3 or later, Vontae and Guy will be gone. For me Lombard and Ashcroft are the next best and we can't get them either. Then there's a group

The Suns might come knocking for pick 3 to get ahead of a Lombard bid. They currently hold picks 8 and 10. Would you rather Jagga or two of Lalor, Hotton, Reid, Allan, Draper/whoever else?

Or, as Jack says, trade for LDU?

Jagga better than smilie is the hill ill die on
I'm not in love with either of them.

Vontae is the only hill in this draft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Both are true. But as Ross Lyon would say "don't let the narrative deceive you"

He was the best clearance and contested ball player in the match last week (and has been all year) - By a large margin.

Just because he turns a contested situation into a clean possession so easily - don't confuse that with The Bomb always getting cheap touches.

He's elite at the coalface.

The good debate on here is will that transition to the big league.
I'd be interested in his cp/up ratio as that metric from the junior level usually translates to the next level
 
This is a strong possibility if we can keep (get!) footballers on the park. It made me think: if we have pick 3 or later, Vontae and Guy will be gone. For me Lombard and Ashcroft are the next best and we can't get them either. Then there's a group

The Suns might come knocking for pick 3 to get ahead of a Lombard bid. They currently hold picks 8 and 10. Would you rather Jagga or two of Lalor, Hotton, Reid, Allan, Draper/whoever else?

Or, as Jack says, trade for LDU?


I'm not in love with either of them.

Vontae is the only hill in this draft.
You'd hate to miss FOS!
Trade pick 3 and then he isnt drafted 1 or 2.
Tho most clubs work out who is going where, so by the time of a trade it would be an informed decision.
Lot of the season to go but the Bomb is putting runs on the board
 
This is a strong possibility if we can keep (get!) footballers on the park. It made me think: if we have pick 3 or later, Vontae and Guy will be gone. For me Lombard and Ashcroft are the next best and we can't get them either. Then there's a group

The Suns might come knocking for pick 3 to get ahead of a Lombard bid. They currently hold picks 8 and 10. Would you rather Jagga or two of Lalor, Hotton, Reid, Allan, Draper/whoever else?

Or, as Jack says, trade for LDU?


I'm not in love with either of them.

Vontae is the only hill in this draft.
Also don't forget we are up to our armpits in a points trade. Bris the best target (8 now but could drift)
Could we also trade with GCS, say Short for pick 10.

We could end up with 3, 8, 10 and 22
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Smilie for me all the way.

194cm beast midfielders that can get around the ground and then push deep into the forward line are worth gold.

Let’s not complicate things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Laylor & Langford could well be the best players to come out of this draft

Trade points for Lions pick
Trade #2 for #9 + #10

#8 , #9 , #10
Laylor , Langford , Whitlock

2nd rounders - Kako , Travaglia
 
Mick Jagga is gonna polarise people - including recruiters.
In terms of getting the ball he is the closest thing to Kevin Bartlett I have seen. And clearly he is team orientated when it comes to disposal. A good result if we get him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Laylor & Langford could well be the best players to come out of this draft

Trade points for Lions pick
Trade #2 for #9 + #10

#8 , #9 , #10
Laylor , Langford , Whitlock

2nd rounders - Kako , Travaglia
Could end up with Cox. Perkins. Reid. Not a massive return on investment as yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Laylor & Langford could well be the best players to come out of this draft

Trade points for Lions pick
Trade #2 for #9 + #10

#8 , #9 , #10
Laylor , Langford , Whitlock

2nd rounders - Kako , Travaglia
Lalor will turn out to be a very good Afl player,has all the attributes .
Give him 2 years in the system ,and he will start dominating.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Spoke to a mate - through child sports, who does a bit of scouting for another AFL club today. Said Josh Smillie was the man. Think Patty Cripps but a more mobile version
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
*smile* cheating afl. As soon as we build up some extra points to trade, in come the new rules.
It’s *smile*. Clubs have planned a strategy for this draft on the existing rules. Any changes should only come in after this year’s draft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 11 users